I hope that some of you guys that are smarter than I am can help me understand this. I served in SWA. Retired from the army in August 2000. In Sep 03 I started having bowel problems. The doctor tried diet, exercise etc..... The problems grew worse over the next two years. In Mar 05 my doctor (a military doctor) listed objective findings of constant diaherra intermittent with constipation, bloating and cramps - diagnosis IBS.
I submitted a claim to VA and asked for service connection based upon persumption due to my service in SWA since IBS is one of the presumptive diaseases. VA denied the claim stating that there was no objective findings in my SMR's during service nor had the symptoms developed within one year of discharge.
What the h--l are they talking about? I served in the required area, the symptoms manifested to a degree that requires a 10 percent rating prior to 31 Dec 2006, IBS is specifically named in the list of presumptive diaseases for SWA service.
I thought that was what the word presumption meant. That if you meet the requirements service connection would be presumed. Now they want to throw in the requirement that it had to manifest some how during active service or within one year after discharge.
I am tired and wore down and VA's ability to constantly change the interpertation of their regs to fit their denial strategy is pushing me over the edge. This decision was either the action of a pure 100 percent idiot or one of the meanest demons that the VA could find from the depths of hell.
Question
Ricky
I hope that some of you guys that are smarter than I am can help me understand this. I served in SWA. Retired from the army in August 2000. In Sep 03 I started having bowel problems. The doctor tried diet, exercise etc..... The problems grew worse over the next two years. In Mar 05 my doctor (a military doctor) listed objective findings of constant diaherra intermittent with constipation, bloating and cramps - diagnosis IBS.
I submitted a claim to VA and asked for service connection based upon persumption due to my service in SWA since IBS is one of the presumptive diaseases. VA denied the claim stating that there was no objective findings in my SMR's during service nor had the symptoms developed within one year of discharge.
What the h--l are they talking about? I served in the required area, the symptoms manifested to a degree that requires a 10 percent rating prior to 31 Dec 2006, IBS is specifically named in the list of presumptive diaseases for SWA service.
I thought that was what the word presumption meant. That if you meet the requirements service connection would be presumed. Now they want to throw in the requirement that it had to manifest some how during active service or within one year after discharge.
I am tired and wore down and VA's ability to constantly change the interpertation of their regs to fit their denial strategy is pushing me over the edge. This decision was either the action of a pure 100 percent idiot or one of the meanest demons that the VA could find from the depths of hell.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
4
1
1
Popular Days
Dec 17
3
Dec 18
3
Dec 19
1
Top Posters For This Question
Ricky 4 posts
Pete53 1 post
Arch 1 post
Popular Days
Dec 17 2005
3 posts
Dec 18 2005
3 posts
Dec 19 2005
1 post
6 answers to this question
Recommended Posts