Jump to content
VA Disability Community via Hadit.com

VA Disability Claims Articles

Ask Your VA Claims Question | Current Forum Posts Search | Rules | View All Forums
VA Disability Articles | Chats and Other Events | Donate | Blogs | New Users

  • hohomepage-banner-2024-2.png

  • 27-year-anniversary-leaderboard.png

    advice-disclaimer.jpg

  • donate-be-a-hero.png

  • 0

Question About Bva Decisions

Rate this question


Computer Tech

Question

I know that BVA decisions only apply to the vet that in the decision.I'm a Air Force Thailand vet that was assigned to Korat RTAFB and worked on the perimeter of Camp Friendship which was adjsent to Korat. This spring a vet who was at Korat at the same time I was and worked in the same building on the perimeter of Camp Friendship granting him service connection for DMII due to exposure to herbicides. My question is would it benefit me to submit a copy of the decision in support of my claim for DMII and IHD.

Thanks for the help.

Rick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Answers 9
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters For This Question

Top Posters For This Question

Recommended Posts

Hello Rick,

This is a great question. And it looks like that it could mean "setting precedence" but we are talking about VA law and it is much more difficult than other courts of law, where precedence is taken as literal law and supported.

I believe that this will help in your fight but in most cases the individual that is applying for say direct exposure issues utilizing this type of evidence has usually been denied by VAROs. Because each Veterans case at the Regional Office levels eyes are just that. They are different and because the ROs do whatever they want to , legal or illegal. Adjudicating a claim at that level does not mean they have to accept this duplicate type of evidence. However this means that taken at probative value in the BVA could still not be enough until it reaches the CAVA arena. Then it can mean that it could be accepted and help win your claim. So this could be a longer more prolonged battle to get your evidence accepted but at the next level or beyond. From what I have read on CAVA cases they are a Federal Court which normally takes precedence opinions and remembering that this is the Federal Court Level and not associated with VA or BVA. It could mean a looooongggg battle.

The VARO has a continous habit of trying to deny duplicate evidence from another veteran. This subject came up not long ago and I believe it was Carlie that supplied some other comments that also showed the hostile approach the ROs have with this type of evidence presenting. However I do believe in the long run it can be used but it may be later in your battle. Our own Berta Simmons has had quite some experience with this too in some other AO cases. So you may want to search her older posts and do some archive studies of BVA cases.

I will say that there was some more discussion on James Cripps case being the first Continental US Agent Orange Case from Fort Gordon , GA. Since his claim other Fort Gordon soldiers have won theirs from the same type of evidence. And I think it was at the RO level. Maybe James will be watching this thread and comment for us. Or perhaps Carlie will add to this opinion. I will tell you that I am fighting a huge battle utilizing this type of profile of evidence and it is complicated.

I hope more will chime in on this as it is going to show up more and more especially with chemical exposure Veterans from a known area that has already been deemed as contaminated from other Veterans claims. Still at any level of the process, the Veteran must remember to ......NEVER GIVE UP. God Bless, C.C.

Edited by Capt.Contaminate
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only thing I can personally say the BVA will accept internet searches that validate an illiness and case studies and tests done on others with the same diagnoses, however they would not accept actual claims previously decided copies. I did internet searches of studies done all around the world and linked to my specific diagnose. These were accepted and used along the process in my favor. Was advised not to send case claims previously done via BVA. Guess it's like using someone's term paper for your research. Again this is my personal experience and via my VSO VFW in Washington D.C. and their attorneys/legal consultants..(Also not accepted with RO) This was a few years ago...doubt it changed but one never knows...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Moderator

Rick:

I think I would go "one layer deeper". Let me explain.

When you get a BVA decision, they always cite precedential case law. So, if you have a similar case, dont cite the BVA case...cite instead the precedential case law cited in the BVA decision.

Its a little more complicated to go the extra level, but if you take the time to do just that, it may well be worth it for you. You see, you probably will have to cite 3 or 4 or even more CACV decisions, rather than just cite one BVA decision. Hope this helps.

I use similar BVA decisions as a "basis of study", and then study the cited CAVC decisions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks bronco,

I've submitted the same evidence to the RO as the vet had, in fact a lot of the stuff that he submitted I had sent him. I had been wonder if I should send a copy of the vet's BVA decision more or less to tell the RO that the BVA has already ruled that the building was near the perimeter so let's not waste time and grant me service connection. I think that I'll just wait to see what they decided on my DMII NOD and reopened IHD claim. Hopefully they'll read the evidence that I've submitted instead of ignoring it.

Rick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello Rick,

I want you to know that I did the same thing you are doing. Sent a BVA hearing that was supportive of my claim and it was banged down at the RO level. They love to use the phrase ... OF NO PROBATIVE VALUE.I know this is not what you want to hear, but it may be your ammo will be alot hotter when it gets to the BVA or above if necessary. I personally like what you are trying to do and think it will prevail , though maybe alittle later. It still is part of the Cfile and has to be dealt with by someone who can read. I also hope you have a good VARO and not one of the ones that have had nothing but trouble and delays for Veterans. You might accidentally slip this one thru. NEVER GIVE UP. God Bless, C.C.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Capt;

I don't plan to ever give up and I've already told my boys that if anything happens to me to get my claims transfered to their mother's name. I've submitted a copy of the Checo report, a map showing where my building was located in reference to the perimeter fence, a performance report that showed I was assigned to the Audodin building on Camp Friendship along with a personal statement, a buddy letter and pictures of the area. They denied the claim saying that no herbicides were used in Thailand and seeing as I didn't serve in Vietnam I couldn't have been exposed to herbicides. When I filed my NOD for DMII I resubmitted the same evidence saying that they had ignored the evidence that I had submitted, I added a copy of the May 2010 C&P bulletin in which the VA acknowledged that herbicides were sprayed on the permiters of the air bases and army camps, I also added a second buddy letter. Now I wait, been waiting since Aug of 2011. I had also filed a claim for IHD which they closed beciasue I hadn't served in Vietnam so Nehmyer didn't apply to me. I reopened the IHD claim this past March citing their ignoring the evidence that supported my claim of being exposed to herbicides. I know that I'll eventually win but I hate the idea of having to wait another three or four years for it to get to the BVA.

My claim is at the LA RO and they are backlogged, a cliam is taking over 300 days and a NOD over 600.

Rick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines and Terms of Use