This eBook will teach you how to get C-Files (paper and electronic) from the VA Regional Office.
How to Get your VA C-File


  • Topics

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      60,327
    • Total Posts
      389,702
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • New Proposed VA Reg Vets Should Know About
      Vets: I appears that the VA is proposing legislation that would require a Vet to prove an incident occurred in service first before a C & P Exam can be granted? I guess this would save the VA a pile of money from limiting CP exams  but I can't help from thinking that trying to get the claims service connected would be much more difficult. I know that the MOAA and the other Veterans Advocacy Groups are proving position papers today and there is congressional testimony starting today at 2:15 PM EST Today. Rootbeer22
    • New Proposed VA Reg Vets Should Know About
      Vets: I appears that the VA is proposing legislation that would require a Vet to prove and incident occurred in service first before a C & P Exam can be granted? I guess this would save the VA a pile of money from limiting CP exams  but I can't help from thinking that trying to get the claims service connected would be much more difficult. I know that the MOAA and the other Veterans Advocacy Groups are proving position papers today and there is congressional testimony starting today at 2:15 PM EST Today. Rootbeer22
    • Finally got my 100% for Malignant melanoma
      Sorry for your health issues, but congrats on the great news. Wish you the best, and God Bless
    • TKR; Arthritis and in service fracture
      Back to Berta...    The 2005 decision which "pre supposed" NSC (and did not order a C and P exam), seems to be a legal violation.  In other words, its equally plausable that the in service fracture caused the arthritis, then the VA needs to order a C and P exam, and not just simply deny the claim and assume there is no nexus.  
    • Knee Condition
      I feel your pain on your knees. I am having new MRIs done in the next few weeks. I am SC for both knees at 10%, and what is crazy is the VA wants to replace my R Knee due to 2 MCL/ACL surgeries, yet I am only rated at 10%. Good luck and keep us posted. God Bless!!
    • My husband died in motorcycle accident
      That's what I thought too. I read somewhere that lawyers are permitted to charge between 20% - 33%. His name is Joseph R. Moore according to my research he has won many cases for widows but if someone here could confirm that for me that would be great. I did sign a privacy act waiver and sent it to Attig Steel Law. They said they will request the cfile first, but if I get the cfile before them I can send them a copy. Wondering if I should wait on them or not. 
    • TKR; Arthritis and in service fracture
      Buck     I looked in MY SMR's, and, there is evidence of the fracture in my SMR's.  As Berta pointed out, of course I need a nexus statement, but then isnt that what a C and P exam is for?   Isnt it true that if there is evidence of a in service event, but no nexus, isnt that mean that a  C and P exam is requested to determine a nexus?  
    • TKR; Arthritis and in service fracture
      Thank you for your responses. Berta posted: "I feel that, in fact, they did adjudicate the claim, and determined it was not SC, and that itself (NSC designation) is a denial." Yes, its a form of deemed denial, where they did not give a reasons and bases for denial, and did not mention a denial.  Its a Colvin violation for VA to fail to give a reasons and bases for denial.   Since it was not formallly adjucticated, as per 38 CFR 3.103, I would posit that the claim remains pending, that is, the one year appeal period is tolled as I never received notice of the decision: 3.103 Procedural due process and appellate rights. (a) Statement of policy. Every claimant has the right to written notice of the decision made on his or her claim, the right to a hearing, and the right of representation. Proceedings before VA are ex parte in nature, and it is the obligation of VA to assist a claimant in developing the facts pertinent to the claim and to render a decision which grants every benefit that can be supported in law while protecting the interests of the Government. The provisions of this section apply to all claims for benefits and relief, and decisions thereon, within the purview of this part 3. (b) The right to notice— (1) General. Claimants and their representatives are entitled to notice of any decision made by VA affecting the payment of benefits or the granting of relief. Such notice shall clearly set forth the decision made, any applicable effective date, the reason(s) for the decision, the right to a hearing on any issue involved in the claim, the right of representation and the right, as well as the necessary procedures and time limits, to initiate an appeal of the decision.
    • Knee Condition
      I get my 10% for right knee. In all the C&P exams they have never talked to me about my pain although I tell them every time. All they ever talk about is range of motion.
    • CLAIM COMPLETE--Frm 80% to 100% Comb Rtg
      Congrats!...Why to hang in there dude

  • HadIt.com Veteran to Veteran providing FREE information and community to veterans since 1997.

    I am proud that I've been able to offer all that HadIt.com has for free for 19 years and continue to do so. HadIt.com does accept contributions to help with costs we also offer paid ad free subscriptions. None of the paid options are required. The forum, the website, news site and podcast are free and will remain so. If you choose to support the site with a contribution or a subscription it is appreciated but never required. If you choose to make a contribution or purchase an ad free subscription, you can do so here. 

ffd95

Irritable Bowel Syndrome Issues

16 posts in this topic

Greetings all. This is my first post, I'm so glad I found this site with so much helpful information. So here goes:

After coming back from Desert Storm, I started having digestive issues. Since I've done two more tours in Iraq, it's become very difficult. I filed a claim last year, and was told by the examiner that the bowel problems were caused by taking too many Tums antacids, and my claim was denied. I told my personal physician what the doctor said and he said he couldn't be more wrong. My doctor sent me for colonoscopy, came back negative, and the term escapes me, but they basically put a camera down your throat. They could see irritation from the acid reflux.

I recently received a va newsletter, where they have stated that Irritable bowel syndrome is on the list of being presumed service connected if you served when and where I was located.

I went to the state VA service officer and she filed for IBS again. (I didn't appeal the first decision, I have just about given up on VA)

How do I get another exam? Will this happen since I filed again? My personal doctor has diagnosed me with IBS. I've even gone so far as to take pictures of my stools with my cell phone and downloaded them to my computer. They are all time stamped, so they can see that this is a daily issue. Does anyone have any suggestions on what else I could do?

Thank you so very much for your time. Sorry it's so long winded, my brain just doesn't work like it used to.

Brad Doyle

Fairview Heights, IL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites




Your more than likely have to go thru another exam. There going to want to look if there has been any changes since your last one.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

By the way, you mentioned you filed last year and was denied. How long ago did you receive your decision letter denying you? You have 1 year from the date of the letter to file an NOD. You can also file a Reconsideration letter with the new evidence you have.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

was told by the examiner that the bowel problems were caused by taking too many Tums antacids, and my claim was denied.

What kind of BS was that examiner saying! He had no right saying that, unless of course you told him you were eating them like candy. Even then, you already had the symptom's of IBS BEFORE you started taking them. JMO, he was totally out of line. Do you know what kind of Dr he was? Sorry about the posting so much, but the more I read it, the more I didn't catch the first time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You need to see an Internal Medicine Specialist to get a proper diagnosis. You may have GERD(Acid Reflux) and IBS, which are different but can cause serious problems. As for your private doctor diagnosing you with IBS, you need to file a NOD. Yes, it could take years but since you have the diagnosis, VA should award the claim. GERD(Acid Reflux) + IBS can get you a higher rating than just IBS alone.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I Ihave Necrotizing pancreas disease (and several other diseases) and the c&p exam doctor, unbeleivably had me lay down, while he pressed all over my stomach area.... can't believe how freaking stupid they are at the exams.. really really pathetic..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Retired44, the C & P exam doctor was probably trying to see how much of your abdomen is tender or is in pain due to your conditions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Retired44, the C & P exam doctor was probably trying to see how much of your abdomen is tender or is in pain due to your conditions.

after 20 years of suffering in HELL, in severe agony, while my intestines rotted away with a 5 inch cyst on my pancreas leaking poisonous fluids and sacs.. which broke and leaking all ove rmy guts in the operating room... for 2x in one weeks

if he wanted to know, less than one year before the exam I was in a va hospital bed fighting for my life.. he could have easuly ordered more copies of my medical records (seriously, there are boxes and reams of extremely rdetailed records of of breathe I took... for that whoe year.. while I fought for my life int he hospital bed while doctors and surgeons, and every frakkin nurse ont he 3rd floor worked on keeping me alive... he could have spent one year reading the records..... I sent the VA claims my records... plus they can probably get them on dvd.... to make reading them easier... by keyword..

every frakkin day for those 56 months, eveyr morningt between 4 and 6:30 am, the doctors and surgeons and hundreds of interns from the va dn uscsd would feel my stomach, because I suffered from sepsis and infection of my intestines and pancreas, it was swollen like a backetball.. and they poked it eveyr morning,, and had to find out if the necrosis and lack of food had destroyed the intestines.. they had to feel and listen to find out if they had stopped working...

I was either screaming for my morphine or Dlaudid, begging for pain relief, and also had a pain pump to squeeze the trigger...

the 12 bags of iv's with infection fighting drugs, food, and many drugs I am not sure what was in every bag.., hanging over my bed, the food running through a tube into my intestines,, PIC lines, (my viens no longer worked and the only way to access my blood and body was through valves implated into my vein/arteries..as I could not even drink more than a table spoon of water.. I could not hold objects, not reach down to touch my leggs.. or pul the blankets up if I got cold,, or move from one gurney to the next for each cat scan or x-ray I had at least 2 pet day...

i was a rag doll, and my head bobbled around like it was on a spring when I was wheeled around...

and this clown wanted to press all lover my stomach to see what a disease dying person felt like a few months later after I miraculously '[sARCASM MODE] = ON' got well enough to go home and have nurses visit me daily to get me walking, talking and eating again...

I walked into their offices sick, and waiting,, I get called, I go to the exam room, and the doctor looks at my folder,, and basically says, and what's your problem...

didn't these a-holes even read my file? where do I start..

l

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I hope you have luck with your IBS claim, IBS can be very disabling. I suffer myself, it started in the service, I asked my service officer about it a few years ago. She said then since my service medical records say probable ibs, probable being the keyword, she didn't think I would get it. Though I was treated with the same drugs I am on now. Her opinion was I was already 100% and it wasn't worth the effort. I thought she was wrong, so I filed but after sometime I withdrew it, my bad. Don't give up. My PTSD and IBS conspire against me, but I won't let it get me down. Don't you either.

A couple of years ago 2009 I think I had to go into the hospital for a week for extreme rectal bleeding, my colon was very swollen and when they finally could do a colonoscopy they found ulcers in my colon. They thought ulcerative colitis, a few months later another colonoscopy no ulcers so they said no on ulcerative colitis and yes to IBS. I take a regiment of pills to control it as best I can. I feel for you buddy it's a hell of way to spend the day and night, day after day. Hang in.

Greetings all. This is my first post, I'm so glad I found this site with so much helpful information. So here goes:

After coming back from Desert Storm, I started having digestive issues. Since I've done two more tours in Iraq, it's become very difficult. I filed a claim last year, and was told by the examiner that the bowel problems were caused by taking too many Tums antacids, and my claim was denied. I told my personal physician what the doctor said and he said he couldn't be more wrong. My doctor sent me for colonoscopy, came back negative, and the term escapes me, but they basically put a camera down your throat. They could see irritation from the acid reflux.

I recently received a va newsletter, where they have stated that Irritable bowel syndrome is on the list of being presumed service connected if you served when and where I was located.

I went to the state VA service officer and she filed for IBS again. (I didn't appeal the first decision, I have just about given up on VA)

How do I get another exam? Will this happen since I filed again? My personal doctor has diagnosed me with IBS. I've even gone so far as to take pictures of my stools with my cell phone and downloaded them to my computer. They are all time stamped, so they can see that this is a daily issue. Does anyone have any suggestions on what else I could do?

Thank you so very much for your time. Sorry it's so long winded, my brain just doesn't work like it used to.

Brad Doyle

Fairview Heights, IL

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

only thing you can do is keep going for help,,, IBS is a catch all for 'we have no clue what's wrong' they might a more difinite cause, but soemtimes, they never find a real cause...

in the future be very careful with any surgeries,,, once a part is messed with there is no going back...

watch diet.. stress, physical labor...

if you end up taking pain meds,, and you keep needing stronger meds, addiction (dependance) is just around the corner.

your lifestyle might end up taking a huge chage in activities,, holding jobs,,, finanaces, and relationships.. just depends on how the dise progresses.

if you are lucky, it's a passing thing,, something might get fixed ,, there is always that possibility...

it usually helps to find others you can personnaly communicate with that have the same symptoms,, being alone with a problem is hard on some people...

keeping notes is a very good idea...

again, diet,,, see what works and what does not... usually people with intestinal issues map out a course, wherever they go, of where bathrooms are... some people that have intestinal problems need bathrooms very often.. so make a kit for your car.... even a chage of clothing..

if you don't need such stuff, count your blessings..

IMHO

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Greetings all. I thought I had heard it all until now. I finally got a consult to see a specialist about my digestive problems. He immediately ordered a colonoscopy. They found 1 polyp and removed it, but also noted I now have hemeroids. (sic)

I had filed for IBS this time instead of stomach issues. When I first filed, I had no clue what was wrong except it wasn't right in my digestive system.

They've scheduled me appointments for C&P to increase my PTSD and for IBS.

So today in the mail, I get a stack of papers from Chicago telling me they need to know exactly why I want my PTSD increased. How can I write on paper explaining this? I'm angry all the time. I often break down crying in the middle of the day, and don't know how to stop. I haven't been to the PTSD ward at VA for quite some time. The last Dr I was assigned to had cancelled the last 3 appointments I had with her. I made an appointment with a nurse at that clinic. She told me outright that they may never fix the PTSD, only make it more bearable. I have never felt so helpless and alone in my life at that point. So I requested to be assigned to another doctor, and never heard back from them.

Then they also mention that they denied my stomach issues back in 2007. I wasn't even seen by the C&P doctor till 2010! They want me to provide proof that I've had this problem since returning from Desert Storm.

Thanks for listening.

Losing hope in this battle.

Brad

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Retired44, the C & P exam doctor was probably trying to see how much of your abdomen is tender or is in pain due to your conditions.

necrotizing pancreatitits, and several complication inlcuding many cysts surrounding the pancreas full of liquid (psuedocysts) also have splenic vein thrombsosis... (spent 6 months in a va hospital bed fighting for my l ife...). Was also hsopitalizized with gastritis on active duty..

the pancreas is between the spine and the stomach,, the psduedocysts and can rupure and you can die if a cyst breaks open and the fluid leaks out... sepsis sets in.. a Cat scan and or ultra sound is the only method to see the disease without surgery..

I know, been there done that, the last thing that a person should do is apply undue pressure... looks up the disease and complications,,it eventfully leads to death, there is no cure...

morphine is the usual drug for pain control help..

if a doctor is that stupid to push on it to see if a person hurts, they should never work with people nor have a medical license..

Edited by retiredat44

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't help with the PTSD but I am service connected for IBS. You said "They want me to provide proof that I've had this problem since returning from Desert Storm". This is a generic response letter that is very confusing, ignore it. You fall under the presumtive rules since you served in Desert Storm (thank you for your service) so you only have to provide proof that you have IBS. If you haven't already done so, submit the records from your private Dr showing a diagnosis of IBS. That is all the proof you need. I hope this helps.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

So sorry you're dealing with this condition, let alone trying to get the VA to understand what you're going through. I've had a resection due to cancer, and am now faced with a second surgery. Once this happens, since I was finally rated for colon issues, I plan on requesting an increase. I'm not looking forward to it, but think you'll get another C&P since this is really a claim for increase v. reconsideration/NOD from the first decision. I would also send in any information from your personal physician.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"from Chicago telling me they need to know exactly why I want my PTSD increased."

as the VA increased your PTSD medications due to more symptoms?

Have you ad any employment problems since last rating?

Any legal problems since last rating? Due to anger or stuff like that.

Have you been going to a vet center?

Have you for any reason accessed any crisis hotlines regarding your PTSD?

"I often break down crying in the middle of the day, and don't know how to stop. I haven't been to the PTSD ward at VA for quite some time. The last Dr I was assigned to had cancelled the last 3 appointments I had with her. "

Can you prove that?

"I made an appointment with a nurse at that clinic. She told me outright that they may never fix the PTSD, only make it more bearable. I have never felt so helpless and alone in my life at that point. So I requested to be assigned to another doctor, and never heard back from them. "

This is all problematic if you re open your PTSD claim. The VA needs to know disabled veterans are getting continuous treatments and meds to justify their comp awards.

"Then they also mention that they denied my stomach issues back in 2007. I wasn't even seen by the C&P doctor till 2010! They want me to provide proof that I've had this problem since returning from Desert Storm."

They are looking here for the same type of evidence as for the PTSD claim:

Documented medical evidence that you have had a current physical disability -the stomach problem)since returning from the Gulf War.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I can't help with the PTSD but I am service connected for IBS. You said "They want me to provide proof that I've had this problem since returning from Desert Storm". This is a generic response letter that is very confusing, ignore it. You fall under the presumtive rules since you served in Desert Storm (thank you for your service) so you only have to provide proof that you have IBS. If you haven't already done so, submit the records from your private Dr showing a diagnosis of IBS. That is all the proof you need. I hope this helps.

hello i am also service connected for ptsd .. right now im trying to get ibs secondary to the ptsd .. the doc who did the interview wrote in his opinion that that ptsd caused the ibs .. so i guess thats good .. but i know they ill just take it into consideration ...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now