Jump to content
  • veteranscrisisline-badge-chat-1.gif

  • Advertisemnt

  • Trouble Remembering? This helped me.

    I have memory problems and as some of you may know I highly recommend Evernote and have for years. Though I've found that writing helps me remember more. I ran across Tom's videos on youtube, I'm a bit geeky and I also use an IPad so if you take notes on your IPad or you are thinking of going paperless check it out. I'm really happy with it, I use it with a program called Noteshelf 2.

    Click here to purchase your digital journal. HadIt.com receives a commission on each purchase.

  • 14 Questions about VA Disability Compensation Benefits Claims


    When a Veteran starts considering whether or not to file a VA Disability Claim, there are a lot of questions that he or she tends to ask. Over the last 10 years, the following are the 14 most common basic questions I am asked about ...
    Continue Reading
  • Ads

  • Most Common VA Disabilities Claimed for Compensation:   


  • Advertisemnt

  • VA Watchdog

  • Advertisemnt

  • Ads

  • Can a 100 percent Disabled Veteran Work and Earn an Income?

    employment 2.jpeg

    You’ve just been rated 100% disabled by the Veterans Affairs. After the excitement of finally having the rating you deserve wears off, you start asking questions. One of the first questions that you might ask is this: It’s a legitimate question – rare is the Veteran that finds themselves sitting on the couch eating bon-bons … Continue reading

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  

Working Toward R-1


I recently filed a claim for the VA to look at my total record and determine if the totality of my service connected condition combine qualifies for a second SMC L-aid and attendance determination or that of SMC O or R1. I had researched the BVA site and internet the last few years and found that such determination where, for a time, hard to find.  However, now there seems to be an abundance of search determinations for me to review and pattern my case by.  One case that is very similar to mine is actually posted here by Jamescripps2, I believe his name here is.  Also, I have profited greatly, knowledge wise, from periodically reviewing ASKNOD.  His post are a combination of education, humor, and other information but mostly shows he cares about the veteran and is not judgmental as some sites that cater to our needs are.

Anyway my situation is as follows:   I have worked my way up to SMC M though a steady reading of posts, BVA decision, CFRs and posts here and another similar site.  I have two 100% ratings: one for mental issues and another for my heart, kidneys, and blood pressure combined.  However, James raised an interesting point about separating some issues in order to achieve the maximum rating as the VA is supposed to be doing.  By my reading chronic congestive heart failure diagnosis alone requires a 100% rating as I have been diagnosed with that.  Further, I don't know the history of Jame but he indicated that he has a 100% rating for chronic kidney disease stage three, I also have this disease at stage 3b, and  it seems he is rated 100% for this condition alone as well.  Yet, all of mine are combined into blood pressure.  So this is why I am thinking of separating these condition from one to two or possible three.  My 100% heart, kidney, blood pressure was a new rating in which it seem SMC L was not looked at by the record. Although I believe it said that no reason to bring it up if the condition doesn't warrant it ( read this somewhere can't remember which regulation it is from).

This post resolves around a claim that I am specifically asking for SMC O or R1 due to my medical conditions being evaluated in light of needing aid and attendance absent of any condition that were used in the original determination which was only one as far as i know - Mental.  My M came when they added a new back dated rating for my Heart and other stuff mentioned above.  I have 25 disability ratings currently (I counted) and expected a few more with a pending appeal due to several favorable C and P examination. Why so many?  Because I live overseas in the Philippines and to get care (free) requires service connection so I have fought for every service and secondary that I could get by my record and understanding of the regulations.  From reading here and the CFR I understand that condition must be separate but I did not truly understand till I read posting between James and ASKNOD posts and discussion back and forth.   

The questions are this The doctor connected my lower back spine degeneration to my cervical spine degeneration thus it is secondary. Therefore all it's secondaries are also not necessarily independent disabilities on their own.  However, the spine condition was used initially in my SMC P at L 1/2 prior to my SMC M determination and has a termination date or whatever its call that starts the day before the new SMC M started; thus it is not used in any determination for a rating now.  The SMC M determination is solely predicated on my heart, blood pressure and kidneys.  I had vocation rehab medical opinion from my PCP that basically said all activities were extremely limited and I was pretty much able to role and bed and open my pie hole only (due to pain, pain medication, heart, mental, orthopedica problems, etc).  Further, I was not qualified even to work on my own outside my house.    

In my prusuit of R1 I asked him to do a 2680 since that was his opinion based on conditions other than the mental - which I have and SMC L for already.   I also asked my PCP doctor at the VA to fill a similar form as well since the volcation rehab opinion was so bad. The ortho  came back right away, (not able to leave home other medical appointments, need assistance medication management due to bilateral upper and lower 'severe radiculopathy", need help dressing, etc) in other words almost all answered in the affirmative expect feeding myself.   Still pending the PCP 2680.  However, I have had two C and P with no promises till results are in but from the doctors comments it seems his comments on my lower back exam. radiculopathy and right shoulder exam would be extremely favorable as well.  But, since I already have the Ortho 2680 and my PCP opinion from Vocation Rehab (2016 was the date; old I know) and numerous C and P's (old as well) in past indicating the need for regular use of a cane for balance issues: this seems it should be enough for the determination by the regulations. I know from ASKNOD posts, I believer it was, that there are differences between post 911 LOU for housing and LOU for compensation. I was originally trying to get the SAH but the findings seem to open up new possibility.  However using a cane can't be seen as LOU for compensation I am sure but maybe for post 911 SAH.  However, what about the chance for R1 as it seems like all the requirement are there?  Any help or advise would be appreciated.  This is a long post I am sure I forgot some things please ask it it would help offer advise.




Added later: Here is a similar case remanded by the court back to BVA and approved/rated: https://www.va.gov/vetapp18/files3/1814284.txt  .   Don't know if a precedent but proves it is possible.

Edited by VICDE
Additinal information

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

4 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0


you should look up  on the hadit radio podcast shows in the hadit archives   and find the show where James Cripps was a guest and he talked about how he was getting the Upper SMC for the different conditions he had..and what he did to get them.....  or PM him here on Hadit

I believe once a Veteran has been awarded SMC -S Helps with his/her credit-ability and comes up with a more severe condition  or his condition has got worse he needs to put in a claim for that condition as long as you have medical documentations (Records) to back you up and A Qualified Dr opinion in your favor that the condition is and meets the SMC Criteria for that SMC Your filing for.

Remember SMC's are based off the severity of the condition ...how it effects the Veteran  ect,,,ect,,  way of life.

Edited by Buck52

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Oceanbound and Buck 52 thank you for your comments.  Yes, Buck52 I understand about the IMO, I think.  The Ortho doctor who performed my exam and 2680 was previously a C and P doctor until the VA switched over to outside providers.  He is the one who decided that I needed so much assistance due to lower back and 4 extremities of "severe radiculopathy" (his words) pain, multiple Ortho problems and pain medications, I guess these are what he used in deciding that I needed help with most activities of daily living.  He is also is one of the regular doctors I see during my VA visits here, so he is also experienced at evaluating me every few months. My pain meds are: Oxycontin, Lidocaine patches, Capsicin cream, Gabapentine, and Baclofen. I have medicine for gouty as well.  I also have about 10 plus other medications for various conditions.  I am pretty much in a zone most of the day as some of the others also cause drowsiness especially the psyche medications.  I will listen to the podcast if I can find it but from it posts it seems I have done much of what he has done already prior to coming here.  However, there are still many pointers I am sure that are not listed here.

Oceanbound, thanks I previously only read the post of Jamescripp2 from before where he indicated he was stage III kidney disease at 100%.  However, he never mentioned the dialysis part. I would rather pass on that and not meet that threshold if I can avoid it.  I thought that dialysis was required as well but if he had been successful, I was thinking it never hurt if you don't try.  In the Navy they use to say ( I will paraphrase) that if you ain't trying everything to succeed you ain't really trying.

 Again thanks.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
18 hours ago, Oceanbound said:

Chronic kidney disease for stage three does not result in 100%, being on dialysis would though.

Oceanbound, I have done some additional research, as I always do if told I am not correct. I believe this is the only proper way for me to learn.  I think your reply although correct is not 100%.  The CFR implies that other conditions other than dialysis can result in a 100% condition as long as the symptoms or lab values are present.  It states, and I have emphasized the basis of my reasoning in bold below:

Requiring regular dialysis, or precluding more than sedentary activity from one of the following: persistent edema and albuminuria; or, BUN more than 80mg%; or, creatinine more than 8mg%; or, markedly decreased function of kidney or other organ systems, especially cardiovascular


But this is besides the point. The point is am I at or near R1 now with the Ortho eval, voc rehab medical opinion, and waiting on the the other 2680 from my PCP or is something else required.

Thanks for your imputs in advance



Edited by VICDE

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Ads

  • Our picks

    • Show your support with HadIt.com logo items. Only a few to start, t-shirts and ball caps coming https://hadit.com/shop/ Can holder, Coffee Mugs and Notebook currently come take a look and check back https://hadit.com/shop/

      • 0 replies
    • I was unable to find a reply box to your post.

      We have a full Agent Orange forum here.

      Many veterans (and even their survivors) have succeeded in getting a disability, not on the presumptive list, service connected due to their proven exposure to AO.

      Also Secretary Wilkie is considering a few new presumptives, but we have no idea if  he will even add any to the list.

      I wrote to him making a strong argument, as  to the potential for HBP to be added, as well as ischemic stroke and have prepared a personal claim based on the same report a veteran used at the BVA, who also had a strong IMO/IME, and the BVA recently granted his HBP as due to his exposure to AO in Vietnam.

      Most veterans with HBP were deemed as having "essential" - a medical term for no know cause- now we have a cause in Vietnam veterans---AO caused it.


      The report is here:


      On page 8 they found there is "Sufficient" evidence that AO caused HBP in Vietnam veterans.

      The BVA case and this report is also searchable in our AO forum.



      • 0 replies
    • I just received a deposit to my checking account. The description says VALG TREAS 310 TYPE: XXVA.
      I'm not sure who to ask about this deposit. I am concerned because I was not notified I would be receiving it.
      I retired from the Marines in 1997 with 10% disability. I've been receiving a separate disability payment from my regular retirement pay. This deposit is completely unexpected. thank you for any insight.
    • Independent Medical Opinions by Your Private Physician

      If you spend any time reading VA case law you’ll come across the phrase less likely, more likely than not and so on. In the VA Clinicians Guide for Disability Examination it lays out how these are weighted.
      • 1 reply
    • Yes 

      After a PTSD/Unspecific MDD Diagnose From the VA Dr's

      The gold standard for diagnosing PTSD is a structured clinical interview such as the Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale (CAPS-5). When necessary, the PCL-5 can be scored to provide a provisional PTSD DSM 5 diagnosis.

      Any clinical clinician such as MD ,Psychiatrist even a L.C.S.W. (Certified)can perform the Diagnostics Evaluation Employed by the the VA

      ...They just need to figure out your symptoms and put together a list of your symptom's that you possess or show from the evaluation...I am not 100% Sure just how they do this ?

      being I am not a Dr or clinical clinician 

      Once a Diagnoses of PTSD is given they try to set you up with a Therapist to help with your New dx And how to adjust or cope with the Anxiety and Depression the PTSD can cause.

        you learn the tools to cope with and depending how severe your symptoms are ? 

       They test /screen you with phychoeducational type therapy treatment usually at first.

       Warning  some of this therapy can be very rough on a Veteran  from holding on to guilt  from the trauma its self or you maybe in a  ''stuck point''from memories and guilt or from the stressor's or anything that reminds you of the trauma you endured.

      The therapy works  even if we think it don't,  I recommend Therapy for all PTSD Veterans  it could very well save your life once the correct therapy is in place and the Veteran makes all his Clinical Appointments.

      I still have Combat PTSD it probably will never be cured completely but we can learn the tools it takes to cope with this horrible diseases 

      even learning breathing techniques  Helps tremendously during a panic attact.

      I have guilt from the war in Vietnam  ( I ask my self what could I have done to make a better outcome/difference?..and also I am in what the therapist calls stuck points. working on that at present once a week for 90 minutes.  I am very fortunate to have the help the VA gives me and I am lucky I have not turned to alcohol or drugs to mask my problem.

      But I have put my family through a living hell with my angers of burst.and they all stood by me the whole time years and years of my family life was disrupted because of me and my children &spouse  never deserved it one bit.

      That's all I want to say about that.

      At least I am still around. and plan to be tell my old age dying day.
  • Ads

  • Popular Contributors

  • Ad

  • Latest News
  • Create New...

Important Information

{terms] and Guidelines