FTCA claims get into many nuance of legalize that truly require the expertise of an FTCA lawyer.
These links are helpful in understanding some of the legal aspects of FTCA.
Also what can appear to be definite malpractice, after a thorough reading of the medical records by a medical expert- might not even be close to malpractice.
I saw this happen personally quite a few times .Once when a local VAMC vet appeared to have horrific malpractice case. He had the newspapers do a big story on the treatment he received and it read like a horror story. He contacted me through the VA Chaplain in Bath and sent me some of his med recs. (Some)and the newspaper article.
Long story- he said he had lawyers interested in his case but failed to get lawyer and filed the SF 95 himself-but too late.I had reminded him many times to get that filed because time was runnng out and I knew the exact SOL date. I had told him to seek a vet rep who had an office right next to the VA chapel where I met this vet for a Section 1151 claim and I gave him a note for the rep as to what I felt was a good 1151 basis here and would help with the claim.He said he filed it there but they didnt know him and had no record of it-
When I finally got the entire medical record package I saw right away that the VA could well mitigate any damages that this veteran claimed to have. There was documentation in the record that he been abusive to the VA staff and had not been compliant at all with his care. He started to even get abusive and controlling with me because I could not file anything for him.Nor make any statement to support his contentions.He needed a vet rep to do that.There was a lot more to all this but my point is-
what can certainly seem like medical error and negligence might not even be close to that scenario.
Only a good IMO doctor can really determine if negligence has occurred to a veteran and if not the veteran should have peace of mind knowing their medical care is,in fact, proper.
This Office of General Counsel Precedent Opinion shows how offsets are impacted by attorney fees.
Since this is an old opinion it is best to check the OGC Opinions site via the VA web site to see if anything else has altered this Pres Op or if there are any subsequent opinions regarding FTCA or 1151 claims that could impact your claims.
The National Veterans Legal Program Veterans Benefits Manual (VBM)
This legal text is available for purchase at the NVLSP web site.
It gives a good but brief overview of FTCA and Section 1151 claims- advising however that FTCA issues should be handled by attorneys.It does not get into the fine points of FTCA law.
The only legal information I had for my FTCA claim was basically what I found in the VBM as the internet in those days had no way to find FTCA information.The info was great but very limited.
I also used a law library for questions I had but could not find answers to in the VBM.
Also the BVA has cases regarding offsets.
They have 2 of my cases there in this regard.In the first claim the BVA was wrong.
In the second case they were correct.
The initial error they made was corrected by the Regional Counsel a few years ago.
I had a more recent offset matter. The OGC and the RC tried to blow me off.(I dealt with lawyers who knew all about my past FTCA case and who I had dealt with before and I had phone contact with them as well as email and snail mail) Persistence paid off.
I told them I was right based on established VA case law which I rattled off every chance I got.
Soon after that ordeal they agreed with me and I await the results now from the regional office.
It sure pays to have a lawyer however to save the time and rigamorale some of this stuff takes.VA lawyers are smart and can be cunning and manipulative-and they know VA case law in and out. I have tremendous respect for their expertise.
FTCA can succeed without lawyer or IMO but it is very difficult to do that.
Question
Berta
FTCA claims get into many nuance of legalize that truly require the expertise of an FTCA lawyer.
These links are helpful in understanding some of the legal aspects of FTCA.
Also what can appear to be definite malpractice, after a thorough reading of the medical records by a medical expert- might not even be close to malpractice.
I saw this happen personally quite a few times .Once when a local VAMC vet appeared to have horrific malpractice case. He had the newspapers do a big story on the treatment he received and it read like a horror story. He contacted me through the VA Chaplain in Bath and sent me some of his med recs. (Some)and the newspaper article.
Long story- he said he had lawyers interested in his case but failed to get lawyer and filed the SF 95 himself-but too late.I had reminded him many times to get that filed because time was runnng out and I knew the exact SOL date. I had told him to seek a vet rep who had an office right next to the VA chapel where I met this vet for a Section 1151 claim and I gave him a note for the rep as to what I felt was a good 1151 basis here and would help with the claim.He said he filed it there but they didnt know him and had no record of it-
When I finally got the entire medical record package I saw right away that the VA could well mitigate any damages that this veteran claimed to have. There was documentation in the record that he been abusive to the VA staff and had not been compliant at all with his care. He started to even get abusive and controlling with me because I could not file anything for him.Nor make any statement to support his contentions.He needed a vet rep to do that.There was a lot more to all this but my point is-
what can certainly seem like medical error and negligence might not even be close to that scenario.
Only a good IMO doctor can really determine if negligence has occurred to a veteran and if not the veteran should have peace of mind knowing their medical care is,in fact, proper.
http://www.govtclaim.com/faq.html
http://www.lectlaw.com/def/f071.htm
http://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/article-29705.html
http://www.vamalpractice.com/
http://74.125.93.132/custom?q=cache:s64sCD...326217334650925
This Office of General Counsel Precedent Opinion shows how offsets are impacted by attorney fees.
Since this is an old opinion it is best to check the OGC Opinions site via the VA web site to see if anything else has altered this Pres Op or if there are any subsequent opinions regarding FTCA or 1151 claims that could impact your claims.
The National Veterans Legal Program Veterans Benefits Manual (VBM)
This legal text is available for purchase at the NVLSP web site.
It gives a good but brief overview of FTCA and Section 1151 claims- advising however that FTCA issues should be handled by attorneys.It does not get into the fine points of FTCA law.
The only legal information I had for my FTCA claim was basically what I found in the VBM as the internet in those days had no way to find FTCA information.The info was great but very limited.
I also used a law library for questions I had but could not find answers to in the VBM.
Also the BVA has cases regarding offsets.
They have 2 of my cases there in this regard.In the first claim the BVA was wrong.
In the second case they were correct.
The initial error they made was corrected by the Regional Counsel a few years ago.
I had a more recent offset matter. The OGC and the RC tried to blow me off.(I dealt with lawyers who knew all about my past FTCA case and who I had dealt with before and I had phone contact with them as well as email and snail mail) Persistence paid off.
I told them I was right based on established VA case law which I rattled off every chance I got.
Soon after that ordeal they agreed with me and I await the results now from the regional office.
It sure pays to have a lawyer however to save the time and rigamorale some of this stuff takes.VA lawyers are smart and can be cunning and manipulative-and they know VA case law in and out. I have tremendous respect for their expertise.
FTCA can succeed without lawyer or IMO but it is very difficult to do that.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
2
Popular Days
Jan 20
1
Jan 21
1
Top Posters For This Question
Berta 2 posts
Popular Days
Jan 20 2010
1 post
Jan 21 2010
1 post
1 answer to this question
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now