I would like some advice about my va claim. I have only posted here once but read new topics daily when home. It amazes me to no end at the thought that goes into some of the opinions by respondents.
I filed a ptsd claim in feb, 2004. I was granted a 30% service connected decision on 22 feb 2005,without a c&p exam. we filed an appeal a week later,(I have realized from reading your forum that I didn't have a very into it type rep)but he for what ever reason only asked for 50% to be decided by a DRO.HE OF COuRSE DIDN'T look at the new evidence and denied our request for 50%.We then filed an appeal with the BVA june 7 2005.
The ro set up a c&p exam for july 7 2005 by a board certified shrink,and after My va rep saw his and two other shrinks reports, he decided to file for IN HIS WORDS, AT LEAST 70%. On oct. 05 2005 I received a letter from DVA that I had been awarded 50% retro to feb 04. I called the ro to see if this would affect my appeal for the 70% I had filed for. I was told ''no'' since the 50% was awarded on an earlier appeal and the 70%was still the works.
I had a meeting with My service rep on oct 10 2005 and mentioned to him that I had a service connected rt knee, and it was well documented in in my service medical records, so he filed a claim. I went for a c&p exam on june 06 2006. I waited about two weeks and went to records in the local VA,but they weren't back. Finding this unusual the clerk called the orthro doc who did the exam. The doc told him the ro had sent it back to him for correction and he had sent them back to the ro that day. I finally got a copy.
The report was somewhat confusing to me and still is. The doc pulled no punches on the major damage to the service connected right knee incuding -30 degrees extension, ( I would like to thank my rep for not filing the left knee)
I'll show you Guys why I am confused by quoting from my report.
MEDICAL OPINION
============
WAS AN OPINION REQUESTED; YES
MEDICAL OPINION SUMMARY
RESTATEMENT OF REQUESTED OPINION;Whether or not the currently diagnosed degenerative joint desease is at least as likly as not related to the right knee injury in service.
MEDICAL OPINION
THIS VETERAN IS LESS LIKELY AS NOT(less than 50/50 probability) caused by or a result of right knee injury.
OTHER MEDICAL OPINION OR COMMENT
Whether or not, the currently diagnosed degenerative joint diasease is as likely as not related to right knee injury in service.
( By the way my service rep retired after appealing for the 70%.I hope he enjoys his retirement, but it would have been nice to have known.) As you might notice above, other medical opinion or comment seems to be the doc's final say but is different as original medical opinion.
I talked to My temp. rep today and after talking to the ro he informed me my case is before the rating board.
I read hadit every day I'm near my computer and value opinion. Thanks in advance to you Guys and Gals for helping this 63 year old grunt to understand this garble.
Question
kkp
I would like some advice about my va claim. I have only posted here once but read new topics daily when home. It amazes me to no end at the thought that goes into some of the opinions by respondents.
I filed a ptsd claim in feb, 2004. I was granted a 30% service connected decision on 22 feb 2005,without a c&p exam. we filed an appeal a week later,(I have realized from reading your forum that I didn't have a very into it type rep)but he for what ever reason only asked for 50% to be decided by a DRO.HE OF COuRSE DIDN'T look at the new evidence and denied our request for 50%.We then filed an appeal with the BVA june 7 2005.
The ro set up a c&p exam for july 7 2005 by a board certified shrink,and after My va rep saw his and two other shrinks reports, he decided to file for IN HIS WORDS, AT LEAST 70%. On oct. 05 2005 I received a letter from DVA that I had been awarded 50% retro to feb 04. I called the ro to see if this would affect my appeal for the 70% I had filed for. I was told ''no'' since the 50% was awarded on an earlier appeal and the 70%was still the works.
I had a meeting with My service rep on oct 10 2005 and mentioned to him that I had a service connected rt knee, and it was well documented in in my service medical records, so he filed a claim. I went for a c&p exam on june 06 2006. I waited about two weeks and went to records in the local VA,but they weren't back. Finding this unusual the clerk called the orthro doc who did the exam. The doc told him the ro had sent it back to him for correction and he had sent them back to the ro that day. I finally got a copy.
The report was somewhat confusing to me and still is. The doc pulled no punches on the major damage to the service connected right knee incuding -30 degrees extension, ( I would like to thank my rep for not filing the left knee)
I'll show you Guys why I am confused by quoting from my report.
MEDICAL OPINION
============
WAS AN OPINION REQUESTED; YES
MEDICAL OPINION SUMMARY
RESTATEMENT OF REQUESTED OPINION;Whether or not the currently diagnosed degenerative joint desease is at least as likly as not related to the right knee injury in service.
MEDICAL OPINION
THIS VETERAN IS LESS LIKELY AS NOT(less than 50/50 probability) caused by or a result of right knee injury.
OTHER MEDICAL OPINION OR COMMENT
Whether or not, the currently diagnosed degenerative joint diasease is as likely as not related to right knee injury in service.
( By the way my service rep retired after appealing for the 70%.I hope he enjoys his retirement, but it would have been nice to have known.) As you might notice above, other medical opinion or comment seems to be the doc's final say but is different as original medical opinion.
I talked to My temp. rep today and after talking to the ro he informed me my case is before the rating board.
I read hadit every day I'm near my computer and value opinion. Thanks in advance to you Guys and Gals for helping this 63 year old grunt to understand this garble.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
4
2
1
Popular Days
Aug 29
5
Aug 30
2
Top Posters For This Question
kkp 4 posts
Berta 2 posts
Vike17 1 post
Popular Days
Aug 29 2006
5 posts
Aug 30 2006
2 posts
6 answers to this question
Recommended Posts