Jump to content
VA Disability Community via Hadit.com

VA Disability Claims Articles

Ask Your VA Claims Question | Current Forum Posts Search | Rules | View All Forums
VA Disability Articles | Chats and Other Events | Donate | Blogs | New Users

  • hohomepage-banner-2024-2.png

  • 27-year-anniversary-leaderboard.png

    advice-disclaimer.jpg

  • donate-be-a-hero.png

  • 0

Was My Exam Just A Dream? - Knee Rom 5260/5261

Rate this question


K_C

Question

The Experience: Just had my first C&P on Monday and was able to read the report yesterday. The doctor was polite and seemed genuinely compassionate, but the exam felt hurried. In fact, I was called on my mobile phone fifteen minutes after the exam, by the doctor himself, to come back because he forgot to perform an important part of it. I'm grateful he called me back in rather than scheduling or just using his imagination to conjure something up. There are many errors and oversights, though some are in my favor, most are unfavorable. The report is more inaccurate than it is accurate. Although I was prepared for this by HadIt (Thank You!) and my other research, it's nonetheless frustrating. I have already prepared my rebuttal to perceived mistakes so my account of the exam is freshly documented. I am also considering a call to the Patient Advocate office per the advice of my VSO--but, I'm on the fence about it. I just can't help but ask myself, jokingly, if I am completely delusional, because it certainly would be the case if I believed what's on the report actually took place.

Medical History & The DBQ: I have substantial pain in both of my knees, it's why I was discharged. Historical and continuous chondromalacia/patellafemoral and IT band syndrome diagnoses. During range of motion testing, the doctor was able to lift both legs to full extension. It was obviously painful and he apologized for causing the pain. In active range of motion, there's no question that I lacked full extension and suffered even greater pain. However, his report contrarily indicates full range in every motion and "no pain" on each measurement. (Side note: He actually used a goniometer, unlike many of the stories I've read here). He also indicated no scars, which is false. How could he know if my legs were clothed the entire exam? :blink:

Question: My question is regarding the knee range of motion testing. Never mind that he wrongly indicated no pain despite having apologized for such, I'm looking for clarification on painful vs actual range of motion for both passive and active. Is painful ROM to be considered in the actual measurement, in degrees, of passive range of motion? What about active range of motion? I ask because I read in another post here, if I understood it correctly, that for DC 5260 and DC 5261 (knee range of motion), the Mitchell criteria is that painful ROM is disregarded in measurement. This conflicts with everything I had read previously, and also with my own sensibilities, but nevertheless could be true. Just looking for clarification.

Thank you to everyone here in the HadIt community. Your posts have guided me to a great deal of information and greater understanding of the VA claims process. :wub:

* EDIT: I found a few unofficial documents that seem to state any reduction in ROM due to pain should be described by the examiner, if feasible. However, if pain in motion exists where ROM is not deemed as limited, then 10% is justified. Does that sound accurate? If so, does anyone know if the below indications from the doctor tie into the rating based on pain (10%), rather than ROM? I'm of course still confused how in one part the examiner can say there's no pain but in the other say that there is.

c. If the Veteran has functional loss, functional impairment or additional
limitation of ROM of the knee and lower leg after repetitive use,
indicate
the contributing factors of disability below (check all that apply and
indicate side affected):
[X] Pain on movement [ ] Right [ ] Left [X] Both
[X] Disturbance of locomotion [ ] Right [ ] Left [X] Both
[X] Other, describe:
crepitus
Edited by whalenkcj
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Answers 9
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters For This Question

Top Posters For This Question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Congrats on the 30% bud. As far as the knee the Doc is full of crap. I have had multiple knee surgeries and when I was Medically Retired last year the VA awarded SC for R Knee at 0% due to ACL/MCL surgery residuals. So I put in for an increase last Sep 13 and instead of the VA increasing the 0% SC, they awarded me 10% for R Knee due to Painful Motion. So my recent claim that completed last week the VA denied my 0% R Knee Increase, and the L Knee as Secondary to 0% denied too. So when I submitted my 3rd FDC last week, I requested L Knee Secondary to the R Knee 10% painful motion SC rating. I have multiple conditions that the VA denied as one condition, changed the wording and granted SC %. My Asthma was denied even though it is documented due to Black Spots on my lungs from my 5 years in OIF/OEF exposed to the SH** fires along with other chemicals. I have never smoked by the way. So what I did, instead of reopening the claim for Asthma, I claimed it as Dyspnea secondary to my 70% PTSD rating, as I do suffer from Panic and Anxiety attacks. I am not as good at the Regs as a lot of good folks on here, but when the Condition is legitimate and is well documented, there is always a way around the VA wording. God Bless

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

If you google the 'DeLuca Factor hadit.com 'you will find posts here on how VA considers pain as a factor in many disability situations.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines and Terms of Use