Jump to content

Ask Your VA Claims Questions | Read Current Posts 
Read VA Disability Claims Articles
Search | View All Forums | Donate | Blogs | New Users | Rules 

  • tbirds-va-claims-struggle (1).png

  • 01-2024-stay-online-donate-banner.png

     

  • 0

Proof Of Stressor

Rate this question


MikeS

Question

Hi all:

I met a fellow vet at the va who was denied his first claim because their was no proff of a stressor.

He said the stressor was civilian casualties in viet nam.

He said that he was discharged honorably "for the convenience of the government" because his behavior had changed drastically after his return to his stateside base.

He also said that stomache pains and sleeplessness were documented after his return from nam.

What would be a good way for him to continue to fight his claim even though there is no record of those civilian deaths that he thinks about every day and dreams about almost every night.

Please help. This veteran is on the verge of accepting the va's denial.

Thanks,

Mike S.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Answers 10
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters For This Question

Top Posters For This Question

Recommended Posts

Guest DON20906

What was his MOS?

Hi all:

I met a fellow vet at the va who was denied his first claim because their was no proff of a stressor.

He said the stressor was civilian casualties in viet nam.

He said that he was discharged honorably "for the convenience of the government" because his behavior had changed drastically after his return to his stateside base.

He also said that stomache pains and sleeplessness were documented after his return from nam.

What would be a good way for him to continue to fight his claim even though there is no record of those civilian deaths that he thinks about every day and dreams about almost every night.

Please help. This veteran is on the verge of accepting the va's denial.

Thanks,

Mike S.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Was he in support of the ops that caused the civilian casualties?

Did he witness any American casualties-or the operation that caused what he saw?

Was this an event that caused accidental deaths of civilians?There could perhaps be a newspaper article somewhere-

If he tries to find his unit on the web perhaps he could get a buddy statement-

Does he remember the name of the town or vill where this occurred?

I worked at a Vet Center as a volunteer (PTSD Combat Rap Group)and have talked to many manyNam vets over the last 20 years-

I think there is much more to his stressor situation than he wants to reveal.

He should certainly file a claim, not only for PTSD but also for the other conditions.

The drastic change in his behavior should be found in his SMRs,which he should get too-

Also on the SF 180 I think he should ask for his service personnel records too and anything (like Article 15s, Capt Mass stuff) that he might have gotten whch would show inservice trauma.

GRADUATE ! Nov 2nd 2007 American Military University !

When thousands of Americans faced annihilation in the 1800s Chief

Osceola's response to his people, the Seminoles, was

simply "They(the US Army)have guns, but so do we."

Sameo to us -They (VA) have 38 CFR ,38 USC, and M21-1- but so do we.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • HadIt.com Elder

I would bet that his best bet is to find someone who witnessed the event. Its my opinion that unless the soldier falls into the category of someone that VA will accept their testimony its a lot easier to pursue a secondary claim such as Depression as almost everyone who has PTSD has Depression or Panic Disorder also.

Veterans deserve real choice for their health care.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • HadIt.com Elder
I would bet that his best bet is to find someone who witnessed the event. Its my opinion that unless the soldier falls into the category of someone that VA will accept their testimony its a lot easier to pursue a secondary claim such as Depression as almost everyone who has PTSD has Depression or Panic Disorder also.

I agree with Pete.

If symptoms were noted in SMR as "stomach pains and sleeplessness", and the veteran can show being treated over the years for psychosomatic symptomology, he could show a "disease or injury [mental disorder] resulting in disability was incurred coincident with service in the Armed Forces, or if preexisting such service, was aggravated therein".

At some point in time, he would need to have the disease or injury properly/medically diagnosed. Proving stressor for PTSD under these circumstances might be more difficult (but do-able), than showing evidence of another or additional mental disorder. BTW, This could be accomplished through an independent medical examination!

Specifically, C.F.R. Sec. 3.303(b) Chronicity and continuity. With chronic disease shown as such in service ... so as to permit a finding of service connection, subsequent manifestations of the same chronic disease at any later date, however remote, are service connected, unless clearly attributable to intercurrent causes. ... When the [chronic] disease identity is established (leprosy, tuberculosis, multiple sclerosis, etc.), there is no requirement of evidentiary showing of continuity. Continuity of symptomatology is required only where the condition noted during service (or in the presumptive period) is not, in fact, shown to be chronic or where the diagnosis of chronicity may be legitimately questioned. When the fact of chronicity in service is not adequately supported, then a showing of continuity after discharge is required to support the claim.

My 2 cents! ~Wings

USAF 1980-1986, 70% SC PTSD, 100% TDIU (P&T)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • HadIt.com Elder

Wings

I would agree with you and Pete on this 100%. If the vet has SMR's with depression symptoms they that would be much easier than a PTSD claim years later with having to prove a stressor. Unless the soldier was in combat and has proof via a combat badge or medal those PTSD claims are not easy. You know that when you claim PTSD the VA is ready for you. When I went for my depression C&P the shrink assumed PTSD and I had to straighten him out on that right away. I did not need to prove something that was already in my records.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi all:

The veteran was in the air force but was sent into the field at An Loc during the Easter Offensive of 1972.

He said that he witnessed a surprise attack on three female (vc ???) by the army sgt who was interrogating them.

This sgt shot and killed all three females.

Neither he or I can find anything on the record.

All we can find is in-service behavior and physical problems and article 15 and a shrink diagnosis of "social disorder" and "personality disorder". All were documented in nam and 9 months later at a stateside air base.

VA docs here say he has ptsd and major depressive disorder stemming from nam.

That's all I know for know.

Does this further info make any sense for an NOD???

Thanks,

Mike S.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Tell a friend

    Love HadIt.com’s VA Disability Community Vets helping Vets since 1997? Tell a friend!
  • Recent Achievements

    • spazbototto earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Paul Gretza earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • Troy Spurlock went up a rank
      Community Regular
    • KMac1181 earned a badge
      Week One Done
    • jERRYMCK earned a badge
      Week One Done
  • Our picks

    • I met with a VSO today at my VA Hospital who was very knowledgeable and very helpful.  We decided I should submit a few new claims which we did.  He told me that he didn't need copies of my military records that showed my sick call notations related to any of the claims.  He said that the VA now has entire military medical record on file and would find the record(s) in their own file.  It seemed odd to me as my service dates back to  1981 and spans 34 years through my retirement in 2015.  It sure seemed to make more sense for me to give him copies of my military medical record pages that document the injuries as I'd already had them with me.  He didn't want my copies.  Anyone have any information on this.  Much thanks in advance.  
      • 4 replies
    • Caluza Triangle defines what is necessary for service connection
      Caluza Triangle – Caluza vs Brown defined what is necessary for service connection. See COVA– CALUZA V. BROWN–TOTAL RECALL

      This has to be MEDICALLY Documented in your records:

      Current Diagnosis.   (No diagnosis, no Service Connection.)

      In-Service Event or Aggravation.
      Nexus (link- cause and effect- connection) or Doctor’s Statement close to: “The Veteran’s (current diagnosis) is at least as likely due to x Event in military service”
      • 0 replies
    • Do the sct codes help or hurt my disability rating 
    • VA has gotten away with (mis) interpreting their  ambigious, , vague regulations, then enforcing them willy nilly never in Veterans favor.  

      They justify all this to congress by calling themselves a "pro claimant Veteran friendly organization" who grants the benefit of the doubt to Veterans.  

      This is not true, 

      Proof:  

          About 80-90 percent of Veterans are initially denied by VA, pushing us into a massive backlog of appeals, or worse, sending impoverished Veterans "to the homeless streets" because  when they cant work, they can not keep their home.  I was one of those Veterans who they denied for a bogus reason:  "Its been too long since military service".  This is bogus because its not one of the criteria for service connection, but simply made up by VA.  And, I was a homeless Vet, albeit a short time,  mostly due to the kindness of strangers and friends. 

          Hadit would not be necessary if, indeed, VA gave Veterans the benefit of the doubt, and processed our claims efficiently and paid us promptly.  The VA is broken. 

          A huge percentage (nearly 100 percent) of Veterans who do get 100 percent, do so only after lengthy appeals.  I have answered questions for thousands of Veterans, and can only name ONE person who got their benefits correct on the first Regional Office decision.  All of the rest of us pretty much had lengthy frustrating appeals, mostly having to appeal multiple multiple times like I did. 

          I wish I know how VA gets away with lying to congress about how "VA is a claimant friendly system, where the Veteran is given the benefit of the doubt".   Then how come so many Veterans are homeless, and how come 22 Veterans take their life each day?  Va likes to blame the Veterans, not their system.   
    • Welcome to hadit!  

          There are certain rules about community care reimbursement, and I have no idea if you met them or not.  Try reading this:

      https://www.va.gov/resources/getting-emergency-care-at-non-va-facilities/

         However, (and I have no idea of knowing whether or not you would likely succeed) Im unsure of why you seem to be so adamant against getting an increase in disability compensation.  

         When I buy stuff, say at Kroger, or pay bills, I have never had anyone say, "Wait!  Is this money from disability compensation, or did you earn it working at a regular job?"  Not once.  Thus, if you did get an increase, likely you would have no trouble paying this with the increase compensation.  

          However, there are many false rumors out there that suggest if you apply for an increase, the VA will reduce your benefits instead.  

      That rumor is false but I do hear people tell Veterans that a lot.  There are strict rules VA has to reduce you and, NOT ONE of those rules have anything to do with applying for an increase.  

      Yes, the VA can reduce your benefits, but generally only when your condition has "actually improved" under ordinary conditions of life.  

          Unless you contacted the VA within 72 hours of your medical treatment, you may not be eligible for reimbursement, or at least that is how I read the link, I posted above. Here are SOME of the rules the VA must comply with in order to reduce your compensation benefits:

      https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/38/3.344

       
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

Guidelines and Terms of Use