HadIt.com Elder Josephine Posted September 28, 2008 HadIt.com Elder Share Posted September 28, 2008 (edited) I am in the process of writing a NOD for these low-ball ratings, If you have the time to give me just a tad of assistance. I am going to start by typing out the Rating of May 8, 2008. I definitely will not send all this back to them, but did this for your benefit. Sometimes it is difficult to read from a scan. Service Connection for Chronic Anxiety with depression. Service connection for chronic anxiety with depression has been established as directly related to military service. On March 4, 2008, The Board of Veterans Appeals granted service connection for an acquired psychiatric disorder to include chronic anxiety and depression. A detailed explanation of how they came to that decision. You originally filed for service connection for an anxiety disorder in an application received on February 8, 1992. Service connection was denied on the basis of your service treatment records not showing any treatment for non-congenital psychiatric disorders. Because there was a failure to retrieve mental heath records and not stored with service treatment records, we are able to go back to that date even though that decision was finalized with no further action until 2002. An evaluation of 10 percent is assigned from February 6, 1992. An evaluation of 10 percent is assigned if there is evidence of an emotional tension or anxiety productive of mild social and industrial impairment. At that time, you had been married for over 20 years. You get along well with your spouse and two children, and had a number of friends. By your own account, you had quit working in a public place in 1983 in favor of working from home. A treatment record of Dr. Pxxx dated August 31, 1983, noted you worked at a high stress job at English Mxxxx. However, there is no indication that you were having trouble handling that stress, several personal events occurred over the years, causing acute increase in anxiety. Dr. Payxx treatment record states: I was working at a high stress job and under a great deal of stress and strain. Activity level low and is working at home. I was not given a C&P examiation in 1992 to see what my true medical condition was for the VA standards. A higher evaluation of 30 percent is not warranted unless there is definite impairment in the ability to establish or maintain effective and wholesome relationships with people, the psychoneurotic symptoms result in such reduction in initiative, flexibility, efficiency, and reliability levels as to produce definite industrial impairment. The evidence on file does not show the aforesaid symptoms. There would not be a note in my medical records of 1992 as to what was going on in my life considering occupational and social employment. Effective November 7, 1996, The Secretary of the Department of Veterans Affairs amended the Schedule for Rating Disabilities for mental disorders to better conform to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders. Volume IV (DSM- IV), Which is used for most mental health practitioners. However, your symptoms closely mirrored those listed at the 10 percent level which is occupational and social impairment due to mild and transient symptoms which decrease work efficiency only during times of significant stress. The symptoms had not elevated enough to warrant a 30 percent evaluation, which includes occasional decrease in efficiency and intermittent period of inability to perform occupational duties due to symptoms such as suspiciousness and mild memory loss. Under the amended rating schedule, an evaluation of 50 percent is assigned for occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as flattened effect, circumstantial, circumlocutory speech, panic attacks more than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands, impairment of short- long term memory ( e.g., retention of only highly learned material, forgetting to complete task) impaired judgment, impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of mood; difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social relationships. In a medical report dated August 7, 1997, Dr. Pxxx noted you had an exacerbation in your anxiety disorder, resulting in him labeling you with Severe Anxiety Disorder. In a statement by Dr. Pxxxx dated May 27, 1998, Dr Pxxx noted your symptoms had been ongoing in all factors of your life since the exacerbation nine months earlier. Additional information regarding your mental disorder is not available until 2004. A higher evaluation of 70 percent is not warranted unless there are deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations, judgment, thinking or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal ideation, obsessional rituals, which interfere with routine activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant; near- continuous panic or depression effecting the ability to function independently, appropriately and effectively; Impaired impulse control ( such as unprovoked irritability with periods of violence ) ; Spatial disorientation; neglect of personal appearance in hygiene; difficulty in adapting To stressful circumstances including work or a work like setting); inability to establish And maintain effective relationships. Although your impulse control has been impaired, It was not continuous. Your personal hygiene was still intact, as well as your spatial orientation. According to a VA examination dated October 18, 2004, you were staying active with friends and family. Panic attacks occurred only once per week. In a VA examination dated April 12, 2005 your spouse announced a more frequent pattern of impaired impulse control, including fits of anger during which you kicked holes in a walls and broke furniture. You reported crying spells and sleeping problems. You admitted to decreased concentration. The examiner noted you were appropriately dressed but appeared disheveled. Although your speech flowed normally, your mood was anxious with a constricted effect. You denied suicidal and homicidal intentions. During a January 15, 2008, Independent Evaluation by Dr. Crowley, you were cooperative and well orientated. No abnormities of thought processes were present. Again, your fears of driving and of heights were noted. You also stressed that you constantly dream of stairs Leading to a pool. The dreams were noted as night terrors, which are far worse than nightmares. This result in six hours of sleep, but you noted it does not harm you. During this exam however, the examiner noted your hands being wet This symptom had been occurring for over 30 years, but at this stage, your hands became wetter as you talked. A higher evaluation of 100 percent is not warranted unless there is total occupational and social impairment due to such symptoms as: a gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior.; Persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability to perform activities of daily living ( including maintenance of minimal hygiene ); disorientation to time or place; Memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation, or own name. There had been no indications of hallucinations or dangerous behavior toward self or other people. You have kept up your personal hygiene and noted no memory loss period. There has also been no mention of complete and total occupational and social impairment. This is taking from my the September 23, 2008 Rating. Entitlement to Individual Unemployability Entitlement to individual unemployability is granted because the claimant is unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service connected disability. Social Security Administration income statements show that you have not worked since 1983. Your VA examination, dated August 22, 2008 showed that you had been unable to work due to your severe anxiety. The examiner noted that you would not be employable due to your panic attacks, anxiety, and interactions with customers and co-workers in a working environment. Based upon the opinion of the examiner, entitlement to individual unempoyability is granted effective April 12, 2005 to August 20, 2008, the date of your increase to 100 percent. In the August 22, 2008 is this examiner stating that I was not able to work in the public sector in 1983 as well? Thanks, Betty Edited September 28, 2008 by Josephine Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Berta Posted September 28, 2008 Share Posted September 28, 2008 (edited) "In the August 22, 2008 is this examiner stating that I was not able to work in the public sector in 1983 as well?" I am not sure Betty - have to think about what you mean here-BUT "In a medical report dated August 7, 1997, Dr. Pxxx noted you had an exacerbation in your anxiety disorder, resulting in him labeling you with Severe Anxiety Disorder." Was this a VA doc or a private doc- I forget-and wouldn't this show as Severe anxiety- a higher rating then they gave you? Did they ever mention your SSA records in detail? What I mean is what percentage of the SSA award is for anxiety? There is a vet here who I suggested to that he use the rating SSA gave him for his SC shoulder (the SSA had other NSC percents too) as evidence of how much ,per the SSA, his SC shoulder was disabling him because the VA lowballed him at 10%. I dont know if this tactic will work but why not- My husband got SSA solely for a CVA then on reconsideration it was a better EED and SSA totally for PTSD. So I dont really know how SSA handles percentages when they award on more than one disability- others here sure would know- I agree that you should definitely try for a better EED. Edited September 28, 2008 by Berta Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HadIt.com Elder Josephine Posted September 28, 2008 Author HadIt.com Elder Share Posted September 28, 2008 (edited) Berta, I never had enough credits to file for Social Security. In a medical report dated August 7, 1997, Dr. Pxxx noted you had an exacerbation in your anxiety disorder, resulting in him labeling you with Severe Anxiety Disorder." This came from my private doctor of 30 years. Not Military. I am trying see how the VA came up with the 10% after 28 years of treatment at that time. They have my post medical records from 1965 to date. Had the VA give me a C&P in 1992, when I first filed, but here we go, they are taking the responsibility of not acquiring my military mental records, thus denying me, but my condition was worse in the earlier years, than the years they gave me the higher rating. I will have to type what Dr. Mxxx actually said in his C&P and not the words of the rater. Thanks, Betty Edited September 28, 2008 by Josephine Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Berta Posted September 29, 2008 Share Posted September 29, 2008 I apologise Josephine- you told us that many times before- then again a person without enough SSA credits certainly has not had any long work history-and this is often only due to disability itself- "In a medical report dated August 7, 1997, Dr. Pxxx noted you had an exacerbation in your anxiety disorder, resulting in him labeling you with Severe Anxiety Disorder." This came from my private doctor of 30 years. Not Military. I am trying see how the VA came up with the 10% after 28 years of treatment at that time." This is the issue to focus on in the NOD-I agree with you. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HadIt.com Elder jbasser Posted September 29, 2008 HadIt.com Elder Share Posted September 29, 2008 (edited) At that time, you had been married for over 20 years. You get along well with your spouse and two children, and had a number of friends. By your own account, you had quit working in a public place in 1983 in favor of working from home. A treatment record of Dr. Pxxx dated August 31, 1983, noted you worked at a high stress job at English Mxxxx. However, there is no indication that you were having trouble handling that stress, several personal events occurred over the years, causing acute increase in anxiety. Dr. Payxx treatment record states: I was working at a high stress job and under a great deal of stress and strain. Activity level low and is working at home. Betty, I believe the VA is hung up on one statement. Working at home. Were you holding down a job at home back then. I believe the Doc meant Housework. You can question that and have the Doc clarify it in your NOD with a statement from him. I believe that is the only thing that you need to succeed. John Edited September 29, 2008 by jbasser Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HadIt.com Elder Wings Posted September 29, 2008 HadIt.com Elder Share Posted September 29, 2008 At that time, you had been married for over 20 years. You get along well with your spouse and two children, and had a number of friends. By your own account, you had quit working in a public place in 1983 in favor of working from home. A treatment record of Dr. Pxxx dated August 31, 1983, noted you worked at a high stress job at English Mxxxx. However, there is no indication that you were having trouble handling that stress, several personal events occurred over the years, causing acute increase in anxiety. Dr. Payxx treatment record states: I was working at a high stress job and under a great deal of stress and strain. Activity level low and is working at home. Betty, I believe the VA is hung up on one statement. Working at home. Were you holding down a job at home back then. I believe the Doc meant Housework. You can question that and have the Doc clarify it in your NOD with a statement from him. I believe that is the only thing that you need to succeed. John I agree with John B. I think he's spot on!! ~Wings Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
HadIt.com Elder Josephine Posted September 30, 2008 Author HadIt.com Elder Share Posted September 30, 2008 At that time, you had been married for over 20 years. You get along well with your spouse and two children, and had a number of friends. By your own account, you had quit working in a public place in 1983 in favor of working from home. A treatment record of Dr. Pxxx dated August 31, 1983, noted you worked at a high stress job at English Mxxxx. However, there is no indication that you were having trouble handling that stress, several personal events occurred over the years, causing acute increase in anxiety. Dr. Payxx treatment record states: I was working at a high stress job and under a great deal of stress and strain. Activity level low and is working at home. Betty, I believe the VA is hung up on one statement. Working at home. Were you holding down a job at home back then. I believe the Doc meant Housework. You can question that and have the Doc clarify it in your NOD with a statement from him. I believe that is the only thing that you need to succeed. John I agree with John B. I think he's spot on!! ~Wings Thanks so much, I will get that letter the 13th of October. Betty Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Question
Josephine
I am in the process of writing a NOD for these low-ball
ratings,
If you have the time to give me just a tad of assistance.
I am going to start by typing out the Rating of May 8, 2008.
I definitely will not send all this back to them, but did this for
your benefit. Sometimes it is difficult to read from a scan.
Service Connection for Chronic Anxiety with depression.
Service connection for chronic anxiety with depression has been
established as directly related to military service.
On March 4, 2008, The Board of Veterans Appeals granted service
connection for an acquired psychiatric disorder to include chronic
anxiety and depression. A detailed explanation of how they came to
that decision. You originally filed for service connection for an
anxiety disorder in an application received on February 8, 1992.
Service connection was denied on the basis of your service treatment
records not showing any treatment for non-congenital psychiatric
disorders. Because there was a failure to retrieve mental heath
records and not stored with service treatment records, we are able to
go back to that date even though that decision was finalized with no
further action until 2002.
An evaluation of 10 percent is assigned from February 6, 1992.
An evaluation of 10 percent is assigned if there is evidence
of an emotional tension or anxiety productive of mild social and
industrial impairment.
At that time, you had been married for over 20 years. You get along
well with your spouse and two children, and had a number of friends.
By your own account, you had quit working in a public place in 1983
in favor of working from home. A treatment record of Dr. Pxxx dated
August 31, 1983, noted you worked at a high stress job at English
Mxxxx. However, there is no indication that you were having trouble
handling that stress, several personal events occurred over the
years, causing acute increase in anxiety.
Dr. Payxx treatment record states: I was working at a high stress
job and under a great deal of stress and strain. Activity level low
and is working at home.
I was not given a C&P examiation in 1992 to see
what my true medical condition was for the VA standards.
A higher evaluation of 30 percent is not warranted unless there is
definite impairment in the ability to establish or maintain effective
and wholesome relationships with people, the psychoneurotic symptoms
result in such reduction in initiative, flexibility, efficiency, and
reliability levels as to produce definite industrial impairment. The
evidence on file does not show the aforesaid symptoms.
There would not be a note in my medical records of
1992 as to what was going on in my life considering occupational and
social employment.
Effective November 7, 1996, The Secretary of the Department of
Veterans Affairs amended the Schedule for Rating Disabilities for
mental disorders to better conform to the Diagnostic and Statistical
Manual for Mental Disorders. Volume IV (DSM- IV),
Which is used for most mental health practitioners.
However, your symptoms closely mirrored those listed at the 10
percent level which is occupational and social impairment due to mild
and transient symptoms which decrease work efficiency only during
times of significant stress. The symptoms had not elevated enough to
warrant a 30 percent evaluation, which includes occasional decrease
in efficiency and intermittent period of inability to perform
occupational duties due to symptoms such as suspiciousness and mild
memory loss.
Under the amended rating schedule, an evaluation of 50 percent is
assigned for occupational and social impairment with reduced
reliability and productivity due to such symptoms as flattened
effect, circumstantial, circumlocutory speech, panic attacks more
than once a week; difficulty in understanding complex commands,
impairment of short- long term memory ( e.g., retention of only
highly learned material, forgetting to complete task) impaired
judgment, impaired abstract thinking; disturbances of mood;
difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social
relationships.
In a medical report dated August 7, 1997, Dr. Pxxx noted you had
an exacerbation in your anxiety disorder, resulting in him labeling
you with Severe Anxiety Disorder.
In a statement by Dr. Pxxxx dated May 27, 1998, Dr Pxxx noted your
symptoms had been ongoing in all factors of your life since the
exacerbation nine months earlier.
Additional information regarding your mental disorder is not
available until 2004.
A higher evaluation of 70 percent is not warranted unless there are
deficiencies in most areas, such as work, school, family relations,
judgment, thinking or mood, due to such symptoms as: suicidal
ideation, obsessional rituals, which interfere with routine
activities; speech intermittently illogical, obscure, or irrelevant;
near- continuous panic or depression effecting the ability to
function independently, appropriately and effectively;
Impaired impulse control ( such as unprovoked irritability with
periods of violence ) ; Spatial disorientation;
neglect of personal appearance in hygiene;
difficulty in adapting To stressful circumstances
including work or a work like setting); inability to establish
And maintain effective relationships.
Although your impulse control has been impaired,
It was not continuous. Your personal hygiene was still intact,
as well as your spatial orientation.
According to a VA examination dated October 18, 2004, you were
staying active with friends and family. Panic attacks occurred only
once per week.
In a VA examination dated April 12, 2005 your spouse announced a more
frequent pattern of impaired impulse control, including fits of anger
during which you kicked holes in a walls and broke furniture.
You reported crying spells and sleeping problems.
You admitted to decreased concentration.
The examiner noted you were appropriately dressed but appeared
disheveled.
Although your speech flowed normally, your mood was anxious with a
constricted effect. You denied suicidal and homicidal intentions.
During a January 15, 2008, Independent Evaluation by Dr. Crowley,
you were cooperative and well orientated. No abnormities of thought
processes were present. Again, your fears of driving and of heights
were noted. You also stressed that you constantly dream of stairs
Leading to a pool. The dreams were noted as night terrors,
which are far worse than nightmares.
This result in six hours of sleep, but you noted it does not harm you.
During this exam however, the examiner noted your hands being wet
This symptom had been occurring for over 30 years, but at this stage,
your hands became wetter as you talked.
A higher evaluation of 100 percent is not warranted unless there is
total occupational and social impairment due to such symptoms as: a
gross impairment in thought processes or communication; persistent
delusions or hallucinations; grossly inappropriate behavior.;
Persistent danger of hurting self or others; intermittent inability
to perform activities of daily living
( including maintenance of minimal hygiene );
disorientation to time or place;
Memory loss for names of close relatives, own occupation, or own
name. There had been no indications of hallucinations or dangerous
behavior toward self or other people.
You have kept up your personal hygiene and noted no memory loss
period. There has also been no mention of complete and total
occupational and social impairment.
This is taking from my the September 23, 2008 Rating.
Entitlement to Individual Unemployability
Entitlement to individual unemployability is granted because the claimant is unable to secure and follow a substantially gainful
occupation as a result of service connected disability.
Social Security Administration income statements show that you
have not worked since 1983. Your VA examination, dated August 22, 2008
showed that you had been unable to work due to your severe anxiety.
The examiner noted that you would not be employable due to your panic
attacks, anxiety, and interactions with customers and co-workers
in a working environment.
Based upon the opinion of the examiner, entitlement to individual
unempoyability is granted effective April 12, 2005 to August 20, 2008,
the date of your increase to 100 percent.
In the August 22, 2008 is this examiner stating that
I was not able to work in the public sector in 1983 as well?
Thanks,
Betty
Edited by JosephineLink to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
3
2
1
1
Popular Days
Sep 28
3
Sep 29
3
Sep 30
1
Top Posters For This Question
Josephine 3 posts
Berta 2 posts
Wings 1 post
jbasser 1 post
Popular Days
Sep 28 2008
3 posts
Sep 29 2008
3 posts
Sep 30 2008
1 post
6 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now