Jump to content


  • veteranscrisisline-badge-chat-1.gif

  • Donation Box

    Please donate to support the community.
    We appreciate all donations!
  • Advertisemnt

  • 14 Questions about VA Disability Compensation Benefits Claims


    When a Veteran starts considering whether or not to file a VA Disability Claim, there are a lot of questions that he or she tends to ask. Over the last 10 years, the following are the 14 most common basic questions I am asked about ...
    Continue Reading
  • Ads

  • Most Common VA Disabilities Claimed for Compensation:   


  • Advertisemnt

  • VA Watchdog

  • Advertisemnt

  • Ads

  • Can a 100 percent Disabled Veteran Work and Earn an Income?

    employment 2.jpeg

    You’ve just been rated 100% disabled by the Veterans Affairs. After the excitement of finally having the rating you deserve wears off, you start asking questions. One of the first questions that you might ask is this: It’s a legitimate question – rare is the Veteran that finds themselves sitting on the couch eating bon-bons … Continue reading

  • 0
Sign in to follow this  

ptsd SMC-S, Filing Procedure, and Back Pay


100% p&t, since 2012... (ptsd)... I want to file for smc-s, but frankly, cant remember how to get the ball rolling... My c&p exam in 2011, clearly stated agoraphobia...Any suggestions, would be appreciated..Also, when approved, do you believe  retro will go back to 2012.. Thank you all, again, for your input, and advice... 


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Recommended Posts

  • 0

Someone at YUKU VBN gave the M21-1MR reference and some legal citations:

If your buddy was diagnosed with PTSD with acute agoraphobia (if that's the case) it's reasonable to argue that SMC-S may be inferred and therefore should have been awarded.

M21-1MR, Part III, Subpart iv, Chapter 6, Section B, 3,d Considering Subordinate Issues and Ancilliary Benefits
"IF a single 100 percent evaluation is assigned in a compensation or pension case, and A&A is not payable THEN ADDRESS ENTITLEMENT TO … Housebound Note: Do not address Housebound if the evidence does not show entitlement exists"

Sometimes raters either seem to skip this step or feel a high threshold exists for the evidence required.

Many vets have successfully responded with a NOD or request for reconsideration, but this would have to be done within the 12 month appeal period, best accompanied with new treatment notes or an outside medical opinion stating the vet is substantially and permanently confined to their home due to their service connected disability.

For purposes of housebound benefits, the Court has held that
being "substantially confined" to the home means an inability
to leave to earn an income. Absent a regulation by the Secretary
defining the term "substantially confined," the Court held that
the term may conceivably be more broadly construed. It found
that Congress intended to provide additional compensation for
Veterans who were unable to overcome their particular
disabilities and leave the house in order to earn an income, as
opposed to an inability to leave the house at all. Hartness v.
Nicholson, 20 Vet. App. 216, 220-22 (2006); cf. Howell v.
Nicholson, 19 Vet. App. 535, 540 (2006)

As Rotor points out, filing a new claim may be successful, but will also raise the possibility of a reduction. When dealing with someone with severe PTSD, it's important not to underestimate the potential adverse mental and physical effects from the stress and uncertainty of a long claims process.


I won a SMC CUE but it involved 100% plus 60% yet my long decision (this was part of my Nehmer AO IHD death claim) yet the VA also awarded based on Housebound too but paid only for one SMC S which is correct.

The rating sheet ( a 1998 decision) contained the 100% plus 60 % rating evidence but the veteran was clearly housebound as well.

When I filed the CUE and sent in additional evidence, I worded the CUE for "lack of consideration"of the SMC regulations.My additional evidence had been established and was in V's possession at time of the CUed decision.

BTW-I don't quite agree with what "Rotor" said because if we all feared reductions we would never get what we deserve.

 "My c&p exam in 2011, clearly stated agoraphobia...Any suggestions, would be appreciated..Also, when approved, do you believe  retro will go back to 2012.."

The C & P exam was in VA's possession when they made the decision.

If the agoraphobia was at a ratable level in 2011, then it appears they made a CUE, and if they grant CUE it should go back to the 2012 decision. 

I am not sure if the VA will consider the C & P statement as a diagnosis.But it is worth trying to get SMC S.

The VA is mandated to infer SMC consideration in every case that warrants it by established medical evidence.








  • Like 1

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

To add: 


This is an agoraphobia BVA award and reveals the rating schedule for agoraphobia:



Entitlement to a rating of 50 percent, and no greater, for agoraphobia prior to May 2, 2008 is granted. “


This was not a HB award however, because the veteran’s TDIU claim was not decided yet.

It shows how the veteran got to 50% for agoraphobia.

Also you could formally claim it but I could not find any specific form for HB.If the VA awards the claim, then it would not be too difficult to raise CUE at that point ,it is would warrant more retro.

I cant copy and paste from my M21-1MR,but you can google this:

M21-1MR ,Part III,Subpart IV,Chapter 6,Section B

For more info on what is an inferred issue.

Regarding the VA HB award statement in my Nehmer decision...that resolved my 2 CUE claims regarding SMC, .that was based on extensive documented evidence that my husband was housebound at time of the 1998 decision I CUed. I guess this is why they awarded the SMC CUE both ways.

Was there any other documented evidence in your VA med recs that would support the CUE for lack of HB consideration that indicates you are HB due to the agoraphobia?


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Thanks, Berta, for all, your input..To answer your question, ,... I don't if any other documentation exists in my records, claiming reference to agoraphobia, or housebound...The only thing I know for certain is, rating sheet  clearly stated diagnosis of ptsd, panic disorder w/ agoraphobia, major depressive disorder, severe...The va examiner noted you have total social, and occupupational impairment....               So that's all the evidence i have, for CUE, that smc-s, should have been inferred...after reading other posts, don't know if its enough, but i think I'm gonna try...Thanks, again...

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

This clarifies everything :

"The only thing I know for certain is, rating sheet  clearly stated diagnosis of ptsd, panic disorder w/ agoraphobia, major depressive disorder, severe...The va examiner noted you have total social, and occupupational impairment... "

It looks to me that they included the agoraphobia within the 100% rating.I have seen that done before.

That is not a CUE.

The VA will only award one MH disability.

You can certainly claim it causes you to be Housebound, but with the 'rating sheet" statement above,I think the C & P examiner based that on symptoms you relayed to him/her

and it might be possible to get the HB award but you would need more evidence for it than what appears to already be considered by VA in the 100% rating.

This is the DBQ for both A & A and HB exams:


In this recent BVA case the veteran was found to be Housebound:


The BVA's explanation is this:

"In weighing the evidence the Board observes that the evidentiary information provided in October 2013 by Dr. D. S. as well as by the VA examinations addressed primarily the impact of the Veteran's service-connected disabilities with respect to the Veteran's ability to work. However, in the context of entitlement to SMC based on HB the essential matter is not the impact on the Veteran' ability to work but whether the Veteran is substantially confined to his premises. As to this, the Board observes that the June 2011 VA examination noted that the Veteran was not able to prepare his own meals and needed assistance in bathing and tending to other hygiene needs. Crucially, it was reported that he seldom left his own home and could only walk for less than one block. Dr. D.S. also maintained that the Veteran experienced pain that was intractable and virtually incapacitating. Physical activity, e.g., walking, standing, bending, stooping, and moving his extremities increased his pain to the extent that bed rest was necessary. From the foregoing, and after giving due consideration to the favorable resolution of doubt under 38 U.S.C.A. § 5107(b) and 38 C.F.R. § 3.102, the Board concludes that after May 1, 2011, the Veteran was so functionally impaired as to be substantially confined to his immediate premises due to his service-connected disabilities which remained throughout the Veteran's lifetime."

For my SMC Cue I proved the 100% plus 60% error ( My Husband was at that time 100% SC P & T plus 100% SC 1151 P & T ,as CUE but bolstered my CUE with significant medical evidence (in VA's possession at time of the 1998 CUE) that the veteran was also housebound.

Although he was 100% P & T for PTSD I could not rely on that, but could reply on his 1151 stroke (100% P & T)

BTW all, I am in the midst of my latest battle-3 CUE claims sent last week regarding the 100% P & T under 1151, who the director of my VARO (by ignoring my evidence AGAIN, insisted to me by phone,that their prior rating did NOT mean the veteran was 100% Permanent due to stroke under 1151 when he died.But that he was totally disabled by it.

I have 13 pieces of evidence ( one from a former VA Secretary) that says he was 100% P & T due to the 1151 stroke and three other VA doctors stated that as well.... at a C & P, plus his VOC rehab records, and his student loan waiver was signed by a VA doctor who also clicked on the P & T box on the form.

VA has to cough up their proof of their  "cure" for his 1151 Totally and Permanently disabled stroke- a cure that they never told the veteran about and caused the 1151 stroke in the first place so you would think they would gladly have let us know in the veteran's lifetime that his continuously totally disabled and permanent stroke , had in fact been " cured" because their recent HBP CUE award and that evidence ( From VACO -FTCA case)proves that VA did nothing at all to alter their medical errors to prevent the stroke, and covered up additional malpractice on the stroke and his AO IHD DMII and heart disease.

If you die with a continuous  total SC disability, and VA has not performed a miraculous cure for it, you have also died with a Permanent and Total SC  disability , because it Lasted your Lifetime.

I have never ever seen any decision at the BVA or elsewhere that ever has changed that established medical fact.

This is why you all need to get the spouse up to speed.

If a vet dies with a 100% P & T rating that has lasted ten years, can the VA say to his widow yeah he died with a 100% P & T total rating but it wasn't really permanent when he died.So No DIC for you.

If you die with a 100% P & T rating less than 10 years that VA continually ignores the evidence for, and says it was Total but Not Permanent, is you spouse fully prepared for that ridiculous battle over any accrued amount or potential DIC when you die?






Death makes a standing 100% award Permanent at death.


Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Thx, again, berta...I value your opinion, and after reading your last reply, i guess I should forget about a cue, for smc-s...if you don't think its warranted, I'm not gonna drive myself nuts, pursuing it.. maybe, start a new claim, for smc-s, but no cue... appreciate, greatly, your help, and advice, with this matter...

Share this post

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

  • Similar Content

    • By Ztmiller8
      Finally heard back that I received my 100% Overall rating and a 100% PTSD rating Following my long appeal process!
      My question is this, given the fact that my appeal was on the advanced docket and is an “Expedited” appeal, what happens now and how long(ish) is the process from here on out with retro and so forth? I’ve read a million things but nothing with an expedited appeal status.
      Anyone deal with this situation before? My jump is from 50 to 100 over the course of 2 years if that helps some. I only am asking because as happy as I am, I would be much happier to pay some of these bills off!
    • By Lizette
      I received my rating for PTSD in 2017.  I recently got a call to schedule an evaluation for PTSD.  I'm assuming they're checking to see if my symptoms have gotten any better.  Is there anything I need and/or should do to prepare for this (ie documentation).  I get so uncomfortable having to talk about things to a stranger.
    • By MarineLCpl
      At the end of June, I noticed a claim had been opened for my SC’d PTSD, currently rated at 70%. 
      Little background, I was rated at 70% for Major Depression back in 2010. I filed for TDIU and it was granted later that year. The VA re-examined the Major Depression in 2015. They changed my diagnosis to PTSD with Major Depression, but continued the 70% rating. IU remained intact. 
      Fast forward to present day, the VA decided to reevaluate the PTSD (just shy of 5 years since my last C&P). I attended an exam, it went well. Doc was nice and made me feel comfortable, which was a relief because I hate going to those things. 
      I received my packet yesterday with a decision. The C&P exam showed my symptoms had gotten worse, but not enough to warrant an increase. They continued my 70% rating and kept the IU intact. 
      Here’s what did change: it states that I now qualify for basic eligibility to Ch. 35 benefits due to my disability being considered permanent and total. I was under the impression that you needed to be rated 100% scheduler to qualify for this, but apparently they consider TDIU P&T equivalent to the 100% scheduler rating in this regard. I did not know this and thought TDIU simply “paid the same rate as 100%.” 
      There was no information regarding the need for future exams. In the past, there was always a closing sentence that stated I could be re-examined. Since they changed my status to P&T, does this negate the need for reexaminations in regards to the PTSD? Just not totally sure how this works. What I do understand is that if I opened a new claim or filed for an increase, a C&P would surely follow of course. 
      Here’s another area that makes me uneasy. I have held off on filing secondary claims related to the PTSD, such as ED and IBS. I’ve also considered filing for tinnitus. But something tells me that I may be asking for trouble if I do so. Some have told me that because I’ve been granted 100% TDIU P&T that I shouldn’t worry about filing new claims in hopes of reaching scheduler status. These opinions are mixed, some say go for it, others say “don’t push it.”
      While they are valid claims, not sure what I should do. The only benefit I see to scheduler, aside from dental, is that I could “work” with no income barriers and not have to worry about risking my benefits if I make too much. Currently, the little work I do is hobby- based and only nets a few thousand dollars a year. I file taxes every year showing this income. BUT, I do have ambitions toward expanding this into a small operation someday to earn a little extra income for an IRA. Retirement is one of my biggest fears. But at the same time, I don’t expect to be making anything beyond marginal income in this lifetime, regardless of an expansion. 
      So much to think about...I suppose I should be grateful I’ve made it this far...I wish I could say my doubts, fears, etc have dwindled, but unfortunately, I feel no different. As we all know, the VA plays by their own rules after all. 
      I WOULD like to say thank you to all those that helped me reach this point. I try to help others on this site as a way of giving back. This community has been a godsend to me for many years. 

      God Bless, 

    • By Wise Guy
      One of my friends been out the military for 6 years. However, he needs to file for MST. He doesn't have any evidence in his records (No police records, investigations, statements, or anything) of MST but to my knowledge, a bill was passed that says we no longer need evidence. I could be wrong so please correct me if I am. Here are my questions below:
      1. Does he need buddy statements from friends he served with to get it connected to service?
      2. Does he need to provide a name of the person that sexually assaulted him?
      3. Does he need a phycologist nexus outside the VA of all his symptoms with the verbiage, "It is in my professional opinion that, his PTSD was caused by Military Sexual Trauma. Additionally, it is more likely than not that his PTSD, severe is connected to his time in service."
      "After reviewing patients buddy statements and having 2 sessions with him, it is in my professional opinion that, it is more likely than not that his PTSD, severe was caused by Military Sexual Trauma. Additionally, it is in my professional opinion that, it is more likely than not that his PTSD, severe is connected to his time in service"?
      If he does need a nexus, which verbiage above sounds better than the other or what sounds better in general? I want him to get this right the first time. 
    • By XIbodybag
      Good morning hadit,
      I have both ptsd and TBI and believe my diagnosed sleep apnea (mixed sleep apnea, with both central and obstructive sleep apnea) has been directly caused by my ptsd and TBI.  I am not overweight, have no medical issues of the throat or the respiratory system that would cause it.  My question to you all is if I want to file sleep apnea secondary to either of this conditions which one should i file it secondary to?  I've found much more literature tying obstructive sleep apnea to ptsd but also found literature that ties both obstructive sleep apnea and central sleep apnea to brain injuries as well.  Is it possible to file it secondary to both?
  • Ads

  • Our picks

    • I told reviewer that I had a bad C&P, and that all I wanted was a fair shake, and she even said, that was what she was all ready viewed for herself. The first C&P don't even  reflect my Treatment in the VA PTSD clinic. In my new C&P I was only asked about symptoms, seeing shit, rituals, nightmares, paying bills and about childhood, but didn't ask about details of it. Just about twenty question, and  nothing about stressor,
    • This is the latest Compensation & Pension (C&P) Clinicians Guide dated 20180719. The only other one I've seen is dated 2002, including the one on this website and the VA website. I got this from my claims agent, who got it from the VA.

      VA Compensation & Pension (C&P) Clinicians Guide 2 Final Corrected 20180719.pdf
      • 5 replies
    • I don’t say thank you enough to all of you...
      You, yes you, are the reason HadIt.com has remained a resource-rich resource. Thousands come each month to read, ask questions, or to feel a sense of community.

      Last month June 2020, we over 50k visitors they viewed over 160k pages. Veterans and their advocates, spouses, children, and friends of veterans come looking for answers. Because we have posts dating back 15 years and articles on the home page, they usually can find an answer or at least get pointed in the right direction.

      You all made that possible. Thank you.
      • 3 replies
    • Help HadIt.com stay online buy a subscription
      If you can afford it and want to help hadit.com consider buying a subscription this gives you as free viewing of the site and allows me to budget in subscription payments.

      You can try it for 1 month for $5 or get a monthly subscription or a yearly subscription.

      Subscribe here https://community.hadit.com/subscriptions/
      • 4 replies
    • VA has a special where we can ask questions TODAY, at 3:00 to "people that matter?"  Someone should ask why we can not ask them questions EVERY day, why today only? (This is a big problem with VA..the 800 number often does not give specific answers).  We should have people in VA who "solve Vets problems" like Allison Hickey did a few years ago. 
      • 8 replies
  • Ads

  • Popular Contributors

  • Ad

  • Latest News
  • Create New...

Important Information

{terms] and Guidelines