This eBook will teach you how to get C-Files (paper and electronic) from the VA Regional Office.
How to Get your VA C-File


  • Topics

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      60,327
    • Total Posts
      389,702
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • New Proposed VA Reg Vets Should Know About
      Vets: I appears that the VA is proposing legislation that would require a Vet to prove an incident occurred in service first before a C & P Exam can be granted? I guess this would save the VA a pile of money from limiting CP exams  but I can't help from thinking that trying to get the claims service connected would be much more difficult. I know that the MOAA and the other Veterans Advocacy Groups are proving position papers today and there is congressional testimony starting today at 2:15 PM EST Today. Rootbeer22
    • New Proposed VA Reg Vets Should Know About
      Vets: I appears that the VA is proposing legislation that would require a Vet to prove and incident occurred in service first before a C & P Exam can be granted? I guess this would save the VA a pile of money from limiting CP exams  but I can't help from thinking that trying to get the claims service connected would be much more difficult. I know that the MOAA and the other Veterans Advocacy Groups are proving position papers today and there is congressional testimony starting today at 2:15 PM EST Today. Rootbeer22
    • Finally got my 100% for Malignant melanoma
      Sorry for your health issues, but congrats on the great news. Wish you the best, and God Bless
    • TKR; Arthritis and in service fracture
      Back to Berta...    The 2005 decision which "pre supposed" NSC (and did not order a C and P exam), seems to be a legal violation.  In other words, its equally plausable that the in service fracture caused the arthritis, then the VA needs to order a C and P exam, and not just simply deny the claim and assume there is no nexus.  
    • Knee Condition
      I feel your pain on your knees. I am having new MRIs done in the next few weeks. I am SC for both knees at 10%, and what is crazy is the VA wants to replace my R Knee due to 2 MCL/ACL surgeries, yet I am only rated at 10%. Good luck and keep us posted. God Bless!!
    • My husband died in motorcycle accident
      That's what I thought too. I read somewhere that lawyers are permitted to charge between 20% - 33%. His name is Joseph R. Moore according to my research he has won many cases for widows but if someone here could confirm that for me that would be great. I did sign a privacy act waiver and sent it to Attig Steel Law. They said they will request the cfile first, but if I get the cfile before them I can send them a copy. Wondering if I should wait on them or not. 
    • TKR; Arthritis and in service fracture
      Buck     I looked in MY SMR's, and, there is evidence of the fracture in my SMR's.  As Berta pointed out, of course I need a nexus statement, but then isnt that what a C and P exam is for?   Isnt it true that if there is evidence of a in service event, but no nexus, isnt that mean that a  C and P exam is requested to determine a nexus?  
    • TKR; Arthritis and in service fracture
      Thank you for your responses. Berta posted: "I feel that, in fact, they did adjudicate the claim, and determined it was not SC, and that itself (NSC designation) is a denial." Yes, its a form of deemed denial, where they did not give a reasons and bases for denial, and did not mention a denial.  Its a Colvin violation for VA to fail to give a reasons and bases for denial.   Since it was not formallly adjucticated, as per 38 CFR 3.103, I would posit that the claim remains pending, that is, the one year appeal period is tolled as I never received notice of the decision: 3.103 Procedural due process and appellate rights. (a) Statement of policy. Every claimant has the right to written notice of the decision made on his or her claim, the right to a hearing, and the right of representation. Proceedings before VA are ex parte in nature, and it is the obligation of VA to assist a claimant in developing the facts pertinent to the claim and to render a decision which grants every benefit that can be supported in law while protecting the interests of the Government. The provisions of this section apply to all claims for benefits and relief, and decisions thereon, within the purview of this part 3. (b) The right to notice— (1) General. Claimants and their representatives are entitled to notice of any decision made by VA affecting the payment of benefits or the granting of relief. Such notice shall clearly set forth the decision made, any applicable effective date, the reason(s) for the decision, the right to a hearing on any issue involved in the claim, the right of representation and the right, as well as the necessary procedures and time limits, to initiate an appeal of the decision.
    • Knee Condition
      I get my 10% for right knee. In all the C&P exams they have never talked to me about my pain although I tell them every time. All they ever talk about is range of motion.
    • CLAIM COMPLETE--Frm 80% to 100% Comb Rtg
      Congrats!...Why to hang in there dude

  • HadIt.com Veteran to Veteran providing FREE information and community to veterans since 1997.

    I am proud that I've been able to offer all that HadIt.com has for free for 19 years and continue to do so. HadIt.com does accept contributions to help with costs we also offer paid ad free subscriptions. None of the paid options are required. The forum, the website, news site and podcast are free and will remain so. If you choose to support the site with a contribution or a subscription it is appreciated but never required. If you choose to make a contribution or purchase an ad free subscription, you can do so here. 

Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
navyvet

Neuropathy

17 posts in this topic

I had been rated at 10% for left foot 10% for right foot 10% for upper left leg and 10% for upper right leg.

I had the required exam that found my neuropathy had worsened . The VA changed my Rating to 20% for left foot and 20 % for right foot, however there is now no rating for left and right upper.

IS THIS STANDARD ROUTINE OF THEM ?

WHAT SHOULD I DO ?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




"I had been rated at 10% for left foot 10% for right foot 10% for upper left leg and 10% for upper right leg."

this is highly irregular, and borders on the prohibition against pyramiding. the rater who did this was incorrect. probably what happened is the next rater came along and corrected the erroneous rating. he did not take anything away from you, you are still 20 percent for each lower extremity. but on the other hand, he did not give you the increase you were seeking. bottom line, it will not do you any good to try to get back a separate rating for your lower and your upper legs. won't happen. best to go after a rating for peripheral neuropathy of the left and right upper extremities. got numbness and tingling in your hands?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"I had been rated at 10% for left foot 10% for right foot 10% for upper left leg and 10% for upper right leg."

this is highly irregular, and borders on the prohibition against pyramiding. the rater who did this was incorrect. probably what happened is the next rater came along and corrected the erroneous rating. he did not take anything away from you, you are still 20 percent for each lower extremity. but on the other hand, he did not give you the increase you were seeking. bottom line, it will not do you any good to try to get back a separate rating for your lower and your upper legs. won't happen. best to go after a rating for peripheral neuropathy of the left and right upper extremities. got numbness and tingling in your hands?

I have numbness and tingling at times in left hand and the left leg is numb to the hip , maybe a little in left leg but definitely not as bad as the left. I had an Electromyography test about 3 months ago and dr said I had moderate neuropathy in feet . and noted some in upper but not as bad .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

see, neuropathy is rated as for incomplete paralysis of the peroneal nerve, which serves the leg below the knee. for neuropathy in the entire leg, it should be rated as for incomplete paralysis of the sciatic nerve, which serves the entire leg. but there should NEVER be two ratings for the same leg.

if you have numbness and tingling in your hands, put in a claim for neuropathy of the upper extremities.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
see, neuropathy is rated as for incomplete paralysis of the peroneal nerve, which serves the leg below the knee. for neuropathy in the entire leg, it should be rated as for incomplete paralysis of the sciatic nerve, which serves the entire leg. but there should NEVER be two ratings for the same leg.

if you have numbness and tingling in your hands, put in a claim for neuropathy of the upper extremities.

Somehow I have the feeling my SO is going to flip . I asked him why they did away with it and got the answer "thats what they decided" with no explaination....

I am on 1200 MG of gabupentin and it has helped but know that its only temporary .I dont have the strength in my left hand like I use to .

If they rule in my favor do you think they will assign disability for sciatic nerve instead of peroneal nerve damage ? I take it its different?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if you have a VSO, ask him for a copy of the "codesheet" from your last rating. that will show what diagnostic code your neuropathy is rated under. 8521 is the coding for the peroneal nerve. 8520 is the coding for the sciatic nerve.

if you are not coded 8520 for the left leg, and you have demonstrable neuropathy in the entire leg, submit a letter asking to be rated under the 8520 coding and explain why. (the evaluations under the sciatic nerve go higher than those for the peroneal nerve). appeal if you are turned down. that is only if you can show by objective evidence that your entire leg is involved.

numbness, tingling, decreased grip strength, and loss of fine motor coordination are hallmarks of neuropathy in the hands. if you think you qualify, make the claim. it costs you nothing to ask.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
if you have a VSO, ask him for a copy of the "codesheet" from your last rating. that will show what diagnostic code your neuropathy is rated under. 8521 is the coding for the peroneal nerve. 8520 is the coding for the sciatic nerve.

if you are not coded 8520 for the left leg, and you have demonstrable neuropathy in the entire leg, submit a letter asking to be rated under the 8520 coding and explain why. (the evaluations under the sciatic nerve go higher than those for the peroneal nerve). appeal if you are turned down. that is only if you can show by objective evidence that your entire leg is involved.

numbness, tingling, decreased grip strength, and loss of fine motor coordination are hallmarks of neuropathy in the hands. if you think you qualify, make the claim. it costs you nothing to ask.

Thank you for your insight , I will get hold of my SO and ask him . Will keep you updated .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thank you for your insight , I will get hold of my SO and ask him . Will keep you updated .

Well I talked to my SO he said my codes were 8699 and 8620 for feet . No mention of 8520 or 8521 . He also stated they said the numbness in my leg is not service connected :)

The numbness started when I was diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes , along with all the other pains .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Well I talked to my SO he said my codes were 8699 and 8620 for feet . No mention of 8520 or 8521 . He also stated they said the numbness in my leg is not service connected :)

The numbness started when I was diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes , along with all the other pains .

the 8699-8620 code makes sense (it is a variant of the 8520 code), but may not be to your advantage in the long run, because it maxes out at "moderate" incomplete paralysis. but i do not understand the reference to not being service connected for your legs. please elaborate? is your 8699-8620 service connected or not service connected? fyi, va will make no distinction between feet and legs when evaluating neuropathy. so if you are service connected for your feet, that is also considered for you legs below the knees.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
the 8699-8620 code makes sense (it is a variant of the 8520 code), but may not be to your advantage in the long run, because it maxes out at "moderate" incomplete paralysis. but i do not understand the reference to not being service connected for your legs. please elaborate? is your 8699-8620 service connected or not service connected? fyi, va will make no distinction between feet and legs when evaluating neuropathy. so if you are service connected for your feet, that is also considered for you legs below the knees.

I am a Vietnam veteran brown water navy in the Delta of Vietnam. I have Type 2 Diabetes and orignally they assigned 10% each for left and right foot and 10% for each Upper legfor Neuropathy Being caused by the Diabetes. I have no Idea why they would say its not service related now !!!

My SO told me where my Total rating had been raised he figured I would be happy with that . :) I just want whats coming to me , I don't think he understands.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I am a Vietnam veteran brown water navy in the Delta of Vietnam. I have Type 2 Diabetes and orignally they assigned 10% each for left and right foot and 10% for each Upper legfor Neuropathy Being caused by the Diabetes. I have no Idea why they would say its not service related now !!!

My SO told me where my Total rating had been raised he figured I would be happy with that . :) I just want whats coming to me , I don't think he understands.

well, i would hope your VSO is mistaken regarding the neuropathy being not service connected, since you had a rating which changed the two ten percents for each leg into a single 20 for each leg. the rater would not bother to do that if it weren't service connected. i would submit an appeal of the 20 percent for peripheral neuropathy of the left leg and explain you have it up to the hip. the 8620 diagnostic code also addresses the sciatic nerve, so you are in the right ballpark regarding that. and don't forget about a claim for the neuropathy of the hand(s).

by the way, many people find that diabetes can cause ED. VA will pay special monthly compensation for ED if it is due to diabetes. that is in addition to the compensation based on your combined evaluation. so submit a claim if it applies to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
well, i would hope your VSO is mistaken regarding the neuropathy being not service connected, since you had a rating which changed the two ten percents for each leg into a single 20 for each leg. the rater would not bother to do that if it weren't service connected. i would submit an appeal of the 20 percent for peripheral neuropathy of the left leg and explain you have it up to the hip. the 8620 diagnostic code also addresses the sciatic nerve, so you are in the right ballpark regarding that. and don't forget about a claim for the neuropathy of the hand(s).

by the way, many people find that diabetes can cause ED. VA will pay special monthly compensation for ED if it is due to diabetes. that is in addition to the compensation based on your combined evaluation. so submit a claim if it applies to you.

My Prostate Cancer got the ED before Diabetes had a chance :) They gave me that. TY

If I submit a claim for the Hands and they find they are not severely affected yet to give a rating.Will that cause me to not be able to claim it if it worsens? Like I said they are only numb and tingling sometimes .They seem normal more with the exception of the left hand not being able to grip like it use to .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"If I submit a claim for the Hands and they find they are not severely affected yet to give a rating.Will that cause me to not be able to claim it if it worsens?"

no. neuropathy is a known complication of diabetes, if you claim it they should order an exam. if they do not find enough to warrant a compensable rating separate from the diabetes, they will service connect at 0 percent and roll it in with the primary diagnosis of diabetes. that way it is service connected, and when it worsens, you have a claim for increase, not a reopened claim.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
"If I submit a claim for the Hands and they find they are not severely affected yet to give a rating.Will that cause me to not be able to claim it if it worsens?"

no. neuropathy is a known complication of diabetes, if you claim it they should order an exam. if they do not find enough to warrant a compensable rating separate from the diabetes, they will service connect at 0 percent and roll it in with the primary diagnosis of diabetes. that way it is service connected, and when it worsens, you have a claim for increase, not a reopened claim.

Does the same apply to my feet ? I know eventually they will get worse .From what I understand the Gabepentin only works for a time , then after all the dosage increases ,it stops working . I really appreciate your expertise I am still new at this. My first rating was about 4 years ago with the Prostate Cancer . Was told about AO and effects by an online friend I was playing cribbage with ,after my operation .

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OK also in answer:

I f you file a claim and they determine a 0% rating, that does NOT hinder you from filing a later claim if the condition worsens, in fact I would think it would help, since service-connection and diagnosis is already established.

Neuropathy is a normal "secondary" issue with type II diabetes, or diabetes period. So if they have already granted service connection for the diabetes, or even if its pending, filing for neuropathy in the limbs is totally normal "secondary" to the diabetes.

Look at entropents post... he is dead on. Just follow his direction. Also, I have been taking neurontin/gabapentine for 6 years, and if I DONT take it, it is very very obvious that it is still working. So, while your body may "acclimatize" to the neurontin, it has been MY (opinion here) experience that it keeps working, you just may need a slightly higher dosage eventually.

Also, again I think your VSO is... less than ideal. Perhaps you might think of going to another organization, or even better (as you are obviously doing) handle it yourself... thats honestly the best way in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
OK also in answer:So I should appeal their decision and add a new claim for my hands at the same time ?

If I do this and my SO doesnt agree with me , how do I go about getting someone else to represent me? Di I formally have to write my SO and ask to be released from his office ? I'm not sure how to go about this properly , I don't want to ruffle any feathers.

I f you file a claim and they determine a 0% rating, that does NOT hinder you from filing a later claim if the condition worsens, in fact I would think it would help, since service-connection and diagnosis is already established.

Neuropathy is a normal "secondary" issue with type II diabetes, or diabetes period. So if they have already granted service connection for the diabetes, or even if its pending, filing for neuropathy in the limbs is totally normal "secondary" to the diabetes.

Look at entropents post... he is dead on. Just follow his direction. Also, I have been taking neurontin/gabapentine for 6 years, and if I DONT take it, it is very very obvious that it is still working. So, while your body may "acclimatize" to the neurontin, it has been MY (opinion here) experience that it keeps working, you just may need a slightly higher dosage eventually.

Also, again I think your VSO is... less than ideal. Perhaps you might think of going to another organization, or even better (as you are obviously doing) handle it yourself... thats honestly the best way in my opinion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Im not sure if I am rated correctly or not for feet.

These are my sympthons

1 . Foot pain burning throbbing both feet

2. leg pain both legs below the knee

3.left foot tends to drag sometimes causing me to almost stumble

4.have a hard time navigating on uneven ground

5.balance is not what it use to be (I use to walk on rocks along the cape cod canal to fish , now I have a problem fishing there at all.

6.pain from left knee , up the back of leg and thigh to lowerback

7.sometimes have tingling in fingers left hand and numbness sometimes

8.strength of left hand not what it use to be

9. sometimes have pain in finger joints

DOES THIS ADD UP TO 20% EACH FOOT?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0