Jump to content

  • veteranscrisisline-badge-chat-1.gif

  • Advertisemnt

  • Trouble Remembering? This helped me.

    I have memory problems and as some of you may know I highly recommend Evernote and have for years. Though I've found that writing helps me remember more. I ran across Tom's videos on youtube, I'm a bit geeky and I also use an IPad so if you take notes on your IPad or you are thinking of going paperless check it out. I'm really happy with it, I use it with a program called Noteshelf 2.

    Click here to purchase your digital journal. HadIt.com receives a commission on each purchase.

  • 14 Questions about VA Disability Compensation Benefits Claims


    When a Veteran starts considering whether or not to file a VA Disability Claim, there are a lot of questions that he or she tends to ask. Over the last 10 years, the following are the 14 most common basic questions I am asked about ...
    Continue Reading
  • Ads

  • Most Common VA Disabilities Claimed for Compensation:   


  • Advertisemnt

  • VA Watchdog

  • Advertisemnt

  • Ads

  • Can a 100 percent Disabled Veteran Work and Earn an Income?

    employment 2.jpeg

    You’ve just been rated 100% disabled by the Veterans Affairs. After the excitement of finally having the rating you deserve wears off, you start asking questions. One of the first questions that you might ask is this: It’s a legitimate question – rare is the Veteran that finds themselves sitting on the couch eating bon-bons … Continue reading

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  

MST C&P exam contradictory


I recently had my c&p for mst ptsd.  The c&p examiner diagnosed me with ptsd.  The stressor was MST.  Her opinion on the DQB form was MST.  

However, she wrote that she couldn't say without speculation if my stressor contributed to my diagnosis.  The rater sent the exam back to her for clarification saying that she said on the DBQ that attributed my ptsd diagnosis with the MST but her written opinion said something different.  She responded and stated the same thing that she couldn't say without speculating that the stressor caused the ptsd.   

What do I make of this?  

 1. Diagnostic Summary  

   Does the Veteran have a diagnosis of PTSD that conforms to DSM-5 criteria    based on today's evaluation?    [X] Yes   [ ] No           ICD code:  F43.10        

  2. Current Diagnoses      a. Mental Disorder Diagnosis #1: PTSD           ICD code: F43.10
    b. Medical diagnoses relevant to the understanding or management of the       mental health disorder (to include TBI): none identified
    3. Differentiation of symptoms    -----------------------------    a. Does the Veteran have more than one mental disorder diagnosed? 

 [ ] Yes   [X] No          

c. Does the Veteran have a diagnosed traumatic brain injury (TBI)?       [ ] Yes   [ ] No   [X] Not shown in records reviewed        

  4. Occupational and social impairment    ------------------------------------    a. Which of the following best summarizes the Veteran's level of occupational       and social impairment with regards to all mental diagnoses? (Check only       one)       [X] Occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity
    b. For the indicated occupational and social impairment, is it possible to       differentiate which impairment is caused by each mental disorder?       [ ] Yes   [ ] No   [X] Not Applicable (N/A)           c. If a diagnosis of TBI exists, is it possible to differentiate which       occupational and social impairment indicated above is caused by the TBI?       [ ] Yes   [ ] No   [X] Not Applicable (N/A) 

              SECTION II:        

Clinical Findings:  

1. Evidence Review    Evidence reviewed (check all that apply):        [X] VA e-folder    [X] CPRS
 3. Stressors 

Describe one or more specific stressor event(s) the Veteran considers    traumatic (may be pre-military, military, or post-military):      

 a. Stressor #1: Veteran repors verbal harrassment at her unit from 2004-2006   and being sexually assaulted in 2006          
          Does this stressor meet Criterion A (i.e., is it adequate to support          the diagnosis of PTSD)?          [X] Yes  [ ] No            

       Is the stressor related to the Veteran's fear of hostile military or          terrorist activity?          [ ] Yes  [X] No                        If no, explain:                reported MST 

    Is the stressor related to personal assault, e.g. military sexual          trauma?          [X] Yes  [ ] No  

 If yes, please describe the markers that may substantiate the              stressor.                
 4. PTSD Diagnostic Criteria   

Note: Please check criteria used for establishing the current PTSD diagnosis.    Do NOT mark symptoms below that are clearly not attributable to the Criterion
 A stressor/PTSD.  Instead, overlapping symptoms clearly attributable to other    things should be noted under #7 - Other symptoms.  The diagnostic criteria    for PTSD, referred to as Criterion A-H, are from the Diagnostic and    Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th edition (DSM-5). 

Criterion (A) Exposure to actual or threatened a) death, b) serious injury,    c) sexual violence, in one or more of the following ways:  

                                    [X] Directly experiencing the traumatic event(s)

Criterion (B) Presence of (one or more) of the following intrusion symptoms  associated with the traumatic event(s), beginning after the  traumatic event(s) occurred:                                       [X] Recurrent, involuntary, and intrusive distressing memories of the traumatic event(s).                   [X] Recurrent distressing dreams in which the content and/or affect of the dream are related to the traumatic event(s).    [X] Intense or prolonged psychological distress at exposure to  internal or external cues that symbolize or resemble an   aspect of the traumatic event(s).

 Criterion (C) Persistent avoidance of stimuli associated with the traumatic event(s), beginning after the traumatic events(s) occurred,  as evidenced by one or both of the following:                         [X] Avoidance of or efforts to avoid external reminders  (people, places, conversations, activities, objects,  situations) that arouse distressing memories, thoughts, or                       feelings about or closely associated with the traumatic  event(s).
Criterion (D) Negative alterations in cognitions and mood associated with  the traumatic event(s), beginning or worsening after the traumatic event(s) occurred, as evidenced by two (or more) of  the following:

[X] Persistent, distorted cognitions about the cause or   consequences of the traumatic event(s) that lead the  individual to blame himself/herself or others.   [X] Markedly diminished interest or participation in  significant activities.   [X] Feelings of detachment or estrangement from others.

Criterion (E) Marked alterations in arousal and reactivity associated with  the traumatic event(s), beginning or worsening after the  traumatic event(s) occurred, as evidenced by two (or more) of  the following:   [X] Irritable behavior and angry outbursts (with little or no provocation) typically expressed as verbal or physical aggression toward people or objects. [X] Hypervigilance.   [X] Sleep disturbance (e.g., difficulty falling or staying asleep or restless sleep).

Criterion (F)                          [X] Duration of the disturbance (Criteria B, C, D, and E) is  more than 1 month.
Criterion (G)                          [X] The disturbance causes clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important  areas of functioning. Criterion (H)      

[X] The disturbance is not attributable to the physiological                       effects of a substance (e.g., medication, alcohol) or                       another medical condition.
Criterion (I)  Which stressor(s) contributed to the Veteran's PTSD  diagnosis?:    [X] Stressor #1
5. Symptoms    ----------    For VA rating purposes, check all symptoms that actively apply to the 

 [X] Depressed mood       [X] Anxiety       [X] Suspiciousness       [X] Panic attacks that occur weekly or less often       [X] Chronic sleep impairment       [X] Disturbances of motivation and mood       [X] Difficulty in establishing and maintaining effective work and social           relationships

 The following contentions need to be examined:       post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) personal trauma - mental disorders        (related to: PTSD - personal trauma)
       DBQ PSYCH PTSD Initial:
       Please review the Veteran's electronic folder in VBMS and state that it       was        reviewed in your report.
       TYPE OF MEDICAL OPINION REQUESTED: Military Sexual Trauma (MST)
       OPINION: Military Sexual Trauma (MST)

What the rater sent back to the examiner:

  Please return the exam to the examiner as on the exam she attributed the PTSD diagnosis to the Veterans MST and then in the separate opinion said     differently. Please have the examiner provide an opinion as to whether the     current PTSD diagnosis is at least as likely as not (50 percent or greater     probability) caused by or a result of the in-service MST-related marker(s),     and provide a rationale. Please note that only PTSD can be service connected based on circumstantial marker evidence    *****************************************************************************    *************

What the examiner wrote back:

Veteran's Service Treatment Records document the presence of events that VBA    has identifiend as potential markers for MST prior to the reported incident    as well as following the reported incident. Writer is unable to opine without    resorting to speculation if Veteran's diagnosis of PTSD is at least as likely    as not caused by or a result of the in-service MST-related marker.
    Determining if a MST stressor occurred is a legal issue not a clinical issue.    Writer is not qualified to opine if a specific marker is sufficient evidence    to support a claim of MST or if the absence of a marker is sufficient    evidence to dispute the claim of MST.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Recommended Posts

  • 0

 Looks like a 70% rating.. just my opinion.

This C&P Examiner can speculate  rather or MST caused/related to your MST PTSD.  with these 4 words


Make sure this examiner is qualified  to do a PTSD  MST C&P Exam.

Quote from Attorney Chris Attig

'' A medical examiner who states “no conclusion as to etiology or diagnosis can be reached without resorting to speculation” may be obligated to research medical literature; his/her conclusions as to service connection must reflect the limitations of knowledge in the medical community at large and not those of a particular examiner or doctor''

Read what Veteran Attorney  Chris Attig mentions about Speculation  from C&P Examiners



Edited by Buck52

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Thanks for the link.  I think she was qualified, she is a VA psychologist and seems to have a lot of training in this area.  I guess I'm just confused by the diagnosis and then the opinion.  Doesn't make a lot of sense to me how are the raters supposed to make a decision when their examiner couldn't.  


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Usually if you get a decent rater  one that will read your records and evidence  and this shows to be favorable to you  to make a decision   he will ,  if not then usually he will send it back to the examiner for clarification  and you may get another C&P hopefully with a different examiner.  it is what the rater decides if this examiner don't redo or do as the rater ask  or just deny the claim from lack of information on the examiners part.  if this happens  SEND IN YOUR NOD ASAP. if you have a MST PTSD Diagnose from the VA then you may want to get an IMO/IME from an qualified  Dr opinion.favorable to you.about your condition.



Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I will have to wait and see as my claim is pending decision approval.  It has moved quickly since my exam.  I appreciate the information.

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

So I got my envelope last night in the mail and my claim was denied.  The reason for denial is that the doctor couldn't opine without resorting to mere speculation.  Does anyone have any advice?  

I'm not sure how she came to that opinion when according to her exam, she diagnosed PTSD and related it to the stressor which was MST.  Doesn't make sense to me.  

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Ads

  • Our picks

    • Enough has been said on this topic. This forum is not the proper forum for an attorney and former client to hash out their problems. Please take this offline
    • Peggy toll free 1000 last week, told me that, my claim or case BVA Granted is at the RO waiting on someone to sign off ,She said your in step 5 going into step 6 . That's good, right.?
      • 7 replies
    • I took a look at your documents and am trying to interpret what happened. A summary of what happened would have helped, but I hope I am interpreting your intentions correctly:

      2003 asthma denied because they said you didn't have 'chronic' asthma diagnosis

      2018 Asthma/COPD granted 30% effective Feb 2015 based on FEV-1 of 60% and inhalational anti-inflamatory medication.

      "...granted SC for your asthma with COPD w/dypsnea because your STRs show you were diagnosed with asthma during your military service in 1995.

      First, check the date of your 2018 award letter. If it is WITHIN one year, file a notice of disagreement about the effective date. 

      If it is AFTER one year, that means your claim has became final. If you would like to try to get an earlier effective date, then CUE or new and material evidence are possible avenues. 


      I assume your 2003 denial was due to not finding "chronic" or continued symptoms noted per 38 CFR 3.303(b). In 2013, the Federal Circuit court (Walker v. Shinseki) changed they way they use the term "chronic" and requires the VA to use 3.303(a) for anything not listed under 3.307 and 3.309. You probably had a nexus and benefit of the doubt on your side when you won SC.

      It might be possible for you to CUE the effective date back to 2003 or earlier. You'll need to familiarize yourself with the restrictions of CUE. It has to be based on the evidence in the record and laws in effect at the time the decision was made. Avoid trying to argue on how they weighed a decision, but instead focus on the evidence/laws to prove they were not followed or the evidence was never considered. It's an uphill fight. I would start by recommending you look carefully at your service treatment records and locate every instance where you reported breathing issues, asthma diagnosis, or respiratory treatment (albuterol, steroids, etc...). CUE is not easy and it helps to do your homework before you file.

      Another option would be to file for an increased rating, but to do that you would need to meet the criteria for 60%. If you don't meet criteria for a 60% rating, just ensure you still meet the criteria for 30% (using daily inhaled steroid inhalers is adequate) because they are likely to deny your request for increase. You could attempt to request an earlier effective date that way.


      Does this help?
    • Thanks for that. So do you have a specific answer or experience with it bouncing between the two?
    • Tinnitus comes in two forms: subjective and objective. In subjective tinnitus, only the sufferer will hear the ringing in their own ears. In objective tinnitus, the sound can be heard by a doctor who is examining the ear canals. Objective tinnitus is extremely rare, while subjective tinnitus is by far the most common form of the disorder.

      The sounds of tinnitus may vary with the person experiencing it. Some will hear a ringing, while others will hear a buzzing. At times people may hear a chirping or whistling sound. These sounds may be constant or intermittent. They may also vary in volume and are generally more obtrusive when the sufferer is in a quiet environment. Many tinnitus sufferers find their symptoms are at their worst when they’re trying to fall asleep.

        • Like
  • Ads

  • Popular Contributors

  • Ad

  • Latest News
  • Create New...

Important Information

{terms] and Guidelines