Ad free subscription.


This eBook will teach you how to get C-Files (paper and electronic) from the VA Regional Office.
How to Get your VA C-File




  • Topics

  • Forum Statistics

    • Total Topics
      60,097
    • Total Posts
      387,959
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • NOD / DRO or TARP?
      Also, I want to point out that my husband returned from his 2nd tour in October of 2008. I do not believe I would have said that I was that concerned with him returning when he had just got back as was stated in the decision. He usually has at least a couple of years between deployments.  I could be wrong, I don't remember. I do recollect saying that when he was gone, a lot of the memories of what we did and seen during the invasion returned or bothered me more..?.  Sorry, I can't be sure.
    • Dr Ellis IMO
      Thanks for the info Flores.  I actually called the clinic this morning.  I am in the process of gathering my records and will be sending them out hopefully by Monday.  They said that they are currently scheduling for the end of June, beginning of July.  The lady sounded very nice.  I am looking forward to meeting Dr. Ellis soon.   Good luck on your claim. Travis  
    • Pending Case Dispatch
      They said it was remanded back to the RO.
    • 25 Year Long Service Connected Disability Denied After C/p Exam.
      Thanks all for the kind words. And yes I do sometimes feel that i don't deserve anything as i did not do combat. And there is way too many service men and women who have given up way more and come home with less than they left with. So it is even harder to stand up and ask for help when I see those Brothers in Arms coming home with severe injuries and some coming home with the Flag we all swore to defend. Thomas that road of drinking and drugs i went down and it almost destroyed my whole family. And after spending 30 days locked up in a rehabilitation hospital i don't care to go back again. I have been sober now for over 2 years have not had a drink and don't miss it none at all. I still pain medications but the VA limits that now and I have to sign that contract every month to get it. I do want to mention something I feel is Good News... As I look at the eBenefits website almost constantly to see if any changes are made. Good news tonight when I looked at it as one of my Open Claims is now in the Notification Stage. And then I looked to see and they had approved my second application to include my wife and kids on. Of course my daughter is in college and my son is 25 now, which they did not accept him as a dependent. That means they may have approved my Claim for Depression and Anxiety. But most likely they are going to a New condition and I will have to fight for the back pay. But since my previous Claim is in the DRO stage and I am awaiting the outcome of it. This new claim for Depression should move over to it now and be included. Is that correct as I can't file another NOD on it til the DRO issue's a SOC first. Anyways here a screenshot of them accepting my wife and daughter as dependents and also a screenshot of the awaiting Notification letter to be delivered. . 
    • NOD / DRO or TARP?
      After some digging, I was not able to find my complete original 2009 decision. I did however find my PTSD appeal decision from 2011 and the rating part of my 2009 letter. I must have separated the 2009 letter at some point to prove I had a 10% service connection, but didn't want them seeing the notes. I hope this is enough to maybe point a path. I can't express how much I appreciate what you guy's are doing here. I have never been comfortable sharing this stuff with anyone, To the point that I have been doing this with just my husbands help because I did not want to talk to a VSO that I don't know. But I see on here that everyone is helping everyone fight the same fight. Thank you very much!  In reference to the previous questions: It appears I did file the DRO route, and no, I did not continue the appeal to the BVA. I actually found where I started to fill out the VA form 9, but I was so fed up with the OKC VA back then that I must have said "screw it". Big mistake on my part I know. Appeal Decision 2011.pdf Original Rating 2009.pdf
    • 25 Year Long Service Connected Disability Denied After C/p Exam.
      ardodd I agree with pete992 My fellow Veteran Brother Never give up on your claim. you don't have to be a combat veteran to file a claim.   you served and did your time  your a veteran just like the rest of us  so if you have a disability to claim...by all means claim it. These claims are never a piece of cake or sure thing ,we all have to fight for what we get with our str's and..medical evidence and good favorable Dr reports (VA or Private)are great to have  its hard for them to deny that kind of evidence. Now with that said ts been known that some veterans have had all the evidence and medical records under the sun to prove there claim and VA still deny's them! eh! (VA don't read all the necessary Documents some times) So the fight is on and some claims take less and some takes a long ass time. If you get denied  they usually will send you the reason why and send you a NOD (notice of disagreement) to dispute what they denied and you can add more evidence and lay statements.(WITHIN A YEAR) Just ask your questions here on Hadit  and some of the elder members with a lot More & good experience and knowledge of VA Claims can help you. Remember Knowledge is Power! And I my opinion that's what we all Need to fight our claims. Don't sale yourself short Buddy.   ........Buck
    • Progress is Progress - However so Slight ;)
      Texas Marine, at this point it might be worth a shot to call the Office of Case Management, try this number-(202)-930-5470, they should be able to give you up to date information and speed things up possibly. Did you have a video teleconference hearing before a VLJ? That is a long time, I had my video hearing at the RO in June of 2015, I believe on the 22nd, by the 17th of August I had the decision from BVA. I hope that they can provide some help and speed up the process!! If that doesn't work, it might be time to send an email to the VA Secretary. Best of Luck to you!!
    • Dr Ellis IMO
      Let me add, after our appointment, it took a little over a week for me to receive the completed IMO. I am on heavy pain meds right now and making less sense than usual! So, first call the clinic, tell them you are interested in obtaining an IMO from Dr Ellis, they will send you the application, after you complete the application(include it in your packet), and gather all of the records you are going to send, including the Summary of Records list, send it off, they will call you as soon as they receive it and usually the appointment timeframe is anywhere from 1 1/2-2 months after they receive your packet. However, after the appointment you will receive the complete IMO usually within 2 weeks, max.

  • HadIt.com Veteran to Veteran providing FREE information and community to veterans since 1997.

    I am proud that I've been able to offer all that HadIt.com has for free for 19 years and continue to do so. HadIt.com does accept contributions to help with costs we also offer paid ad free subscriptions. None of the paid options are required. The forum, the website, news site and podcast are free and will remain so. If you choose to support the site with a contribution or a subscription it is appreciated but never required. If you choose to make a contribution or purchase an ad free subscription, you can do so here. 

Old 5311

Service Connected Osteoarthritis And Degenerative Joint Disease

27 posts in this topic

The VA just determined the following conditions are related to my military service, so connection has been granted:

Degenerative joint disease cervical spine, assigned 10%.

Degenerative joint disease, lumbar spine, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left knee, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right knee, assigned 10%.

TOTAL 10%

Can this possibly be correct? I am crippled, and have continuous pain, even lying down. I cannot stand, walk or take stairs. The VA knows all this.

My hunch is they are waiting on attrition!

Someone please explain this decision to me or advise.

Thank You.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites







The bright side of this is that the various conditions are now service connected. So, you can ask for higher ratings and TDIU due to the multiple SC conditions. The VA often "low balls" original compensation claims. A notice of disagreement (NOD) is one way, and perhaps the first of several steps. You should, if eligible, also file for SSDI. An SSDI approval for SC connected conditions is extremely useful, and will help substantiate your claim.

As for a detailed description of how and why the VA assigned the various 10% ratings, a look at the VA's disability/compensation schedule will provide some idea. You should ask the VA for an "SOC" and the details concerning the way they assigned the 10% ratings. (If they have not already given you that information.) You will need to conduct most of the research and so forth personally. This helps provide a rationale for the NOD.

The VA just determined the following conditions are related to my military service, so connection has been granted:

Degenerative joint disease cervical spine, assigned 10%.

Degenerative joint disease, lumbar spine, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left knee, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right knee, assigned 10%.

TOTAL 10%

Can this possibly be correct? I am crippled, and have continuous pain, even lying down. I cannot stand, walk or take stairs. The VA knows all this.

My hunch is they are waiting on attrition!

Someone please explain this decision to me or advise.

Thank You.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Are you saying they totalled all this and gave you 10% ?????

also did any consider the bilateral factor?

if you are not working did you formally apply for TDIU?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Let's see:

10 X 10 = 10

People keep asking me, "Why is the VA so SCREWED UP?"

The above is a perfectly good example, I would think.

I'd be willing to bet that they can't do much better with adding or subtracting, either. :lol:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Chuck75 and Berta,

Thanks for the replies. You are exactly right all those add up to 10%. I did get a Statement Of Claim, but do not know about a bilateral factor. I could get 20% if a group of joints were affected. You are right I got low-balled. I have deformity and have lost 2" of height. Also wearing VA issue braces on the legs. Two VA doctors knew my condition was SC and made the notes. They gave the civilian doctors statements credibility. My employer has given me Special Accomodation so I'm thankful for that.

Regards "Old 5311"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

•The decision was a disappointing surprise. I am living with a service connected disabling handicap with continuous pain. I cannot stand, walk or take steps. This condition increases my PTSD symptoms. Their decision is for only 10%. Do you have any thoughts or advice on this? Page no. 7 says a 20% evaluation is not warranted unless X-ray evidence shows involvement of two or more major joint groups with incapacitating exacerbations of flexion limited to 30 degrees; or evidence of limitation of abduction lost beyond 10 degrees. This disability is very hard to live with, the limitations are endless. I would think it should be 40-60%.

R/"Old 5311"

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I sure would check the diagnostic codes too as well as the rating schedule-

and I would think the braces would put you into a higher rating for some of this-

Bizarre-

I guess if ten vets showed up -with one claim each -and each claim was just like one of yours then VA would pay 10 vets 10% each.????

maybe that doesnt make sense what I just said but sometimes the VA's Rationale is utterly weird to me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know whats going on I am new to the game but I have arthritis degenerative in the neck wrist and foot/ankle

I get 20% for the neck

10% for the wrist (pain)

10% for the foot (pain)

40% but fuzzy math makes it less.

My xrays so the radiologist says doesn't show arthritis, but I can see it on my films.

I will NOD this I think my pain should be rated higher and the xrays they used were 18 months old.

If you have wrist and fingers involved that 2 joints, if you have both hands its bilateral. Check the rating codes it is explained there.

Re file a new claim for pain and limited motion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Veteran Forum Friends, Thanks for your thoughts. I Faxed my DAV VSO and will wait for that reply. For the record, I waited nine years for this decision, with the condition worsening continuously. I really expected a >40% rating. Every claim I have submitted has been denied by the same person at St. Pete. You must understand, they are understaffed and have huge case loads. So the easiest thing to do is deny, deny and deny. Then you wait and wait. ATRITION is the main objective! Definitionof atrition: we are gone! I think these VA employees are in low pay grades, although I understand the majority are veterans who must comply with their boss's orders. Annual evals are important and now under NSPS it is a new ball game. Only the good ole boys will see promotions and bonuses. The managers are largely non-vets who avoided the draft somehow. They are promoted, rewarded and recognized for keeping costs low and below budget.

I guess I'm just too young to be this darn old!

39 nholdin, not bitter.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I plugged these numbers into my spreadsheet calculator, and assuming none is rated as 'bilateral', 10 tens crunches down to 67% - or 70% in comp terms. I would venture a guess there was an error somewhere on your letter or in your process. Did you submit a form for IU? Good luck,

--Jim

The VA just determined the following conditions are related to my military service, so connection has been granted:

Degenerative joint disease cervical spine, assigned 10%.

Degenerative joint disease, lumbar spine, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left knee, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right knee, assigned 10%.

TOTAL 10%

Can this possibly be correct? I am crippled, and have continuous pain, even lying down. I cannot stand, walk or take stairs. The VA knows all this.

My hunch is they are waiting on attrition!

Someone please explain this decision to me or advise.

Thank You.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Jim,

No I have not filed IU. Still working under special accomodation status. I'm Warm, Dry, and comfortable. Thank God! Still bewildered by this rating.

Jim

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

"Still working under special accomodation status"

Make sure you tell VA that and supply any documentation of this if you can-

that decision you got is outrageous.

In Voc Rehab my husband needed accomodations to his PTSD which the college gave him-and they documented this.

the VA never considered this as part of his evidence but there was plenty more evidence they had anyhow- still this shows to VA that

you are more disabed than they think.

And a picture of the braces might be worth a thousand words (or more comp)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Berta,

Since you slept on this, you really came up with excellent thoughts. I never considered these factors. The NOD, Pictures w/braces and w-o/braces, and employer's Special Accomodation document should make a good point. My VSO can carry it to the RO and place it in his hands. We'll do it! P.S. I did file for clothing allowance due to the wear and tear the braces have on my trousers.

Thanks for your message,

Jim

NEW WORLD DICITIONARY. Second College Edition.

"Outrageous"

1. having the nature of, involving, or doing great injury or wrong.

2. exceeding all bounds of decency or reasonableness; very offensive or shocking.

3. violent in action or disposition; unrestrained.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Today I sent a NOD for the 10% OA Appeal. Also sent employer's comments regarding accommodations and many pictures. I sent it via my new DAV VSO at St. Pete. Kelly Sunday. This VSO is a real go-getter. I wish I knew the gender but what ever, the e-mailed NOD was forwarded to the Appeals Board. I had to ask the question about how long it would take to get a response. Typically 2-3 years!! The best thing the VA has going for them is ATTRITION!

Last week I sent a Notice of Omission. ED was part 2 of the appeal which was not addressed. ED is a result of years of PTSD meds, trial meds, cocktail meds, and routine anxiety/depression/insomnia meds. Word of advice, check the side effects of your meds, do your refills on time and be careful. The side effects may be causing your symptoms! ED is a real slam to the morale. Feb. 18, 2008 we will celebrate our 41st anniversary. She is a wonderful, faithful wife who honors the Oaths we took before God and witnesses. She is one in a million.

If anyone has a success story regarding ED please let me know.

Warm FL Regards, Jim

Old 5311

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yesterday a fairly large direct deposit from the VA was discovered in my CU account. Nice surprise, but I don't know what it was for. I've akked my VSO and waiting for a reply. Do you think a letter will come soon explaining it? It could be an error.

Thanks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

OLD5311: I think the Department of Veterans Affairs realized there Mistake and corrected it.....Hopefully....Good Luck. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

WOW!!!! all you can do is sit tight- this happened to me and I called VA many times as to what the heck one check was for-a biggy and no letter until a few days later-

Then again you got one of the most BIZARRE award letters for the 10% that I had ever seen!

I hope they acted on your TDIU and maybe that is what the $$$ is for-

you could play around with the VA Comp schedule and the date of month you filed the claim- use date of next month-

and see if something fits in to the amount (add your dependents too- OR just sit back and say WHEW and take the family out for a special dinner and wait for the letter -which is SOOOOOOO hard to do when one gets a big VA check)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am at 40% and in a similar boat with the arthritis but have not worked since 2004. I just yesterday got a SSOC and it stated continued denial of TDIU but made a point of mentioning the record of "severe debilitating arthritis." My ankles, knees hips and back are a mess with neuoropathy too.

I am connected for ankle injury and flat feet so I think they're telling me that if I can convince them my arthritis is service connected, I'll get it. I could then claim the side effects of the heavy meds (methadone for pain) I'm on too.

Can I ask how you got connected for arthritis???

I have scrounged a couple medical studies referring to it but I'm thin on the ground there. My sole provider is the VA and my Dr. there is good to me and conscientious as far as patient care goes, but he won't stretch far enough to flat say my arthritis is caused by my service connected conditions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

JQ, if you have a "record of severe debillitating arthritis", to what do they attribute that?

Have they said?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JQ, if you have a "record of severe debillitating arthritis", to what do they attribute that?

Have they said?

Yeah, I'd be interested to know the answer to this question also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
JQ, if you have a "record of severe debillitating arthritis", to what do they attribute that?

Have they said?

No. No comment as to cause at all.

I see my Dr. next week and am going to try and get him to put it in his progress notes.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Chuck75 and Berta,

Thanks for the replies. You are exactly right all those add up to 10%. I did get a Statement Of Claim, but do not know about a bilateral factor. I could get 20% if a group of joints were affected. You are right I got low-balled. I have deformity and have lost 2" of height. Also wearing VA issue braces on the legs. Two VA doctors knew my condition was SC and made the notes. They gave the civilian doctors statements credibility. My employer has given me Special Accomodation so I'm thankful for that.

Regards "Old 5311"

Hey Old 5311,

You might want to ask some of these guys about VA math. Don't quote me because I am not an expert, but I think using VA math you might be rated 70% schedular. Also, as they said earlier, you might get TDIU, or even SMC at some rate since you said you have major mobility issues. Berta and Pete probably know the most about that. OH,,,there's always Tincanman, Cantamont, Rick or well, you get the point. Good luck.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You need MS spread sheet but you do the math list disabilties High % to lowest %

VA_Calculator.xls

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

71.75%sc=70%sc

Lookslike some one type in 10%. made a one to a seven.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

71.75%sc=70%sc

Looks like some one type in 10%. made a seven to a one mistake.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The VA just determined the following conditions are related to my military service, so connection has been granted:

Degenerative joint disease cervical spine, assigned 10%.

Degenerative joint disease, lumbar spine, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Shoulder, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Hip, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right Wrist, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Left knee, assigned 10%.

Osteoarthritis, Right knee, assigned 10%.

TOTAL 10%

Can this possibly be correct? I am crippled, and have continuous pain, even lying down. I cannot stand, walk or take stairs. The VA knows all this.

My hunch is they are waiting on attrition!

Someone please explain this decision to me or advise.

Thank You.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

i would raise hell.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now