I had filed a claim for a sparined right ankle in 1990 shortly after my discahrge from active duty. I had 2 exams and for this the last one in 2002, I was denied service connection both times. This was even though the 2002 examiner diagnosed me with a right ankle spain. He had also said "examination reveals very marked (congenital) Pes Planus bilaterally and certainly that could be a cause of his discomfort." This was also used to deny my right knee claim. I went to get a IMO and had that faxed in to the VA, in the mean time I moved away and tried to have my claim follow me but, the denial became final. I see they said "Service connection is not granted for a congenital disabilty and your SMRs do not show aggrivation by service"
Here I am years later I have found that the doctors office where I got my IMO had missed spelled my name and the evidence in support of my claim went into someone elses file. I have had foot issues since my time in the service and the VA podiatrist supplies my custom orthotics. I looked over my SMR to see if Pes planus was ever noted and it was. I had been prescribed orthotics and a heel lift as part of a work up on my right knee. So with this information I submitted a claim for Pes Planus, which the VA turned into me re-opening and renaming my Right Ankle sprain claim(HOW DOES THAT WORK).I thought I was in good shape, I had my documentation SMR, have current diagnosis and treatment (moderate ecessive pronation of STJ in stance and gait, Mild abducted gait, mild genu varum), documentation of Pes Planus in my comp and Pen files along with their X-ray evidence, a letter from my pediatrician that stated she cared for me from birth until a month before my joining the service and she said that she never treated or diagnosed my with Pes Planus( = not congenital). My entry physical state feet as Normal.
I was on this site and noticed a refernce to Wagner v. Principi, §3.304, and Authority: 38 U.S.C. 1111. "(b) Presumption of soundness. The veteran will be considered to have been in sound condition when examined, accepted and enrolled for service except as to defects, infirmities, or disorders noted at entrance into service, or where clear and unmistakable (obvious or manifest) evidence demonstrates that an injury or disease existed prior thereto and was not aggravated by such service. Only such conditions as are recorded in examination reports are to be considered as noted. "
My question is should this apply to my case where it goes back to 1999 and 2002? If it does apply Do I need to bring this to their attention? I feel like me knee claim is also being held because of the"congenital" notation the examiner made in 2002.
Should my Pes planus been lumped into my Ankle claim or should it be its own claim?
Sorry so long but this has been an exhausting and confusing process with no end in sight.
Question
RIVER RAT
I had filed a claim for a sparined right ankle in 1990 shortly after my discahrge from active duty. I had 2 exams and for this the last one in 2002, I was denied service connection both times. This was even though the 2002 examiner diagnosed me with a right ankle spain. He had also said "examination reveals very marked (congenital) Pes Planus bilaterally and certainly that could be a cause of his discomfort." This was also used to deny my right knee claim. I went to get a IMO and had that faxed in to the VA, in the mean time I moved away and tried to have my claim follow me but, the denial became final. I see they said "Service connection is not granted for a congenital disabilty and your SMRs do not show aggrivation by service"
Here I am years later I have found that the doctors office where I got my IMO had missed spelled my name and the evidence in support of my claim went into someone elses file. I have had foot issues since my time in the service and the VA podiatrist supplies my custom orthotics. I looked over my SMR to see if Pes planus was ever noted and it was. I had been prescribed orthotics and a heel lift as part of a work up on my right knee. So with this information I submitted a claim for Pes Planus, which the VA turned into me re-opening and renaming my Right Ankle sprain claim(HOW DOES THAT WORK).I thought I was in good shape, I had my documentation SMR, have current diagnosis and treatment (moderate ecessive pronation of STJ in stance and gait, Mild abducted gait, mild genu varum), documentation of Pes Planus in my comp and Pen files along with their X-ray evidence, a letter from my pediatrician that stated she cared for me from birth until a month before my joining the service and she said that she never treated or diagnosed my with Pes Planus( = not congenital). My entry physical state feet as Normal.
I was on this site and noticed a refernce to Wagner v. Principi, §3.304, and Authority: 38 U.S.C. 1111. "(b) Presumption of soundness. The veteran will be considered to have been in sound condition when examined, accepted and enrolled for service except as to defects, infirmities, or disorders noted at entrance into service, or where clear and unmistakable (obvious or manifest) evidence demonstrates that an injury or disease existed prior thereto and was not aggravated by such service. Only such conditions as are recorded in examination reports are to be considered as noted. "
My question is should this apply to my case where it goes back to 1999 and 2002? If it does apply Do I need to bring this to their attention? I feel like me knee claim is also being held because of the"congenital" notation the examiner made in 2002.
Should my Pes planus been lumped into my Ankle claim or should it be its own claim?
Sorry so long but this has been an exhausting and confusing process with no end in sight.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
Top Posters For This Question
6
1
1
1
Popular Days
Aug 1
11
May 18
2
Top Posters For This Question
RIVER RAT 6 posts
Pete53 1 post
Berta 1 post
Philip Rogers 1 post
Popular Days
Aug 1 2010
11 posts
May 18 2011
2 posts
12 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now