Jump to content
  • Advertisemnt

  • 14 Questions about VA Disability Compensation Benefits Claims


    When a Veteran starts considering whether or not to file a VA Disability Claim, there are a lot of questions that he or she tends to ask. Over the last 10 years, the following are the 14 most common basic questions I am asked about ...
    Continue Reading
  • Ads

  • Most Common VA Disabilities Claimed for Compensation:   


  • Advertisemnt

  • VA Watchdog

  • Advertisemnt

  • Ads

  • Can a 100 percent Disabled Veteran Work and Earn an Income?

    employment 2.jpeg

    You’ve just been rated 100% disabled by the Veterans Affairs. After the excitement of finally having the rating you deserve wears off, you start asking questions. One of the first questions that you might ask is this: It’s a legitimate question – rare is the Veteran that finds themselves sitting on the couch eating bon-bons … Continue reading

  • Searches Community Forums, Blog and more

  • Ad Free Subscription.jpgOne Time Financial Gift.jpg

    Subscriptions and Gifts are NOT Tax Deductible. HadIt.com is NOT a Non Profit.

  • 0

Mariano V Principi


I posted this link for LZ Jump today but this discussion bears repeating here:

Help - Search - Members - Calendar

Full Version: Doctor Shopping Or Fishing Expedition

hadit.com Veterans Forum > General VA Claims Questions & Information > (VA Claims Research) Veterans Affairs Claims and Benefits Research


Jan 6 2009, 11:31 AM

Does someone have the rule handy on what we refer to as

"Doctor Shopping or Fishing Expedition".

Thanks for any and all help.



Jan 6 2009, 12:02 PM

Carlie- Mariano V Principi was supposed to stop doctor shopping and fishing expeditions.

I used Mariano and put this BVA citation into my AMC response:

"The BVA has referenced a holding in Mariano thus:

“The probative evidence in this case demonstrates that it is

at least as likely as not that the veteran's hypertension

developed as a result of his service-connected diabetes

mellitus. Significantly, there is no probative evidence to

the contrary. See Mariano v. Principi, 17 Vet. App. 305,

312 (2003) (holding that the Board is not permitted to seek

additional development for the purpose of obtaining evidence

against the claim).”

from: http://www.va.gov/vetapp08/files3/0820535.txt"

The BVA threw out the first VA doc opinion against my claim and ordered a New opinion-

I had raised Mariano in my I-9. But I raised this case again for the AMC as I was worried that the "new" VA opinion could still incorporate the old opinion which both Dr. Bash and I successfully knocked down.

Also the VBM 208 edition makes this point on page 105:

"If the veteran has submitted a private opinion in his or her favor,the VA may grant the claim without developing negative evidence."

I helped a vet with no rating at all get 100% TDIU in four months due to his extensive psychiatric rcords from a private physician.

I expected that VA could have awarded on my first 2004 IMO or at least on the second one from 2006. The BVA read these for the first time in late September and an examiner- hopefully read them during the recent AMC medical review.

I feel that if the VA has enough info to justify an award- whether from a private doctor or VA doctor- the claim should be awarded.

Even if the claim has probative medical evidence from a private doc, then any negative opinion from VA could be challenged and if these opinions are of equal weight-the vet should still succeed under Relative Equipoise.

I felt that the VA was seeking a "new" opinion in my case because their old opinion wouldnt stand up to Dr. Bash's.

But I also feel that if all of my evidence was properly considered -to include my FTCA stuff- the new VA opinion should award the claim.


Jan 6 2009, 09:46 PM

Thanks Berta,



Jan 7 2009, 12:09 AM

Is requesting a C&P exam the same as Dr. Shopping if there is sufficent medical evidence to support SC or even if a C&P examiners opinion differs from the other medical evidence in support, does it mean that the evidence is in relative equipoise, provided they do not find the prior medical opinion was made in error?

Rockhound Rider cool.gif


Jan 7 2009, 12:51 AM

Are you having Gimli help too? works for me! smiles.

Good question, but what I understand VA may require a C&P exam at any time, I can't refuse a C & P exam or reexamination. Even if I feel I've provided more than adequate evidence from private physician sources, VA will could request a C & P exam by one of their own examiners. Then I read that failure to report for such exam may result in an interruption or even termination of benefits.

Not sure if relative equipose is applicable until applied AFTER the va goes through their determination steps.


QUOTE (Rockhound @ Jan 7 2009, 12:09 AM) *

Is requesting a C&P exam the same as Dr. Shopping if there is sufficent medical evidence to support SC or even if a C&P examiners opinion differs from the other medical evidence in support, does it mean that the evidence is in relative equipoise, provided they do not find the prior medical opinion was made in error?

Rockhound Rider cool.gif


Jan 7 2009, 02:08 AM

That's basically what I am saying. Knowing that you must attend a C&P exam and the examiner gives a differing opinion/diagnosis, but fails to support his diagnosis by finding/showing the prior diagnosis was made in error, does this mean that the evidence is in equipoise? You have one opinion for one diagnosis which supports SC and you have another with a differing diagnosis that doesn't support SC wouldn't this one for and one against mean that the decision should be in favor to SC for the Veteran?

Without the all important statement from the differing opinion/diagnosis that the prior opinion/diagnosis was made in error, then wouldn't the evidence be in equipoise?

Rockhound Rider cool.gif


Jan 7 2009, 04:18 AM

To the Rock'ster! Found this great discussion in hadit archives. hope it helps.


http://www.hadit.com/forums/lofiversion/index.php/t948.html titled 'A change in diagnosis in a orginal claim'


Jan 7 2009, 05:46 AM

Its strange that the VA can call a Veteran on Doctor shopping but their hired guns don't count.

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

0 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

There have been no answers to this question yet

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Our picks

    • Type 1 Diabetes recent onset!
      I was diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes in September 2017 OUT OF NOWHERE.

      i am a Navy Reservist and deployed in later 2009 to mid 2010 and again later 2014 to mid 2015; had a 2 year recall between those deployments.  

      Only healthcare received since commissioning in 2008 was from the Navy and no issues EVER.

      insulin dependent and have dietary restrictions and in a non deployable status.

      VA denied initial claim due to Type 1 not showing on active duty and now appealing.

      Anyone with successful experience getting a rating with my circumstances?  I live in Upstate New York.
      • 9 replies
    • Agent Orange Kadena Afb Okinawa
      I am looking for anyone who was on Kadena AFB, Okinawa or .Chanute AFB, IL. My dad was there from Oct. 68-April 70. He has ichemic heart disease, diabetes which has resulted in the amputation of his right leg below the knee and peripheral neuropathy. We were denied in 2002 AMVETS filed a claim on his behalf for heart condition, diabetes and back problems. I refiled in December 2011 and have just received the claim statements and medical release forms. I am familiar with filling out this paper work because my husband is a combat veteran of Iraqi Freedom. I have been reading articles from the Japan times and I am a member of the Agent Orange Okinawa facebook page. Another thing that helps make my dad's case is that he was on Chanute AFB, IL and it is on the EPA Superfund list and has PCBs/Pesticides and Dioxins/Furans listed as ground and water contaminants. I welcome any advice, tips or articles that I may have missed in my own research.
        • Like
      • 15 replies
    • CBO Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028 Published Dec 2018
      CBO Options for Reducing the Deficit: 2019 to 2028 - This CBO Report has been making the news. This post includes parts relevant to veterans. Nothing has been decided as of yet and some seem very unlikely but you never know. Forewarned is Forearmed.


      • 10 replies
    • 2019 Veterans Benefits
      State Benefits, Space A and More ... https://www.hadit.com/2019-changes-to-veterans-benefits-state-and-federal/
      • 2 replies
    • Appeal granted and closed.
      My appeal was granted and closed on November 9.  I got an unofficial notification from the DAV on November 15 stating "appeal granted with an evaluation of 30%" which is great!  My question is this:  How long until I get the official notification from the va? Nothing on ebennies has updated since the appeal closed. Appeal is now in historical and just says complete and at originating va office. I understand no one knows va timelines to a tee but a general timeline would be great.  Thank you all! Hope you have a Merry Christmas!


      Edit:  This was my first time appealing and it was a VBA grant. 
        • Like
      • 6 replies
  • Ads

  • Popular Contributors

  • Ad

  • Latest News
  • Create New...

Important Information

{terms] and Guidelines