This eBook will teach you how to get C-Files (paper and electronic) from the VA Regional Office.
How to Get your VA C-File


  • Topics

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      60,355
    • Total Posts
      389,902
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Next claim going down range finally
      Hamslice..  IMHO, They don't need anything further from you or anyone else.  This is just a catch all statement that they perhaps forgot to type: "NONE"...  
    • Next claim going down range finally
      Update number 2 (cont) I see on My HealthyVet, I have 2 C&P's coming up in June, IM COMP & PEN IM RAD ULTRASOUND Oh, boy, Hamslice
    • Next claim going down range finally
      Update number 2, Went to "Gathering Evidence" today, and they moved up my completion dates to 8/28/16-11/07/2016.  Was in 2017 before. Heres my favorite; Needed from others (1) "These are requests for documents that VA has asked others to provide. Here are two actions you can take to speed up the processing of your claim: If you have access to these documents, you can upload them here on this page. Ask the person or organization in possession of your documents to immediately provide them to VA. To mail documents to your nearest VA Regional Office (VARO), search VA's online VARO directory."   It would be nice to know what they are looking for. I might be able to help! Fun with claims, Hamslice  
    • Veterans First Act
      Right on Hamslice. This is a perfect opportunity to contact your representative before this becomes a law. Ask some friends to do the same. We still have a chance to do something about this. It's go time people-
    • Awaiting BVA Remand for R-2
      It's not that easy. I do not have your c-file. I know nothing about the hx of the claim. Is the bowel or bladder incontinence part and parcel of a SC disease? If so, yes. Remember, there are no time limits on SMCs. The moment you demonstrate your entitlement, be it five or fifteen years ago, that is the date of SMC. I suggest you Private Message me to discuss it.
    • I think I made VA mad
      Are you military retired?  If so what percentage are you at.  I know my husband had to do the admin review, when he hit 50 %. Because there has to be an audit,. And it takes awhile.
    • Just got my C&P letter, what to expect?
      You have to let us know what you are claiming for us to help. Example, PTSD, I don't have and have not been examined for it, so I could not help you there, others would. Also, no drug test that I know of. Hamslice Might want to take a break from the pipe the night before, just saying...  
    • Veterans First Act
      Its all about the money. They use dates to deny and exclude. Its never the intent of the legislation, but, they celebrate when it gets passed, even though some get shorted by dates. My two favorites are; The bill that lets reservists retire a day for a day in combat earlier than age sixty after 9/11.  Sounds great, hurray!!, But, only for those vets that served in combat after Jan 1, 2008.  WTF. And, a recent CBO calculation reports that only 20% of reservists take there retirement pay at age 60, so it is not a worthwhile program and no need to have them get thier retirement any earlier.  Thats because the other 80% are dead.  Thats my favorite right there. Anyway, Hamslice  
    • Should I file a CUE or leave NOD in place?
      The YouTube link should be on this thread.
    • My husband died in motorcycle accident
      The 10% could have been appealed by the spouse but it wasn't. The only factual info here is that he died at 10% SC for PTSD and that he died in a motorcycle accident. I see no way the 10% can be raised. This is one of the most difficult DIC claims I have seen in over 20 years.Actually THE most difficult. It is way too soon to even suggest that she will succeed on this claim. I am concerned that reckless behavior due to PTSD can also be deemed as willful misconduct...just search DIC  misconduct at the BVA to find our what I mean. Search DIC Insanity as well....DIC has been awarded due to insanity in PTSD vets because that is what caused their demise. If he had a documented History of flashbacks,and visual hallucinations solely due to PTSD, like my husband did,  that would be different.   We don't even know if the VA will extend the time frame for her.    

  • HadIt.com Veteran to Veteran providing FREE information and community to veterans since 1997.

    I am proud that I've been able to offer all that HadIt.com has for free for 19 years and continue to do so. HadIt.com does accept contributions to help with costs we also offer paid ad free subscriptions. None of the paid options are required. The forum, the website, news site and podcast are free and will remain so. If you choose to support the site with a contribution or a subscription it is appreciated but never required. If you choose to make a contribution or purchase an ad free subscription, you can do so here. 

tom91

Privileges Due To Disability

14 posts in this topic

According to the VA website, a vet must be rated 100% in order to obtain an ID card for PX privileges; however, it seems when I was discharged for disabilities in 1991, the army would base it upon 30%+. Does anyone have any further information?

Also, if my claim is approved and found to be an error back to 1991, it would have been a 30% rating at that time. If I'm correct on ID priv @30%+, will they honor that privilege now or deny it since the VA guidelines is 100%. It by all means is not the first priority with this claim but certainly curious.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




This is just an educated guess but they would retire those with 30% or more disability and as a retiree you would get a retirees ID card, allowing you access to base activities.

pr

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you were MEB'd out of service you are considered retired. Your Exchange benefit is a result of the Military, The VA is a different issue.

If you are a 100 percent P and T vet, then you are considered disabled from being in the seervice.

J

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I got 30% from the VA after I ets'd in 94. I got a ID card, but it was for a limited time. One year, I think.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There are only three ways to get a Military Id after leaving service.

1.) you must be retired with length of service

2.) you must be medically retired from your branch of service with at least 30% disability

3.) you must be rated 100% schedular or TDIU from the va and it must be a permanent rating.

If you are rated 30% from the va you are not entitled to, nor will the military issue you an ID card, not even on a temporary basis.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If you were MEB'd out of service you are considered retired. Your Exchange benefit is a result of the Military, The VA is a different issue.

If you are a 100 percent P and T vet, then you are considered disabled from being in the seervice.

J

Your statement is a little misleading ....

Being medicallly boarded out of service does not qualify anyone for an ID card. Service Medical boards award disability based on the severity of the medical problem, the rating can be 0 -100% just like the va. Any service member that is awarded 30% or more from their branch of service is considered retired and receives the ID card.

Sometimes the service will assign a member to the temporary disabled retired list and that person will retian his ID card, and receive 50% of his base pay, for no longer than five years. At the end of five years or eairler, the veteran will be placed on the permanent disabled retirement list with a permanent rating of 30% or higher, be discharged with 205 or less, or be call back to active duty.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah Teac I left the 30 percent off. Anyway a MEB retirement is not the same as a VA retirement.

The VA will re rate it anyway. Usually at a lower percentage.

Thanks for clarfying that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You know what...after I thought about it, the wife and I got the ID cards (tan) while I was outprocessing from Ft. Bragg, not after I ets'd. I didn't get out on a MEB, either. Why did we get the cards? I probably still have them somewhere...dangit! now I gotta go look for them :angry:

EDIT: just asked the wife and she knows exactly where the cards are, but it's too late to go digging around in the basement. She said we had PX and commissary privileges for a year after I ets'd.

Edited by rentalguy1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

When I got out, after my regular 4 year enlistment, I was issued a Reserve ID identification card. I went on to the base at Long Beach, Ca., but never went to the comstore or the base store. The Reserve card was for 2 years.

Edited by Stretch

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Just to clarify further on my question....

If the VA determines I should have been MEB @30% and therefore, should have received additional privileges at that time (such as ID), do they do anything retro about that? Although my case is still remains outstanding, this may be the case with me. Seems unfair to us all if the government doesn't make it all right when an error occurs that is beyond our control. Yeah they pay backpay but what about the other items?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Forgot to make mention that I located the information on what a soldier receives currently if they are discharged medically. It seems to remain the same as what I recall from 91. The ID card is not something temporary if you get 30%+. I also received an ID temporarily for 2 years since I got out @20%......................

Info is located under ARMYBenefits.com

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Just to clarify further on my question....

If the VA determines I should have been MEB @30% and therefore, should have received additional privileges at that time (such as ID), do they do anything retro about that? Although my case is still remains outstanding, this may be the case with me. Seems unfair to us all if the government doesn't make it all right when an error occurs that is beyond our control. Yeah they pay backpay but what about the other items?

To my knowledge The va does not have any authority to change the percentage that the military awarded to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Teac, I suggest you find the regs related to the VA rating. The military does not use the same criteria.

The VA will and can rate a disability according to its own criteria. If that rating is lower than the MED, Then the Vet may be SOL. The VA does not consider the Military rating. Only what is in the Title 38 part 4..

J

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Teac, I suggest you find the regs related to the VA rating. The military does not use the same criteria.

The VA will and can rate a disability according to its own criteria. If that rating is lower than the MED, Then the Vet may be SOL. The VA does not consider the Military rating. Only what is in the Title 38 part 4..

J

And I suggest you re-read what I stated, which was, " the va does not have the authority to change the percentage that the Military awarded you."

I was rated at 30% from the Army. The va rated me at 100%. The va rating does not change the rating from the Army, and the Army's rating is still valid. One has nothing to do with the other, and I never in any why said that they did.

Also;

1. The va must consider the rating the military awarded, it does not have to agree but it still must be considered because it is a part of the medical record.

2. When I was rated by the Army over 20 years ago the Army and the VA used the same exact Critera and rating schedule to rate me. Until recently that was the case, now the va awards all disability ratings to include those by a MEB board. This was changed by congress because the services where lowballing awards...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now