Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

Ptsd Denials

2 posts in this topic

I was surprised to notice today how many legitimate PTSD claims have bee denied by VAROs in 2006.I didnt read them all just enough to wonder what is going on.

This one is good example:

"The veteran was awarded the air crewman badge which is

indicative of combat exposure. Therefore, the veteran is

entitled to the combat presumption under 38 C.F.R.

§ 3.304(f). Additionally, the veteran's personnel records

reflect that he was a lineman/wireman which likely would have

placed him in a combat zone.

The veteran has reported several credible stressors. At a VA

examination in September 2003, the veteran reported driving a

truck as part of a convoy which was shot at, causing him to

lose control of the truck and get into an accident. At a

hearing before the Board, the veteran's representative stated

that the veteran was repeatedly exposed to rocket and mortar

attacks on Hill 837 (and the veteran indicated that they were

shelled every other night for six months on Hill 837); and

the veteran referenced several accidents in which he ran over

civilians while driving a truck. "

Apparently the VARO screwed up on VCAA or DTA regs too:

"In light of this result, a detailed discussion of VA's

various duties to notify and assist is unnecessary (because

any potential failure of VA in fulfilling these duties is

harmless error)."


Service connection for PTSD is granted."

Is it beyond my comprehension why claims like this cannot be properly resolved at the RO level- cant they read at all?

It took 2 years for this decision from the VA and who knows how many more years it was at the RO-with all the evidence needed to award-and then denied and sent to the BVA.

Makes you sure wonder what the VFW (POA on the brief so I assume on the initial decision too) did to help him-

obvious DTA errors in the RO decision as well as probative evidence in the c file-ridiculous!

(The aircrewman badge does not specify combat but the regs indicate what it is for:

Crew Member: Individual must be on flying status as a crewmember in a specified position or non-crewmember in the case of observers, medical aidmen, gunners, aircraft maintenance supervisors or technical inspection)

I believe his MOS in a combat zone was more indicative of "engaged in combat" for the presumption.)

Edited by Berta

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I think it could be the difference between 38 U.s.c. § 1154 vs. 38 U.s.c. § 1154. Although this is VA law, maybe the BVA reserves the right to discriminate between who was in combat and who was not.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0




  • Topics

  • Member Statistics

    • Total Members
    • Most Online

    Newest Member
  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
    • Total Posts
  • Posts

    • If you may recall....   My buddy and I both used Dr. Bash   My buddy went from 80% to 100% thanks to Dr. Bash.   I on the otherhand was NEVER PROPERLY NOTIFIED OF MY C@P APPOINTMENTS.   the Va then rated me without me ever showing up and I remained at my 70%.   I appealed their decision based on never notifying me...but it will be a few years before I see my day in court. So I reported to the VA that my daughter had graduated college back in 2014..   They continued paying me her school rate for two years till then finally got to it. Then they sent me paperwork saying I owed them 4,000.00 I did the forms for waiver of debt being that it was no fault of my own and that Ive been unemployed for 3 years.   To my amazement they sent me a letter today saying that the 4k owed has been waived!!!!!! While this does not cover the full amount that I spent on Dr Bash just for the VA to not notify me of my appointments and essentially leave me high and dry...   It does feel good to have some success and not have to fret over the 4k. Thank you Hadit. The information here is amazing.
    • Writ of Man-dingus!  Make it happen :)  
    • Awesome! Thanks asknod. Attitude is everything. Thanks
    • Hey all! Thanks for responding to me in my desperation....not a threat...just thoughts...I tell my counselor every week about my thoughts...she says you got any plans? not specific i say...and therein lies the difference. I think about it alot. Do I have concrete plans? No. Do I research ideas....hell yes!!! I found a great website that goes over all the options and chances/odds of succeeding.....You know what I find strange? Why is it acceptable and legal for a woman to murder her unborn child...straight up homicide...but I am not allowed to exit from a devastatingly painful life...this is so wrong. The Netherlands have their shit together....anyone with severe mental illness like myself can obtain government sanctioned dr. assisted suicide but i risk going to prison for acquiring medications that will assist my end to suffering. Mental illness is an illness yet I have been handcuffed and taken down by the police forcibly more than 10 times in 24 months because of my come they dont do that shit to cancer patients? My crime? Public nuisance. Im weird. I act weird. I have been involuntarily locked up against my will more than 10 times in 24 months ....why would you handcuff and manhandle someone who is suffering an illness and has committed no crime? these asses have no comprehension of mental illness nor how to treat it...I am treated like a criminal for a disease I have...bullshit...I never hurt anyone nor threatened anyone..ever!....My psychiatrist admits that the whole meds game is a crap shoot and it is just trial and error to see what works....i deserve compassion to end my suffering...we put dogs down when they are in pain...why cant I put myself down to end the pain that this illness causes me. I cant live without my has been 4 youngest was oldest was 13....when the cops literally pulled them from my arms....and they will be the first to tell you...i never neglected nor hurt them...i was just...'weird'....
    • Thanks! Yep...I'd like to read the decision though. It will have to wait until my lreturn.