Read Disability Claims Articles
View All Forums | Chats and Other Events | Donate | Blogs | New Users | Search | Rules
- 0
Howell v Nicholson
Rate this question
Read Disability Claims Articles
View All Forums | Chats and Other Events | Donate | Blogs | New Users | Search | Rules
Rate this question
Question
Mr cue
Ok here is the way the lawyer word the issue.
I am happy now we just waiting to see who is going to address it.
The VA brief is due in 20 days they will try to get a extension I guess the court will give them 10 extra days.
So about 30 day we will see how the veterans affairs lawyer answer it.
Only thing that bother me is he is not showing that I have not been able to leave my home to make a income since 1993.
But hAy I could get it all address.
2. The Board’s statement of reasons or bases denying an earlier effective date
than May 9, 2018, for SMC based on housebound status under 38 U.S.C. §
1114(s) was inadequate.
Pursuant to 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s) a veteran is entitled to SMC if his or her service
connected disabilities render the veteran permanently housebound. The requirement of permanently housebound” will be considered to have been met when the veteran is
substantially confined to such veteran’s house (ward or clinical areas, if institutionalized)
or immediate premises due to a service-connected disability or disabilities which it is
reasonably certain will remain throughout such veteran’s lifetime. 38 U.S.C. § 1114(s).
The term “substantially confined” is not defined by statute or regulation. Howell v.
Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 535, 540 (2006). The Secretary has taken the position that
“substantially confined” is met when the claimant is restricted to his house except for
medical treatment purposes. Id (noting Senate Report No. 1745 (June 27, 1960) that
Congress intended to provide additional compensation for veterans who were unable to
overcome their particular disabilities and leave the house in order to earn an income as
opposed to an inability to leave the house at all). The Court has held that leaving the house
for medical purposes cannot, by itself, serve as the basis for finding that a veteran is not
substantially confined for SMC purposes. Id.
Here, the Board did not define the term “substantially confined” nor did it address
the Court’s holding in Howell, 19 Vet. App. at 540 or Congress’s intent behind the statute.
Johnson v. Wilkie, 30 Vet. App. 245, 254-55 (2018)(stating that without a standard for
comparing and assessing terms, such conclusory findings by the Board are unreviewable
by the Court and prevent the veteran from what his evidence must demonstrate for a benefit
to be granted). This is to say that the Board did not explain why the functional limitations
identified by, inter alia, the 2018 VA examiners and paraprofessional care plan, showed
that possessed the ability to overcome his particular disabilities and leave the house
in order to earn an income. Howell, 19 Vet. App. at 540. As noted above, the evidence of record shows that mr cannot travel beyond his current domicile, is unable to dress and
undress himself, do dishes, housework, prepare meals, or put away groceries, and has some
difficulty in the ability to feed himself, bathe, groom, use the toilet, drive, change from a
sitting to standing position, and walk long distances. R. 1430-31 (1430-31), 2310 (2309-
13). The Board’s failure to define “substantially confined” and apply these limitations to
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
4
2
2
Popular Days
Apr 7
5
Apr 6
1
Apr 8
1
Apr 9
1
Top Posters For This Question
Mr cue 4 posts
broncovet 2 posts
Rivet62 2 posts
Popular Days
Apr 7 2022
5 posts
Apr 6 2022
1 post
Apr 8 2022
1 post
Apr 9 2022
1 post
Popular Posts
Mr cue
Yes when you hire the lawyer you are in there hands. I am fine with what he did. I just hate that a few of the issues I had. Are no longer going to be address. But I am get to the point
7 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now