• Topics

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
    • Most Online

    Newest Member
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
  • Posts

    • Thank you Vync for the warm welcome and reply. The addendum was made by the C & P examiner, but 10 weeks later. They are saying my progression is the typical rate of progression for my spine issues, therefore not related. That leaves me unsure if I should appeal this or claim it as chronic low back pain. I have several records to support as such. Also, when the examiner quoted my angles they were much lower than anything sound. A spinal curve doesn't shrink and then exaggerate again a few years later.    
    • Okay everyone, I have been MIA for a few days to try and collect myself.  I received a call from my Women's advocate at the local VA who can see my file.  I am beyond upset and just deflated.  The DRO Steve Wilbur held true to his reputation.  He called me on August 18th, 2016 to tell me he was going to decide my NOD within the week, but he actually lied to me because he decided it that day.....DENIED!!!  To further more upset me, my claim has so many errors from the beginning of the original decision to today's decision.  We went over everything on the phone and we found so many errors.  I am going to wait for the SOC so that I get the Form 9.  At first I said "F" it and I was going to give up and just apply for my right foot secondary to my left ankle but I thought about it and the more and more I did, the more and more I got so pissed off!   Over the weekend another Veteran and I spoke on the phone.  He too had the same DRO, Steve Wilbur and was denied on the same day as me.  The other interesting thing....my boyfriend received his SOC in the mail for his denial on the same day and guess who was the DRO????  Yep, Steve Wilbur.... Apparently Steve Wilbur has a very bad reputation in WACO.  I was told by this veteran that his attorney is heading there today to raise hell over this situation.  I emailed Robert McDonald for what it is worth too.  Both of us had solid evidence to overturn the original decisions.  I feel we were both retaliated due to the fact that we emailed Robert McDonald a few weeks ago for an update.  This is devastating and now I have years of waiting because of Steve Wilbur. When I was on the phone with my rep at the VA, she was reviewing the notes and Steve Wilbur has so many mistakes noted on my SOC.  One issue is the fact that my original C&P exam from July 2013, the examiner gave NO RATIONALE, however several months later, a medical opinion was given by a doctor who NEVER saw me but rather took a quick glance of my documents and denied me even after the fact that the examiner from the C&P exam noted both my DBQ's from my podiatrist and stated my injuries were in-service.  Furthermore, I had the letter from my current podiatrist stating all my injuries were in-service. So disappointed but I will continue to fight this!
    • Welcome to Hadit! Was the addendum made by the C&P examiner, a non-C&P doctor, or possibly someone working at the VARO? How long after service did they claim the condition progressed after service?    
    • With the 100% P & T decision the VA should have mentioned or enclosed the Chapter 35 applications for your dependents.They usually send the Chapter 35 pamphlet as well, which is linked below.   The dependents are also eligible for CHAMPVA  which also can be searched for here.I dont know how VA informs vets these days of their dependent's potential for CHAMPVA  in 100% P & T awards. As I recall I received a VA letter advising me on CHAMPVA and that has to be applied for.The letter was separate from the 100% P & T posthumous award that included Chap 35 apps for me and my daughter.More info here. http://www.benefits.va.gov/gibill/docs/pamphlets/ch35_pamphlet_2.pdf   http://www.va.gov/vaforms/medical/pdf/vha-10-10d-fill.pdf http://www.va.gov/purchasedcare/programs/dependents/champva/      
    • @Bonzai Great to see you!!!  Have you checked out http://www.disabledveterans.org I think it will helpful in your fight for Voc Rehab. We have had a lot of complaints about Voc Rehab so do keep us posted on your progress. You may even want to think about starting your own blog about it. That will give you something to do. I did it and here we are 20 years later. About a blog, you can use your photographs and your wive's to illustrate your posts. It might just turn out to be your thing.


70% Ptsd / Tdiu / P&t

13 posts in this topic

Dear HadIt.Com;

I just received a letter from the VARO-St. Paul, MN stating that they are scheduling another/new C&P Examination for me. I was rated P&T on May 30, 2002; and the rating report stated that there would be no future examinations scheduled.

Why am I now receiving this letter? Does anyone know why there are service-connected examinations being scheduled for P&T awardees?

I am also in the Philippines, so will the VARO require that I take this exam at the VAMC-Hawaii or here in VA-Manila Outpatient Clinic?

Any comments, information, or suggestions are welcome. Please advise!

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Unfortunately with the VA; nothing is "P&T". From what I've heard if they schedule exams, even when your initial letter said "no further exams" it is usually after the first 10 years.

Have you reported any income to the VA? or to Social Security? if yes, either one of those would tip them off.

Has your condition improved? That could tip them off.

It could be a number of things....I try not to think like the VA does; it gives me migraines....

take care & good luck,

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Don't sweat it. If your disabilities are static it will be a simple review.

More that likely they will schedule the exam in Manilla.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

You need to find out what reason they are requiring an exam when you are P&T. Some Doc must have given a rosy report on you and they are checking on it.

If you have not improved than you have nothing to worry about

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

The VA is required by law to periodically examine all of our files. It's been several years since you've had a C&P, so that's why they are bringing you in. The only truly permanent rating is the one that has been in place for 20+ years. All others are subject to change. The good news here is that your rating has been in place for over 5 years, so that means it cannot be reduced based on a single C&P exam. Sustained improvement of the condition(s) must be shown through two or more exams. I would suggest clicking the link to the Mental Health Claim Repository in my signature line and reading up on what the exam entails and what the rating criteria are. Then go to the exam as requested.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

You didn't say if you had any other claims pending, or had anything on appeal perhaps for an earlier effective date. If you do, then it's common to be called in for a C & P to examine you based on your claim or appeal.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now