Cue "one Shot"

[broncovet]

This time, I know where I read it..it is from Jim Strickland, and it is here:

http://jimstrickland912.com/CUE.html

Earlier I asked about this "one shot" cue, and the general consensus was that it was bunk. (my slang for "bunkum" or "BS").

Still, I do think Jim Strickland is both knowledgeable and credible. So, I will ask again..is Jim Strickland wrong, or are we only allowed one CUE? This is from J.S's "A to Z guide to VA Disability Benefits"

[carlie]

I guess I am, well, in disbelief, that Jim Strickland would publish such an error, because I have found Jim's information to be highly accurate and up to date. I think someone should tell him, because Vets go to his "A to Z Guide" and rely on that to make decisions on their claim. Jim need's to either retract his statement or back up his position with CASE Law, CFR's, M21's, Veterans Benefit Manual, etc.

PS. I am not badmouthing Jim Strickland. He is a volunteer VA advocate who has given hours and hours of his time to help Veterans without compensation (as you have also). However, it appears he simply made a mistake..like all of us do.

bronco,

I agree that the information listed at the link you posted,

contains some statements,that are not completely accurate.

I will leave Jim alone about it though as one day he will

more likely than not clarify the information a bit more.

VA laws and regs are so involved and intricate, that's why

you will hear sooooooo often - the claimant is ultimately

responsible for their own claim and to triple check everything

you hear or read.

C&UE can most definetly be filed on not only the same final Rating Decision

more than once - but even on the same issue contained within the Rating Decision,

more than once, yet another C&UE claim filed under a different legal theory.

As Berta pointed out, when BVA dismisses the C&UE claim without prejudice to refiling.

There are also different theories of legal error - C&UE can be filed under

more than one theory of legal error.

C&UE can be filed on the same final Rating Decision in regards to

percentage granted, effective date granted, etc...

These are all sub-issues of the claims adjudication process and each individual

sub-issue is allowable for a claim of C&UE, as such each one separately

must be very,very specific.

jmho,

carlie