Ask Your VA Claims Questions | Read Current Posts
Read Disability Claims Articles
Search | View All Forums | Donate | Blogs | New Users | Rules
EW2(SW)
-
Posts
13 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
VA Disability and Benefits Information
VA Benefits News
Store
Posts posted by EW2(SW)
-
-
Long story short, claim is back in Gathering Evidence...
In 2011 I submitted a claim for PTSD... Was denied claim for PTSD and told I had anxiety and thats what I needed to file for.
2013 Filed for Anxiety and this time went to C&P. For previous PTSD claim did not have a C&P
C&P last month notes read that DSM-V criteria I do have Chronic PTSD w/ Occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity!!!!
So I sent them a letter at the end of August asking if this would go back to my original PTSD Claim or if it woud fall under the anxiety claim of 2013...
I was immediately sent to Gathering evidence and there I have sat...
Any insight as to what they are thinking or might do would be grately appreciated.
-
Long story short, claim is back in Gathering Evidence...
In 2011 I submitted a claim for PTSD... Was denied claim for PTSD and told I had anxiety and thats what I needed to file for.
2013 Filed for Anxiety and this time went to C&P. For previous PTSD claim did not have a C&P
C&P last month notes read that DSM-V criteria I do have Chronic PTSD w/ Occupational and social impairment with reduced reliability and productivity!!!!
So I sent them a letter at the end of August asking if this would go back to my original PTSD Claim or if it woud fall under the anxiety claim of 2013...
I was immediately sent to Gathering evidence and there I have sat...
Any insight as to what they are thinking or might do would be grately appreciated.
-
It is a very strange diagnosis... He said my C&P was for PTSD, but it clearly states in eBenefits that its for Anxiety... To top it off, I had a PTSD claim filed back in 2011 that was denied in 2012 for lack of evidence and they never even sent me to a C&P.
SMH
-
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION: I conclude the veteran does meet criteriafor post-traumatic stress disorder. He does not meet criteria for amild neurocognitive disorder due to TBI. He is able to maintainactivities of daily living including personal hygiene. He has notexperienced a significant trauma since discharge, but there has beena worsening of his condition because his PTSD has not beenadequately treated. There have not been remissions and symptoms arecontinuous. He does not have a problem with drug and alcohol abuse.There is not inappropriate behavior. He is in treatment at thecurrent time and on medication but has had many failed trials withSSRI medications and now is having at least an early good responseto Clonazepam 0.5 mg b.i.d. to lessen the intensity of his anxietybut not resolve it. His thought processes and communication are notimpaired. His social functioning is impaired by anxiety andwithdrawal avoidance. His employment has not been impacted bypsychological issues. The veteran has continued to be employeddespite the PTSD all of this time. No other diagnosis or mentalcondition was found other than PTSD secondary to a motor vehicleaccident while in the service in 1997. He is competent to handle VAfunds.SEVERITY STATEMENT: For PTSD, there is occupational and socialimpairment with reduced reliability and productivity due to suchsymptoms as depressed mood, chronic sleep impairment, anxiety, panicattacks more than once a week, and disturbances of motivation andmood.See earlier section entitled "SUBJECTIVESYMPTOMS OF MILD NEUROCOGNITIVE DISORDER DUE TO TBI" for scoresrelated to that issue. See also separate medical/neurologicalevaluation report for any medical, physical, or physiological
effects of TB
-
Thank Senior... Just crazy that it was in Notifications... Then it updated still in notification to say letters send, etc... Checked AB8 and other form and both said 60% and then it changed back to Gathering evidence and date requested for evidence shifted to 8/8/2014.
-
Any clue as to what might be going on?
Thank you.
-
Thank you for taking the time to read this.
My Major claim is for TBI with MDD and Anxiety with Panic... I went through 2nd Level TBI evaluation and have been seen by Dr.'s for Anxiety and Depression since I got out in 02'. 2nd level TBI said just that. I had a TBI from a serious MVA. I did not receive a C&P for Mental Health. Thoughts?
My second compliant is my neck and left leg. During exam Dr said me lookin to the right was just about 60degrees and left was 55degrees... Not sure what that meant, but then she checked my left and right arm and said my left arm had a good bit of atrophy in it and it worried her because of the MVA that I had in the military and she told me to ask my PCP for an MRI because she could not do that.
Now, I have not seen my C&P from my neck and leg visit, but my decision has moved forward and I have not had a mental health C&P...
Anybody know of anyone getting MH disability with no C&P?
-
Is it possible for you to post more of the exam results?
I'm a bit confused. You said no C&P has been done. Is it possible this exam was the C&P?
It was never mentioned as being the C&P... Only listed as
LOCAL TITLE: TBI SECOND LEVEL EVALUATIONSTANDARD TITLE: TBI NOTEThe Dr. Mentioned that the Eval is not for Compensation, but determintation if a TBI happened... Which in the above post came back asA combination of OEF/OIF deployment related TBI and Behavioral Healthcondition(s)
There were 30 total questions most of them had a,b,c,d add ons to the numbers to include questions like:16. Please rate the following symptoms with regard to how they haveaffectedyou over the last 30 days. Use the following scale (Neurobehavioral SymptomInventory):None 0 - Rarely if ever present not a problem at all.Mild 1 - Occasionally present but it does not disrupt activities, I canusuallycontinue what I am doing; does not really concern me.Moderate 2 - Often present, occasionally disrupts my activities; I canusuallycontinue what I am doing with some effort; I am somewhat concerned.Severe 3 - Frequently present and disrupts activities; I can only dothingsthat are fairly simple or take little effort; I feel like I need help.Very Severe 4 - Almost always present and I have been unable to performatwork, school, or home due to this problem; I probably cannot function withouthelp.16-A Feeling dizzy: Moderate16-B Loss of balance: Moderate16-C Poor coordination, clumsy: Mild16-D Headaches: Moderate16-E Nausea: None16-F Vision problems, blurring, trouble seeing: Moderate16-G Sensitivity to light: Moderate16-H Hearing difficulty: Mild16-I Sensitivity to noise: Mild16-J Numbness or tingling in parts of my body: Moderate16-K Change in ability to taste and/or smell: None16-L Loss of appetite or increase appetite: Mild16-M Poor concentration, can't pay attention: Mild16-N Forgetfulness, can't remember things: ModerateI am just trying to find out what potential disability rating I should receive based off of Dr.s notes if any at all... That way I have someithng to go off of if they try to low ball me? I have also just completed my TBI eye exam and Organizational and memory loss class. -
Wasn't the evaluation a C&P exam? Did you see a psych doc or neurologist at VA? They are the only type of docs that can do a TBI exam for rating purposes.
Did they ask you the long list of questions on the ECI table? Things like, do you get lost easily, even when using navigation systems?
Yes, I went through all of those questions and the results are in MyHealthEVet... the answers I posted above are just two from her Evaluation notes... She is a Physiatrist from the VA... There were ratings I had to answer that ranged from
None 0 - Rarely if ever present not a problem at all.Mild 1 - Occasionally present but it does not disrupt activities, I canusuallycontinue what I am doing; does not really concern me.Moderate 2 - Often present, occasionally disrupts my activities; I canusuallycontinue what I am doing with some effort; I am somewhat concerned.Severe 3 - Frequently present and disrupts activities; I can only dothingsthat are fairly simple or take little effort; I feel like I need help.Very Severe 4 - Almost always present and I have been unable to performatwork, school, or home due to this problem; I probably cannot function withouthelp.Does this help? -
Just finished my 2nd Level Evaluation for TBI and these two items stuck out to me
27) Are the history of the injury and course of clinical symptoms consistent with
a diagnosis of TBI sustained during OEF/OIF deployment?
No
28) In your clinical judgment the current clinical symptom presentation is most
consistent with:
A combination of OEF/OIF deployment related TBI and Behavioral Health
condition(s)
I read through myhealthyvet and the Dr. Listed me as having TBI with loss of consciousness and anxiety and depression.
I have an open claim for TBI due to MVA (New), Residuals of TBI (New), and anxiety (New). I am currently at 30% for my back and wrists.
I am wondering if anyone has any insight on this evaluation and what I could possibly expect and what I should look for... No C&P has been done, but I have been moved to PENDING DECISION APPROVAL.
Claim has been since 3/20/13
Thank you for your help -
Just finished my 2nd Level Evaluation for TBI and these two items stuck out to me
27) Are the history of the injury and course of clinical symptoms consistent with
a diagnosis of TBI sustained during OEF/OIF deployment?
No
28) In your clinical judgment the current clinical symptom presentation is most
consistent with:
A combination of OEF/OIF deployment related TBI and Behavioral Health
condition(s)
I read through myhealthyvet and the Dr. Listed me as having TBI with loss of consciousness and anxiety and depression.
I have an open claim for TBI due to MVA (New), Residuals of TBI (New), and anxiety (New). I am currently at 30% for my back and wrists.
I am wondering if anyone has any insight on this evaluation and what I could possibly expect and what I should look for... No C&P has been done, but I have been moved to PENDING DECISION APPROVAL.
Claim has been since 3/20/13
Thank you for your help -
Just finished my 2nd Level Evaluation for TBI and these two items stuck out to me
27) Are the history of the injury and course of clinical symptoms consistent with
a diagnosis of TBI sustained during OEF/OIF deployment?
No
28) In your clinical judgment the current clinical symptom presentation is most
consistent with:
A combination of OEF/OIF deployment related TBI and Behavioral Health
condition(s)
I read through myhealthyvet and the Dr. Listed me as having TBI with loss of consciousness and anxiety and depression.
I have an open claim for TBI due to MVA (New), Residuals of TBI (New), and anxiety (New). I am currently at 30% for my back and wrists.
I am wondering if anyone has any insight on this evaluation and what I could possibly expect and what I should look for... No C&P has been done, but I have been moved to PENDING DECISION APPROVAL.
Claim has been since 3/20/13
Thank you for your help
From Prep For Decision Back To Gathering Evidence, But Here's The Stinker
in VA.gov Questions (formerly E-Benefits)
Posted
Thanks Master Chief