Ad free subscription.


This eBook will teach you how to get C-Files (paper and electronic) from the VA Regional Office.
How to Get your VA C-File




  • Topics

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      60,113
    • Total Posts
      388,051
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Code Sheet
      Question >Meddac. If I apply a a claim for S.A...or OSA. Secondary to my  PTSD 70% SC Claim Would VA concider that an Increase? As to which my present rating is 100%  TDIU P&T on First Disability & have the PTSD 70% statuatory rating of a SMC-S- 1 H.B   ...........Thanks in Advance ........................Buck
    • service connection granted
      Lawyer just called granted service connection for tbi and All residuals. Now i have remanded a small issue which was my skull fracture which I have plenty off xrays from my accident. Thank you all for all your advice my appeal off I officially in less then 5 months. I annoyed allot of people in my way to this grant and I apologize I still dont know what this means yet but maybe someone can chime in please?
    • Code Sheet
      Are they (D.A.V.) Not supposed to give them out if you have a claim going? or what about a claim that's been adjudicated  and the veteran needs the codes to see what they rated...from? I went to D.A.V. Today at 10:00am sign in and sit there until 10:45 and Had to go to my Eye clinic at 11:00  ...was finished with the Eye clinic at 11:40  rushed back to the D.A.V. Office and they closed up early    they close at 12:00 on Thrusdays.    damn it. eh!
    • Denied Sleep Apnea Claim
      I got my letter from IMO, in the letter he stated I had prehypertension while in the military, that my records showed I had gone in for fatigue, and that my ex-wife had complained about my heavy snoring while in the military. He also stated that even though I was only recently diagnosed with SA in 2015 which was 20 years after I retired. He finished the letter that with the conditions he mentioned in the letter that more likely than not I had SA while in the military with the conditions mentioned in his letter. I will submit this his letter along with the wife from my ex-wife as well as a letter from my daughter basically stated how the ex-wife complained about me snoring all night long. I am also submitting a letter from my housekeeper when I worked in Moscow just a few years ago. She also complained about my snoring being so loud and she was down the hall in her own room. I am not sure how the VA will rate whether or not the SA is SC, I guess I will find out soon enough. I just wanted to give an update and as soon as I hear from the VA I will post the results here.
    • Dr. Bash really cares
      I paid Dr. Bash to do 7 IMEs for me. He did them all with great attention to detail. The VA ordered me 4 c&p examinations based on Dr Bashs ime's. Unfortunately the VA never notified me of these pending c&p examinations, so I never attended them. The VA then closed my claim and had a VA dr give his reasoning on all contentions as to why I was denied.   Every ime dr bash wrote, this dr gave reasoning as to why it was denied. Often he admitted that there was reasoning for service connection but still denied. I feel that if I had been properly notified of my c&p exams and attended I would have likely been service connected. In great disapointment, I contacted Dr Bash to let him know how the VA had screwed me on the c&p exams and how they had their VA dr try to disprove everything dr Bash had said in his IMEs.   I expected nothing other than to let Dr Bash know how everything went down.   As far as I was concerned the ime's he did for me were top notch and it was simply the VA screwing me. Dr bash only asked me how much I had paid him 8 months prior and what our goal was.   I told him the dollar amount that I had paid him and told him how our initial goal was to go from 70% to 100%   Dr Bash to me to be strong and that more help was coming. He never asked for any money and only asked that I sent him everything the va Dr had said in my BBE denial letters.   To my surprise I sent Dr Bash everything and just a few weeks later Dr Bash sent me a 13 page letter that went toe to toe with everything the VA dr has discredited and showed how the VA Dr had cued himself in instances and also how Dr Bash's opinion had more weight via his extensive experience. I dont know whats gonna happen, but I do know that Dr Bash is a very busy man and had already been paid for his agreed upon services that he delivered. For Dr Bash to write another 13 page letter to combat the VA not only gives me more bullets for this battle, but shows that he truly cares about Veterans being treated fairly and takes great pride in his job.   I highly recommend Dr. Bash for anyone contemplating his services.    
    • NOD
      New to the board, question about action after NOD received. My NOD was received two months ago but no appeal has been opened. Is this normal for a regional office to delay opening an appeal? Thanks in advance for responses.
    • Extraschedular IU?
      Years ago back in 2002  I was 50% Ask for increase& C&P was blown out of the water  NOD a proposal to reduce b/c an idiot VA Examiner...Had DRO  Hearing at RO, DRO gave me an increase of 50%  making me 100% and since I could not work he expedited  my claim to TDIU P&T  Disability as in Nature with no Future exams, Effective upon receipt.   just last year I filed a claim in for PTSD and was awarded  70% Rating and this time they awared me SMC S-1 H.B. AT 170% Rating but still consider at 100% rating....even if a veteran is awared SMC's  he/she is still considered 100% but get paid a higer comp according to the SMC Disability's   .......................Buck Right now with spouse  I get 3.415.92
    • New Va Pain Medication Policy
      I'm going to kinda change the subject here but it has to do with pain meds. Pain medications only work for so long before they actually quit working. No matter how much they increase, and the more they increase, the less they will work on you. Remember they only work in the brain at the nerve endings. Most people's best bet is to do what I did, I was first on Oxycodone and then PM switched me over to Morphine SR and MOrphine IR. A week ago I asked my PM doctor to please take me off the MorphineS because they just were not working anymore because the VA has kept me on the lowest dose now for 3 years. See once a year they should increase the dosages but they haven't been doing this. So I asked to go back to Tramadol 100mgs 3 times a day so what he did is keeping me on the Morphine SR and prescribed Tramadol 50mgs 4 times a day. I am doing this to DETOX my body as I feel its toxicity levels are high because of the pain and other meds I take. You have to do this, its a must. I am a bit time Christian but I do believe in cannabis as a natural pain reliever and whenever they get it squared away here in Florida I am switching over to that. First I will try the Charlotte's strain which has very, very low THC but normal levels of cannabis which is what we need to relieve our pain. If I have to fly to Denver to test it out for a weekend I will just to see if the Charlotte's strain does what they say its doing for people in pain. No smoking it just eat a little bit of it as you get more in digestion than smoking it. I watched a ex-police officer taking this as he has some type of disease that causes pain in his legs. He said it works. I believe the FEDS are in fact hiding the truth from people about cannabis because they have Patent on it for Neurological reasons!!! Think about it, why would they have a Patent on it? Secondly how can a government put a patent on something they didn't create?

  • HadIt.com Veteran to Veteran providing FREE information and community to veterans since 1997.

    I am proud that I've been able to offer all that HadIt.com has for free for 19 years and continue to do so. HadIt.com does accept contributions to help with costs we also offer paid ad free subscriptions. None of the paid options are required. The forum, the website, news site and podcast are free and will remain so. If you choose to support the site with a contribution or a subscription it is appreciated but never required. If you choose to make a contribution or purchase an ad free subscription, you can do so here. 

68mustang

Research On Meniere's Disease

5 posts in this topic

Berta

I have been doing research on the internet about Meniere's disease. I have found some medical abstracts and reports that state what causes it and some state that the causes are unknown. I don't know much about medical treatises, but are medical abstracts and reports considered treatises?

Acoustic trauma is stated in some of the abstracts and reports as a cause of Meniere's Disease. There is a book that states one of the causes of Meniere's Disease is acoustic trauma.

I am already rated at 10% for tinnitus, which was diagnosed as having been caused by acoustic trauma while working both in US Navy ships' boiler rooms and engine rooms.

How can this information be used if my claim is denied for hearing loss and Meniere's Disease, which were diagnosed by the exam specialist contracted by the VA. If anyone else has any input to provide please do so. Thanks.

68mustang

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites







Medical treatises and abstracts are basically the same thing- the abstracts are usually a condensed version of a treatise.

I would think with your MOS (as long as the VA understands how this put you into acoustical trauma) would certainly make them consider an award for hearing loss if there is no other possible etiology and that the Meneriere's could be rated as SC as well.But I am assuming that there is someting in your SMRs or discharge certificate to support the claim you have.

Then again this vet was denied for hearing loss in this lengthy BVA case-

he also had Meniere's too.

His Discharge Physical revealed no hearing problems and apparently his SMRs didnt either:

http://www.va.gov/vetapp07/files1/0706913.txt

In part:

"The veteran submitted an August 1994 report for the Social

Security Administration (SSA), from a private ENT doctor,

M.B, M.D. Dr. M.B. reported that the veteran appeared to

suffer from Meniere's disease that resulted in a disabling

bilateral sensorineural hearing loss and a fluctuating type

of dizziness. Dr. M.B. indicated that the veteran had 80 to

90 percent hearing impairment, and that he first succeeded

the threshold (presumably SSA's threshold) of hearing

impairment in March 1993, and that his hearing had worsened

since that time. The veteran claimed in a letter received in

April 1997 that Dr. M.B.'s findings were rendered exclusively

from VA medical records."

and

"In November 1997, the same ear disease examiner who conducted

the VA examination in December 1996, rendered an addendum.

The VA examiner noted that the claims file was made available

a week prior to the date of the dictated report. The

examiner noted that the limited service medical records made

no mention of hearing loss, tinnitus or inner ear

difficulties, and that the January 1957 examination whispered

voice and the audiometer recording indicated normal hearing.

he examiner stated that while it was reasonable to argue that

the amount and type of noise exposure the veteran experienced

in service might have resulted in some hearing loss or

tinnitus, it was in no way imaginable that the experience

would relate to his later progression of hearing loss and

tinnitus, and the presently described balance difficulties.

It was the examiner's conclusion that, based upon the service

record, the veteran's present difficulties could not be

causally related to his period of active military service."

Denied-this just goes to show how adversarial the VA can be.

The veteran was an AAA gun mechanic and obviously exposed to inservice acoustical trauma.He had internet abstracts and buddy statements but the BVA held that nothing appearded at all in his SMRs for HL (or Menieres) and denied the claim.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Medical treatises and abstracts are basically the same thing- the abstracts are usually a condensed version of a treatise.

I would think with your MOS (as long as the VA understands how this put you into acoustical trauma) would certainly make them consider an award for hearing loss if there is no other possible etiology and that the Meneriere's could be rated as SC as well.But I am assuming that there is someting in your SMRs or discharge certificate to support the claim you have.

Then again this vet was denied for hearing loss in this lengthy BVA case-

he also had Meniere's too.

His Discharge Physical revealed no hearing problems and apparently his SMRs didnt either:

http://www.va.gov/vetapp07/files1/0706913.txt

In part:

"The veteran submitted an August 1994 report for the Social

Security Administration (SSA), from a private ENT doctor,

M.B, M.D. Dr. M.B. reported that the veteran appeared to

suffer from Meniere's disease that resulted in a disabling

bilateral sensorineural hearing loss and a fluctuating type

of dizziness. Dr. M.B. indicated that the veteran had 80 to

90 percent hearing impairment, and that he first succeeded

the threshold (presumably SSA's threshold) of hearing

impairment in March 1993, and that his hearing had worsened

since that time. The veteran claimed in a letter received in

April 1997 that Dr. M.B.'s findings were rendered exclusively

from VA medical records."

and

"In November 1997, the same ear disease examiner who conducted

the VA examination in December 1996, rendered an addendum.

The VA examiner noted that the claims file was made available

a week prior to the date of the dictated report. The

examiner noted that the limited service medical records made

no mention of hearing loss, tinnitus or inner ear

difficulties, and that the January 1957 examination whispered

voice and the audiometer recording indicated normal hearing.

he examiner stated that while it was reasonable to argue that

the amount and type of noise exposure the veteran experienced

in service might have resulted in some hearing loss or

tinnitus, it was in no way imaginable that the experience

would relate to his later progression of hearing loss and

tinnitus, and the presently described balance difficulties.

It was the examiner's conclusion that, based upon the service

record, the veteran's present difficulties could not be

causally related to his period of active military service."

Denied-this just goes to show how adversarial the VA can be.

The veteran was an AAA gun mechanic and obviously exposed to inservice acoustical trauma.He had internet abstracts and buddy statements but the BVA held that nothing appearded at all in his SMRs for HL (or Menieres) and denied the claim.

Thanks Berta for the response.

The veteran really got the short end of the stick. If I read it correctly none of the veterans' personal medical providers stated that his problems were more likely than not caused by his military service. The VA did everything possible to evade the issue of service connection by using his recreation gunfire exposure .

The following web site has the report on the congressionally mandated study by the Institute of Medicine assessed noise-induced hearing loss and tinnitus associated with military service from World War II to the present, the effects of noise on hearing, and the availability of audiometric testing data for active duty personnel.

It states that whisper tests were not reliable to assess hearing loss yet the VA

will use the military services administration of whisper test to say a veteran had no hearing loss at separation. There is a lot of info in the report, which can be read for free.

68mustang

http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?record_id=11443

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

68,

I resently got my rating for Peripheral Vestibular Disorder at 30%. The rater based it on an ENT C&P stating that it was related to SC acoustic trama. C&P doc says no Meniere's based on range of frequency for hearing loss. Regular ENT says possible Meniere's. The 30% rating is top for PVD but is an accurate reflection of the disability to me so I left it there. I could probably fight to have it rated as analogous to Meniere's for a higher rating but in my case I don't feel that is warranted.

The link between acoustic trama and Meniere's is a little tenuous right now. ENTs argue both ways. Good Luck to you and if I find anything that looks handy I will post it.

Mark

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
68,

I resently got my rating for Peripheral Vestibular Disorder at 30%. The rater based it on an ENT C&P stating that it was related to SC acoustic trama. C&P doc says no Meniere's based on range of frequency for hearing loss. Regular ENT says possible Meniere's. The 30% rating is top for PVD but is an accurate reflection of the disability to me so I left it there. I could probably fight to have it rated as analogous to Meniere's for a higher rating but in my case I don't feel that is warranted.

The link between acoustic trama and Meniere's is a little tenuous right now. ENTs argue both ways. Good Luck to you and if I find anything that looks handy I will post it.

Mark

Thanks mitchell3006 for responding. I have to wait to see what the VA's QTC contract specialist notes in his report. After the examination he stated that I had Meniere's Disease, but did not state whether it was or not cause by the type of military job I did. I am rated for tinnitus at 10%.

There are medical abstracts that state that the cause of Meniere's is unknown and then there are some that state acoustic trauma is the cause. Some state that Meniere's may develop many years after exposure to acoustic trauma. There are also VA decisions where veterans have been awarded compensation for Meniere's that began many years after military service because of the jobs that they did in the military. Plus there are also many where compensattion has been denied because Meniere's did not show up until many years later.

The web site that I put in my earlier post has very good info about noise and military service. And how noise can lead to hearing loss and tinnitus many years later after exposure to noise in the military.

I will continue to post info on hearing loss,tinnitus, and Meniere's Disease that I find that could be helpful. Thanks again.

68mustang

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now