Bullwinkle

Original claim was an FDC, it took about two months for the decision after I filed (September 2017). They service connected all four of my contentions but two at only 0%. I asked for a reconsideration of those two. The new evidence is a medical evaluation and treatment after the decision. They scheduled a new C&P exam for 12 Jan 17. So we'll see........thanks again for the information.

Thanks jfrei. Appreciate the information. I'm ready to hit the send button but wanted to be sure. Thanks again.

Hello all. I would like to submit a request for reconsideration for a two contentions that were rated at SC at 0% in September 2017. I have everything (new medical evidence, VA Form 21-4138, etc.) loaded into e-benefits ready to send but was not sure requesting a reconsideration through e-benefits was the right process. My question is......can a request for reconsideration be submitted through e-benefits? Thanks again.

I thought I stated I was "Just seeking some friendly advise". My fault. Sorry I lost you. No worries........

Berta......as requested. Attached is my IME. I am trying for an increase from 0% on three (Left Cuboid Syndrome, Left Hip/Thigh Impairment and Left Hip Limit of Flexion). Thank you again.

Thanks for the input and advice. I'm still within the appeals period as these ratings were given to me in September 2017. I think after hearing your concerns I will remove the history of STR's and post a one page cover letter with recent medical documentation along with the IME. I will scan in the IME and try and attach it. Thank you again

Hello everyone. Just seeking some friendly advise. I received a SC for Left Cuboid Syndrome at 0% , Left Hip/Thigh Impairment 0%, Left Hip Limit of Flexion at 0% and Trochanteric Bursitis of the Left Hip at 10%. I plan to request an increase for the first three. I drafted a "Statement of Support of Claim" and wanted to get what ever critique or advise I can. I did have an IME done and the doctor was very good and complete in his examination and did a positive write up. I know it's long and so I apologize. Thank you. Left Foot -“Left Cuboid Syndrome” (claimed as plantar fasciitis and arthritis) - service connected at 0% established as related to the service connected disability of “leg length discrepancy, left lower extremity”. The evaluation currently assigned to my Left Foot does not accurately reflect the severity of my disability or the pain associated therewith. The pain on manipulation and use of my feet has worsened to the point that it adversely affects my ability to function under the ordinary conditions of daily life, including employment. I joined the Army October 8, 1975 at age 17 and, as my entrance medical exam records indicate, I had no preexisting conditions noted upon entry into service. From 1975, when I entered the service, up until around 1983 all our military activities, including physical training, combat readiness training and unit missions were conducted in US military issued combat boots while wearing various loads of gear and ammunition ranging from 20-40 lbs. The cushioning for these boots was minimal at best. The problem with my feet started shortly after my hip and leg began to bother me around 1980. I had several instances while in the service related to pain to my legs and feet as indicated in my service treatment records. Many times I had pain without seeking medical attention. When the pain was more frequent and no longer bearable I went to the troop medical clinics. In 1980, while in the service, I began to have pain in the arches of both feet. At the time I had no idea I had a left leg discrepancy or that it could be affecting other areas of my body. On April 25, 1984 I was seen at the 29th General Dispensary in Germany for pain and swelling of my left foot. I was carrying a large wooden equipment box with another soldier when the box slipped and dropped on my lower left leg and foot (See attached STR, dated 25 April 1984). On December 2, 2003 I advised the VA nurse of current ankle pain in the mornings during my VA Primary Care appointment (See attached Martinsburg VA CPC 2 Physician Assistant Note, dated December 2, 2003). May 24, 2016 I was seen for continuous pain in my left foot at the VA Hospital, Martinsburg, WV. I was diagnosed (x-ray) with plantar fascial fibromatosis of my left foot and treated. I was given an anti-inflammatory medication, compression socks and additional heel lifts (See attached VA exam diagnosis and VA Radiology Report, Left foot dated 5/24/2016). I have a sharp, stabbing pain at the base of the heel immediately after I get out of bed in the morning. Most times I have an inability to put the sole of my foot to the floor without pain. I have difficulty walking any distance and an inability to run. Load bearing on my feet is very painful. At times my coordination and balance is affected when I am moving around and the pain causes me to compensate on how I stand or walk. Sometimes my ankles give out and I roll one of them or stumble. I have walked with a limp after the first five years in the Army and have done so ever since. I find myself getting slightly depressed at times because of the constant pain affecting my feet. The pain level I am experiencing averages 6/7 on a good day and 8/9 when I have severe flare ups. The heel lifts I have been given have not been helpful at alleviating any pain in my foot up to this point. I have been wearing the lifts since 1988 and the only impact they have had is to minimize my altered gait somewhat due to my short left leg. The anti-inflammatory (Diclofenac Sodium Topical Gel) helps somewhat but only for a short period of time. There is a logistics issue when using this anti-inflammatory as I have to remove my shoes and socks to apply the gel, so I normally can not apply the gel when I am out of the home. The pain in my left foot is a stabbing pain in the bottom of my foot at the center (arch) and heel. The pain is usually the worst with both feet the first few steps after getting up in the morning, but also by long periods of standing or rising from sitting. The pain is usually worse after exercise, but not as much during it. My feet hurt more as the day goes on. It hurts the most when I climb stairs or after I stand for a long time. The early morning pain returns after about an hour and remains present throughout the day, leaving me unable to walk any real distance or stand without pain. The pain on manipulation and use of my feet adversely affects my ability to function under the ordinary conditions of daily life, including employment. I currently work as a police officer however I can not perform my current job effectively and now only work part time (8-16 hours a month). Load bearing on my feet is very painful. The added weight of the gear on the gun belt and the ballistic vest that I must wear (approximately 25 lbs combined) makes the pain in my feet almost impossible to bear. I have difficulty walking any distance and an inability to run. In 2016 I earned approximately $10,500 from work and did not receive disability from any source. I have worked and earned even less in 2017. I am able to drive but after 30-45 minutes the pain is to the point that I have to stop and take a break. I have been compensating for the pain in my feett by changing the way in which I walk and stand. This has contributed to the pain in my knees, hips, and back. I was prescribed an anti-inflammatory (Diclofenac Sodium Topical Gel) that would not affect me taking my prescribed daily aspirin. I apply this medication 2-3 times a day on my feet. On October 2 and 16 of 2017 I was seen by Dr. Gorenshtein at the Foot and Ankle Center in Winchester, VA. Dr. Gorenshtein diagnosed plantar fascial fibromatosis of my left foot. I was fitted for an arch support to be used with my current heel lift but again this has not helped with the pain in my foot as its purpose is to protect the arch while it heals. Dr. Gorenshtein advised he will have my left foot laser measured November 27, 2017 in order to make an orthopedic device that will incorporate both a heel left and arch support to be placed in my left shoe. This will alleviate wearing two devices in my shoe as I do now. I continue to receive treatment twice a month for both my left foot and left hip/leg at the Martinsburg VA Hospital, Winchester (VA) Orthopedic Association and Dr. Gorenshtein at the Foot and Ankle Center in Winchester, VA. at least twice a month. Left Hip/Thigh Impairment & Left Hip Limit of Flexion - service connected at 0% each. The evaluation currently assigned to my Left Hip/Thigh Impairment issue does not accurately reflect the severity of my disability or the pain associated therewith. The pain on manipulation and use of my left leg has worsened to the point that it adversely affects my ability to function under the ordinary conditions of daily life, including employment. Currently I have continuous pain and numbness to my left thigh. The pain and numbness is constant every day and all day and does not let up. On a good day the pain level is 5/6 however when I have a flare up or when standing or driving longer than 15-30 minutes the pain level is at 7/8. Sometimes when I have a flare up the pain is incapacitating to the point I have to immediately stop what I am doing and wait until the pain subsided in order to continue. At the end of the day it is at 7/8. In 1988, while in the Army, I was diagnosed with Left Leg Discrepancy. I believe this discrepancy has caused biomechanical stress in my left thigh, knees, hip and feet. On August 25, 1980 I was seen at the 130th Army General Hospital in Dexheim, Germany for tightness in my left leg. (See attached STR, dated 25 August 1984). December 10, 1980 I was seen at the 130th Army General Hospital in Dexheim, Germany for shin splints (I began to feel pain in both my shins, which lasted about a week to ten days, however the onset of pain was intermittent and bearable for 2-3 years. When the pain was more frequent and no longer bearable I went to the hospital) (See attached STR, dated December 10, 1980). On September 26, 1983 I was seen at the Troop Medical Clinic, Ft. McClellan, AL for pain to my upper left leg and pain in my shins (See attached STR, dated September 26, 1983). On July 14, 1988 I was seen for pain and swelling in my left knee at the Troop Medical Clinic #1, Ft. McClellan, AL. The attending military doctor attributed the pain in my left hip to a 2% biomechanical stress from my left leg discrepancy. This leg length discrepancy has also aggravated and caused pain in my left thigh, knee and hip and foot. (See attached STR, dated July 14, 1988). December 6, 1988 I was seen for right knee pain at the Physical Therapy Clinic, Noble Army Hospital, Ft. McClellan, AL. A permanent heel lift for my left foot was ordered at this time. This heel lift was to compensate for my leg length discrepancy and prevent any further damaged it had caused (See attached STR, dated December 6, 1988). January 29, 1992 seen for left hip pain at the Physical Therapy Clinic, Ft. McClellan, AL. During this examination the doctor measured and recorded my left leg to be 89 cm and my right leg to be 91 cm. The attending military doctor attributed the pain in my left hip to a 2% biomechanical stress from my left leg discrepancy (See attached STR, dated January 29, 1992). June 23, 2003 attended VA Primary Care appointment at the Veterans Administration Hospital, Martinsburg, WV. I advised the staff of left hip pain and numbness in left leg (See attached Martinsburg VA CPC 2 Physician Assistant Note, dated June 23, 2003). December 2, 2003 attended VA Primary Care appointment at the Veterans Administration Hospital, Martinsburg, WV. I advised the staff again of left hip pain and numbness in my left leg as well as ankle pain in both feet, especially in the am when waking up. (See attached Martinsburg VA CPC 2 Physician Assistant Note, dated December 2, 2003). March 17, 2017 I was seen for left hip pain at the Winchester Orthopedic Association, Winchester, VA. I was diagnosed with trochanteric bursitis of the left hip/primary osteoarthritis of the left hip (x-rays). I had begun to feel pain in my outer left leg and hip with numbness and sharp pain since 1980. This pain and numbness lasted about a week each time. The pain was bearable with motrin, however the pain became constant within the last 17 months is extremely painful and constant now (See attached Civilian Medical Report, dated March 17, 2017). March 2017 through April 2017 I completed physical therapy at the Winchester Orthopedic Association, Winchester, VA., however the pain remained (See attached Civilian Medical Report, dated March 17, 2017). May 12, 2017 I received a therapeutic steroid injection (fluid guide x-ray) of the left hip performed by Winchester Medical Center Hospital, Winchester, VA ordered by Winston Cameron, MD of Winchester Orthopedic Association, Winchester, VA. This treatment helped to mitigate some of the pain in my hip however I continue to have shooting pain, numbness, and tingling in my outer left leg on a constant basis when standing, sitting, or walking for periods of 15 minutes or more (See attached Civilian Medical Report, dated May 12, 2017). July 2017 through September 2017 I again completed physical therapy at the Winchester Orthopedic Association, Winchester, VA., however the pain remained in my left leg and left foot. I was referred by the attending doctor to a podiatrist, Alex Gorenshtein, MD at the Foot and Ankle Center in Winchester, VA for the continuous pain in my left foot (See attached Civilian Medical Report, dated July-September 2017). I have a lack of endurance and my coordination and balance is affected when I am moving around. I have been compensating for the pain in my left leg by changing the way in which I walk and stand. This has contributed to the weakness and pain in my knees, hip, and back. I have difficulty walking any distance and an inability to run. Load bearing on my left leg is very painful. The pain in my left leg has altered my daily living to include taking care of myself, personal hygiene, preparing and eating food, standing, sitting, caring for my home or completing home repairs, walking, traveling, recreational and social activities. Decisions must be made and priorities set daily depending on the level of pain I am currently having. I have compensated, or attempted to compensate, for my pain by changing my daily routine to make things easier or more bearable. Currently I have continuous pain and numbness to my left thigh. The pain and numbness is constant every day and all day and does not let up. On a good day the pain level is 5/6 however when I have a flare up or when standing or driving longer than 15-30 minutes the pain level is at 7/8. Sometimes when I have a flare up the pain is incapacitating to the point I have to immediately stop what I am doing and wait until the pain subsided in order to continue. A flare up can come on fairly quickly and unexpectedly. I currently do not have the sufficient physical capacity to meet the occupational demands of my current profession as a police officer and must look at other occupations available that do not require standing, walking or sitting for more than 30 minutes and one that will allow me to stop at times to either lie down and rest or remove my shoes and socks to apply the topical anti-inflammatory medication when needed. Load bearing on my leg is very painful. The added weight of the gear on the gun belt and the ballistic vest that I must wear (approximately 25 lbs combined) makes the pain in my feet and left leg almost impossible to bear. I have difficulty walking any distance and an inability to run. I can not perform my current job effectively and now only work part time (8-16 hours a month). As stated previously, in 2016 I earned approximately $10,500 from work and did not receive disability from any source. I have worked and earned even less in 2017. Sometimes I get stressed and a little depressed from the chronic pain and have difficulty with falling asleep or staying asleep. I continue to receive treatment twice a month for both my left foot and left hip/leg at the Martinsburg VA Hospital, Winchester (VA) Orthopedic Association and Dr. Gorenshtein at the Foot and Ankle Center in Winchester, VA.

Well.....claim is complete. Was hoping for a little more but at least they were all service comp. Not sure how I will proceed. Is the best option a "reconsideration" ? Does that have to be done within 60 days? I am preparing to have an "independent medical examination" before anything. left hip osteoarthritis and bursitis 10% 05/11/2017 left hip/thigh impairment 0% 05/11/2017 left hip limitation of flexion 0% 05/11/2017 leg length discrepancy, left lower extremity 0% 12/11/2014 left cuboid syndrome (claimed as plantar fasciitis and arthritis) 0% 05/11/2017

Thanks Navy. I guess I'll find out soon enough. The original competition date was to be in November - January some time. Today it changed to September 17, 2017. Submitted: 08/02/2017 (Compensation) Completion: 09/15/2017 - 09/17/2017

Thank you Hamslice and Berta for your input. It is much appreciated.

My left leg was determined to be 2 cm shorter than the right leg about six years after entering the army. Because I was having issues with my hip they ran some test and one of the test was to measure my legs. I had never considered this as an issue previously as I never even knew it. In my service records the army doctor wrote the pain in my hip was "caused by a 2% biomechanical altered gait caused by left leg discrepancy". They fitted me with heel lifts at that time. When I got out of the army the VA gave me a SC diagnoses of left leg discrepancy with 0% ( Presumption of soundness).

During my C&P exam the examiner had both my feet x-rayed. My original claim was for secondary plantar fasciitis of the LEFT foot due to LEFT leg shorting. The examiner stated it was "as least as likely". Apparently there are more serious issues with my RIGHT foot based on the x-rays however, this was not part of my original claim. Would this be something I would need to do a new claim for? Any advice would be much appreciated. Thank you. X-Ray Report: RIGHT AND LEFT FOOT: AP and lateral. CLINICAL INDICATION: C & P examination. REFERENCE: Left foot 5/24/2016. The lateral views were obtained in the weightbearing position. Right: There is a hallux valgus deformity. There are arthritic changes at the first metatarsophalangeal joint. There is spurring at the dorsal aspect of the head of the first metatarsal. There are moderately severe arthritic changes at the interphalangeal joint of the first toe. There is a 3 mm spur at the plantar aspect of the calcaneus. The calcaneal pitch is in the borderline normal range. Left: There is a mild hallux valgus deformity. No fracture deformity, bony erosion or destructive lesion is noted. The calcaneal pitch is in the borderline normal range.

Thanks Buck. I was a little perplexed on the first opinion (hip) where he says "less likely than not" in para "b" and then "as least likely as not" in para "c".

Just looked up my C&P exam results from Wednesday (6 Sept). Trying to figure out the results. It seems there may be an error in the first "B" and "C". Any thoughts? Thank you in advance. TYPE OF MEDICAL OPINION PROVIDED: [ MEDICAL OPINION FOR DIRECT SERVICE CONNECTION ] b. The condition claimed was less likely than not (less than 50% probability) incurred in or caused by the claimed in-service injury, event or illness. c. Rationale: Based on interview and examination of the Veteran, review of the Veteran's VBMS case file, review of the Veteran's VHA medical records, and review of relevant medical references the Veteran's LEFT hips conditions as described in the Hip Conditions DBQ are as least likely as not (50% or greater probability) incurred during his military service as documented as complaints of LEFT hip pain & assessment of LEFT iliotibial band syndrome are documented in his STRs. As directed nexus is reasonably demonstrated the secondary nexus question proximally is rendered moot. TYPE OF MEDICAL OPINION PROVIDED: [ MEDICAL OPINION FOR SECONDARY SERVICE CONNECTION ] a. The condition claimed is at least as likely as not (50% or greater probability) proximately due to or the result of the Veteran's service connected condition. c. Rationale: Based on interview and examination of the Veteran, review of the Veteran's VBMS case file, review of the Veteran's VHA medical records, and review of relevant medical references the Veteran does not have current symptoms of plantar fasciitits. His current symptoms are attributable to LEFT cuboid syndrome. The Veteran's LEFT cuboid syndrome is as likely as not (50% or greater probability) proximately due to or the result of leg length discrepancy due to altered gait biomechanics caused by the leg length discrepancy.

Yes, it is Tbird and thank you. Been paying forever. I wish I would have known about this site sooner. I have learned so much just from the little time I have been reading on here.

So I received a notification package today regarding the review on my SSB Recoupment. My recoupment was supposed to end November 2019 at which time I was to start reviving benefits December 2019 (30 percent). Apparently the VA miscalculated my SSB recoupment and now have advised me, after their review, recoupment will be finished November 2017. I will start receiving benefits in December. That was great news. Now for the C&P in the am.......

Below is the C&P 's "Clinician Guide" link dated March 2002, off the VA website. I know it has probably been posted in the past but I figured just as a refresher. https://www.benefits.va.gov/warms/docs/admin21/guide/cliniciansguide.doc

Update: My original claim (FDC) was a formal claim for secondary conditions of “Arthritis Due to Strain” in both my left foot and left hip caused by my service-connected condition “left leg length discrepancy”, which is rated at 0 percent. My left leg length discrepancy and pelvic tilt has played a role in either causing or aggravating my diagnosed trochanteric bursitis of the left hip. I have been scheduled for a C&P exam for the 6th of Sept at the VA in Martinsburg. When I looked in E-Benefits I saw a new claim opened. Actually the VA opened a new claim to review my SSB recoupment and make some kind of adjustment. The closed the claim and have sent me a notification package (which I have not received as of yet). So as it stands now I will undergo the C&P exam this week.

Have a question. I submitted a claim in E-Benefits for secondary for both my left hip and left foot (due to left discrepancy), which is SC. The plantar fasciitis in my foot was diagnosed by the VA and my hip was diagnosed by a civilian doctor. I uploaded all my VA medical and personal doctors medical evaluation and documents along with a copy of my service medical records. My question is why this was done so fast as my initial claim was put into E-Benefits on 08/02/2017 and now I see its already in the "Preparation for Notification" phase. Also under disabilities claimed it states "mqas review - recoupment adjustment (New)". I did get an SSB payment when I left the service that I have been paying back for years now. My question is this seems too fast for the VA.....and not a good sign. (E-Benefits yesterday) Status of Your Claim: Gathering of Evidence Submitted: 08/02/2017 (Compensation) Estimated Completion: 11/11/2017 - 02/03/2018 Estimated Completion Info Tooltip with additional information Disabilities Claimed: bursitis(secondary to: leg length discrepancy, left lower extremity) (Secondary), (secondary to: leg length discrepancy plantar fasciitis left lower extremity) (Secondary) Current Status: Gathering of Evidence (E-Benefits Today) Status of Your Claim: Preparation for Notification Submitted: 08/21/2017 (Regulatory or Procedural Review) Estimated Completion: 08/24/2017 - 08/28/2017 Estimated Completion Info Tooltip with additional information Disabilities Claimed: mqas review - recoupment adjustment (New) Current Status: Preparation for Notification Representative for VA Claims: VETERANS OF FOREIGN WARS OF THE US