Jump to content
  • veteranscrisisline-badge-chat-1.gif

  • Advertisemnt

  • Trouble Remembering? This helped me.

    I have memory problems and as some of you may know I highly recommend Evernote and have for years. Though I've found that writing helps me remember more. I ran across Tom's videos on youtube, I'm a bit geeky and I also use an IPad so if you take notes on your IPad or you are thinking of going paperless check it out. I'm really happy with it, I use it with a program called Noteshelf 2.

    Click here to purchase your digital journal. HadIt.com receives a commission on each purchase.

  • 14 Questions about VA Disability Compensation Benefits Claims


    When a Veteran starts considering whether or not to file a VA Disability Claim, there are a lot of questions that he or she tends to ask. Over the last 10 years, the following are the 14 most common basic questions I am asked about ...
    Continue Reading
  • Ads

  • Most Common VA Disabilities Claimed for Compensation:   


  • Advertisemnt

  • VA Watchdog

  • Advertisemnt

  • Ads

  • Can a 100 percent Disabled Veteran Work and Earn an Income?

    employment 2.jpeg

    You’ve just been rated 100% disabled by the Veterans Affairs. After the excitement of finally having the rating you deserve wears off, you start asking questions. One of the first questions that you might ask is this: It’s a legitimate question – rare is the Veteran that finds themselves sitting on the couch eating bon-bons … Continue reading

Sign in to follow this  

Would This Qualify For Some Type Of Smc

Recommended Posts

Hi all,

Would this qualify for some type of SMC and if so what type (SMC S, etc.)

Vets C&P exam states that vet needs help getting dressed, shaving (can't stand in front of mirror), can't put on his knee brace, has a shower chair so he can shower himself. It also states he notes it has gotten him to a point where he can do very little. Needs assistance dressing (can't lift arms), needs assistance shaving; can no longer cook various menu items for he and his wife because of neck pain and because he can't stand in order to cook. Can no longer bowl. Can no longer do yardwork.

Vet is 100% TDIU P&T. His combined rating is 80%. L Knee condition 60%,C-spine condition 20%, R Knee condition 10%, and L Thigh Atrophy 10%.

Thanks in advance for your replies.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

IMHO, YES, he should be eligible for additional compensation. There are 3 possibilities:

1. Bradley vs Peake may apply, entitling you to SMC S. Its rather complex, but it sounds like you have "100 plus 60", because Bradley specifically states that TDIU can "sub" for the 100 part.

2. You may also be eligible for Housebound, (in fact), which is also paid at the SMC S rate, as above.

3. Lastly, he may be able to get "Aid and Attendance", which is a greater benefit than those above.

I recommend applying for the "A and A" benefit AND SMC S. You wont get both, tho. The VA will give you the highest they think you are eligible for..either SMC S or A and A. I think you have a "good shot", based on what you posted, as a minimum of SMC S, or maybe even A and A.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

To qualify for statutory SMC S, Housebound a veteran must be rated 100% and have an additional seperate rating of 60%, or show the actual need for housebound.

To qualify for SMC S , House bound, Under Bradley v Peake, a veteran must have been awarded TDIu based on one disability rated at least 60% and have an additonal seperate disability of 60%. This veteran does not meet the requirement of Bradley v peake.

Aid and attendance (A&A) is only payable to veterans that are rated 100% (not TDIU) and the vetean must show an actual need.

The veteran may qualify for SMC S based on actual need, but he will have to request it, and may have to have a c/p to specifically address the need for SMC.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

As Teac pointed out, there are two ways to qualify for housebound:

1. First, if you meet the "100 plus 60" as in Bradley vs Peake, then the VA must infer your eligibility for housebound and you should not have to do anything to apply for it. (In practice, I would go ahead and apply because, if you have not gotten it, then it sounds like something went wrong and the VA did not infer it.)

2. If you are housebound in fact, that is, you meet the legal defination of housebound WITHOUT qualifying for the "100 plus 60" in Bradley vs Peak, then you have to apply for housebound..it wont be inferred.

There is at least one instance when a Veteran can get Aid and Attendance and NOT be 100%. That would be Pension Aid and Attendance. With Pension A & A you qualify on a bases of need (this generally means low income, and not too many assets), but you still have to meet the guidelines for A and A.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am totally confused. With the ratings listed below are you saying his total ratings is 100 plus 60. If not what is his total ratings: He is:

60% left knee injury; 10% scaring secondary to left knee injury; 10% left thigh atrophy seconary to left knee injury; 10% right knee condition secondary to left knee injury; 20% cervical spine condition secondary to left knee injury. He has been granted TDIU P&T.

His C&P states: "Entitlement to IU is granted because the claimant is unable to secure or follow a substantially gainful occupation as a result of service-connected disabilities.

The BVA remanded your case to obtain medical opinions on the issue of whether or not your service connected conditions render you unable to secure or follow substantial employment. At your Spine examination, the examiner stated that due to your cervical injury you would not be employable in your former occupation as a chef because your range of motion limitations would restrict your abilities to perform the job functions. He opined that due to constant pain and limitation of motion, you would be unable to secure or follow a gainful occupation due to your service connected disabilities. The Joints examiner stated that your knee and tibia issues render you unemployable because you are unable to sit or stand for prolonged period of time. Entitlement to IU is granted effective May 29, 2009, your date of claim."

Are you saying the 100% TDIU is considered separate from his left knee injury and all its secondariees and that is what qualifies him the 100 plus 60. Please tell me whether this is true or not.

Thanks in advance for all the replies.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Mikeoif
      I filed for tdiu and ptsd claim in Oct of 18, I didn't have all my medical files lined up and was given service connection for unspecified anxiety at 30% in March 19, and denied tdiu for failed scheduled rating needed and they mentioned that I had work experince and helped for a year with my niece , weird mention in the paperwork for why tdiu was denied but whatever. So I filed supplemental claim in april and had a highly regarded univeristy brain department and psychiatrist department diagnosis me for ptsd as a referral from the VA. So boom got another c&p in June and was given 70 % rating for ptsd but didn't file anything for the tdiu, at this time hired a va lawyer before I got my 70% rating thinking id have to appeal if they denied my ptsd again but they didn't so then I kept the lawyers on as they looked at my files for more things to be done and then they had me file tdiu paper work again but then on OCT 31st they filed a higher level review for my TDIU decision going back to march when it was denied. My two questions are how does HLR handle tdiu claims and cause I was denied originally for it for lack of rating and lack of medical evidence does my new c&p in June and my medical diagnosis with recommendation that got me to 70% now, will that evidence be included in the review of the tdiu or is the Review just of the evidence that was available at the time of the original denial back in march? I've been out of work for over a year as well but haven't kept a job down for a decade though I've tried for sure. OIF 08-09 1-22 INF, 1 BCT, 4th I.D. Also do granted my tdiu effective date should be Oct 2018 right as my intent to file date? Thanks
    • By drewdabbs
      This may have been answered elsewhere but as a long time lurker I have not been able to find it. A brief background. I am at 80% SC (70% for a mental health disorder, 10% for a couple of physical disabilities). But nearly all of this has been awarded through BVA appeal process that has been on going since 2009. Part of the appeal has been TDIU. In short the RO did not automatically send the 21-8940 to start the process when I hit 70% RO and I didn't know I qualified. Once I did know I appealed and it became a part of the 2009 ongoing BVA appeal, but joined it in about 2014. A social/industrial survey was ordered (2015) but not completed as the social worker at the hospital completing it didn't know what it was (he thought it was a survey of current patients). So the BVA appeal has gone back to the common BVA Remand to RO SSoC to BVA Remand tennis game for a few years. A mess.

      Here are my current questions: I have been awarded new service connections and ratings since the TDIU denial part joined the appeal. I have also moved, so the 2009 appeal is at the original RO where is any new claim would go to my, now, more local RO.
      1). is there any way possible to file for TDIU now, through my local office since new service connected disabilities are present?
      2). Just general opinion if you could, but I had been told that it is detrimental to an appeal to request that RO handling the case be changed or moved to the most recent or local RO. Does anyone have any insight if this is actually true? The old RO is a hassle, its keeps sending appointments and decisions to the old address no matter how many times and ways I update my address, for instance.
      Thanks vets, any help I get I'll try and pay it forward.
    • By mikeriggs
      I filed a claim in october of 2018 for ptsd and TDIU, long story short I tried to do everything myself and didn't have the proper diagnosis so I was service connected for anxiety based on having a medical marijuana card diagnosis for anxiety but the rating was 30% and I much worse off then that. So I obtained a referral from the va to a fancy psychiatrist from the university of north florida's behavior health department and was diagnosed with ptsd, bi polar 1 and panic disorder. I used this new medical evidence as my supplemental claim evidence and filed it April 16, 2019 after receiving my letter March 20, 2019. My claim is now at Pending Decision Approval with an estimated completion date of july 2, 2019 which is super fast from all I have read. My question is, Am I going to be awarded tdiu with the evidence I submitted if they adjust me up to 70% which I think it will . Or if they award 70% for ptsd on this new supplemental claim will i have to re-apply for tdiu again? Or would that all be considered in the final review of the entire claim? Thanks for any help.
      1-22 1BCT 4th I.D. "Regulars by God"
    • By MsAsya
      I first found this forum after I started my claim Aug 7, 2018. This was 10 years after my discharge. I had done everything I could to stay away from the military after my experience and had never even been to the VA before this year. I prepared my claim myself and was concerned I would be denied. I posted my c and p exam results here October 31, 2018 and members commented on their thoughts of success or failure, and said I would get about 50%. I then took my exam results to the Veteran rep here at my local unemployment office who told me ultimately I would be denied and should appoint a representative and prepare for appeal. I choose the DAV and left with my spirits a little crushed, but after reading people stories here I knew I had to remain hopeful. Nov. 29, 2018 I received an email from the DAV with the Decision that had been made even before I could see it. The email stated I had been service-connected at 70% PTSD permanent, also approved for TDIU and Dependent Education, but Ebenefits still said pending approval. So again I came to the forums for assistance and posted a copy of the email. I was met with congratulatory responses and assurance that the email was legit. @GeekySquid then messaged me a ton of information about benefits that were now available to me. It was from that information I was able to start the process of getting my life back on track. Im currently working with VR&E also known as Voc Rehab, to go back to school. Geeky told me they would give me hard time but to be persistent and it paid off my counselor has approved my long term goal of a Masters Degree🤗. I can not put in words how thankful I am for this forum and its Members.
    • By Point_break
      I'm put in my claims for PTSD and migraines. I plan on filing for TDIU due to both. I'm currently in a protected work environment. I was also fired from my last job because of my migraines. Would the VA send me in for another C&P exam right after just having gone through one? 
  • Ads

  • Our picks

    • 14 Questions about VA Disability Compensation Benefits Claims
      When a Veteran starts considering whether or not to file a Veterans Affairs Disability Claim, there are a lot of questions that he or she tends to ask. Over the last 10 years, the following are the 14 most common basic questions I am asked about when it comes to filing Veterans Affairs Disability Claims. [Reprinted here with permission from Veterans Law Blog]
      • 0 replies
    • Disabled Veterans Property Tax Exemptions by State
      A disabled veteran in Alabama may receive a full property tax exemption on his/her primary residence if the veteran is 100 percent disabled as a result of service and has a net annual income of $12,000 or less.
      • 0 replies
    • Thanks everyone for their answers and advise and yes Ido have a VSO American legion but unfortunately I still have to manage to work and call times are mornings only almost impossible to talk with him.

       I am gonna try to get ahold of him tomorrow but u have to call right at 0730 eastern OR call list fills and never get on his list sucks!

      The worst thing I’m going through is that I’m stuck in limbo I can’t file on my other things I can’t add nothing I can’t do anything basically my hands are tied, this is complete wearing on me mentally Not to mention I’ve been out of the service since 95 was six service-connected disabilities and then thrown to the wayside as a young adult with no knowledge of how what or when by the VA  now that I’m middle-aged my service-connected disabilities Have gotten so severe that I have multiple secondaries until I came across by chance a VSO in my county that helped me out back in 15 I’d still be at a loss and left at the wayside forgotten about now that I’ve been back in the system And have a 80% rating the VA now is trying to drop two of my ratings because I feel that this DRO rview is going to put me at 100% or really close  in a way to just keep us down and out and causing worse injuries by forcing ourselves to do what we have to as humans to survive in the workforce that you can’t really physically do anymore sucks all the way around! 
    • Need your support - Please buy a mug or a membership
      had to move to a dedicated server this month and our costs have gone up, if you have been thinking about subscribing to an ad free forum or buying a mug now would a very helpful time to do that.

      Thank you for your support
      • 16 replies
    • Permanent and Total from cck-law..com
      1:10 What is Permanent and Total Disability?

      2:05 Conditions that automatically receive a permanent and total rating (P&T)

      2:32 Conditions less likely to receive P&T

      4:29 How to find out if your VA rating is permanent

      6:03 Is there a VA form to apply for Perm and Total status?

      6:39 Viewer Question: If you have permanent and total Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI), are you automatically entitled to P&T disability at the VA?

      8:03 If you receive Total Disability for Individual Unemployability (TDIU), are you permanent and total?

      8:26 The advantages of having Permanent and Total VA Disability Other Protections from VA Rating Reductions

      10:26 Stabilized Ratings

      11:26 Continuous Ratings

      12:57 What to do if VA proposes a rating reduction

      16:03 Final Thoughts & Tips


      • 8 replies
  • Ads

  • Popular Contributors

  • Ad

  • Latest News
  • Create New...

Important Information

{terms] and Guidelines