My father's application for compensation or pension (form 21-526) dated June, 1978 lists the following under nature and history of disabilities.
"Heart condition developed while in service in Korea has been evident ever since, causing me considerable trouble, shortness of breath, easy fatigue, chest pains, migrane headaches and nervousness. Left knee and back injury-on the job, Aug, 1969."
Report of medical examination for disability evaluation (form 21-2545) dated August, 1978 again lists the following under sec. b-medical history since latest va exam. as related by person examined.
"Heart condition developed while in service 1953-1954 while stationed in korea. Since then I have had considerable trouble with it. It has been the cause of my shortness of breath, easy fatigue, and constant chest pains,, migrane headaches and a very bad case of nervousness. In 1969 I suffered an on the job injury on my left knee and back. This injury has caused considerable trouble and discomfort since then, and has progressively gotten worse through out all these years. Feels as if an arthritic condition has developed on my entire back and left leg. My knee seems as if it is semi-stiff all the time and I am always experiencing a dull ache there."
Listed under diagnosis in medical exam.
1. No history of heart disease found. History of paroxysmal tachycardia recurring.
2.residual injury right shoulder.
3.history of injury left knee.
4. recurring l.s. muscle strain.
Statement in support of claim(form 21-4138) dated Mar, 1978 again lists the above mentioned complaints.
Rating decision dated Sept, 1978 states.
Service connection for heart condition; NSC pension.
Mr, XXXX claims disability for a heart condition, a back injury, a shoulder injury and a left knee injury. On the current examination, x-rays of the right shoulder, left knee and lumbar spine were negative. Clinically there was a moderate loss of motion of the lumbar spine. Motion of the right shoulder was limited to approximately the horizontal. No clinical findings of the left knee disability are shown. There was a non-service connected gun shot wound of the right upper thigh, the only findings were well-healed scars. blood pressure readings were within normal limits, the heart was not enlarged, there was a regular sinus rhythm and normal EKG. There was mild tachycardia. The examiner states that there was no heart disease found, and indicates a history of paroxysmal tachycardia.
We have been unable to obtain complete service medical records. However, we do have seperation examination for each period of service. These examinations show normal blood pressure readings and a heart condition is not shown either clinically or by history. Service connection is denied for a heart condition, as it is not shown in service.
Rating decision dated Nov, 1978 states.
effective date of pension benefits is granted from Dec, 2 1977.
8. NSC WW11, PTE, KC
7013. 0% Paroxysmal Tachycardia.
2. PT WW11 from 12-2-77
5201. 20% residuals, right shoulder injury
5295. 20% lumbosacral strain.
5257, 0% right knee injury, by history.
7805. 0% gsw scar, right side.
NSC COMB: 40%
Why were his complaints of migrane type headaches and a very bad case of nervousness not addressed in the medical examination for disability evaluation. Clearly these were sign and symptoms of shell shock(PTSD after 1980's). My father did receive a 100% service connected disability rating for PTSD in 2008, he died of Lymphoma in 2010. If all his medical complaints stated on his application for compensation or pension were not examined or addressed, does this constitute a clear and unmistakable error on the va's part? Would my father have received a 100% service connected disability rating 10 years prior to his death?
My father served proudly in the army from April 1946 through Oct. 1947 and from Jan 1948 to Apr, 1954. A veteran of World War ll, Korean War and peacetime.
Any thoughts or ideas welcome